22 March 2022

Selected Republicans And Republican Candidates For Office

* This is a sitting Republican U.S. Senator from Indiana:
U.S. Sen. Mike Braun: SCOTUS should leave abortion, interracial marriage to states.
(Source NPR affiliate WFYI of Indianapolis). Note also that U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas is in an interracial marriage.

* At least four notable GOP candidates this election cycle have horrific histories of domestic violence.
Missouri's US Senate hopeful Eric Greitens . . . had to resign as governor after a woman accused him of tying her up and taking her photograph as potential blackmail material if she told anyone about their affair. But the AP got its hands on an affidavit filed by Greitens's ex-wife Sheena Greitens in the custody dispute over their two children, and it is really, really ugly.

Prof. Greitens, a China expert who relocated to Austin where she teaches at the University of Texas, did manage to extricate herself and her children from the marriage. But now her ex-husband is seeking custody of the children, and she's alleging a shocking pattern of abuse at the end of their relationship.

“Prior to our divorce, during an argument in late April 2018, Eric knocked me down and confiscated my cell phone, wallet and keys so that I was unable to call for help or extricate myself and our children from our home,” she wrote. “I became afraid for my safety and that of our children at our home.”

She went on to describe “behavior [that] included physical violence toward our children, such as cuffing our then-3-year-old son across the face at the dinner table in front of me and yanking him around by his hair.”

For the record, Greitens denies the allegations.

“His ex-wife is engaged in a last-ditch attempt to vindictively destroy her ex-husband,” the candidate's spokesman Dylan Johnson told the AP. “Eric has always been a great Dad, who loves his boys and has always put them first, and that is why he is filing for full custody of his children.”

Prof. Greitens describes the ex-governor as becoming mentally unstable as his political fortunes unraveled, threatening to harm himself if she didn't publicly support him and implying that he might hurt the children if she didn't do what he asked. 
At one point, Eric Greitens made a reference to the fact that he had the children — and she didn’t — while trying to persuade Sheena Greitens to delete emails she had sent to the family therapist seeking help, according to the affidavit.

“Eric threatened to accuse me of child abuse if I did not delete the emails and convince the therapist to delete them,” she wrote.
The professor also describes her ex-husband hiding a gun in the house, so that “multiple people other than myself were worried enough to intervene to limit Eric’s access to firearms.”
Senate candidate Sean Parnell dropped out of the race in Pennsylvania in November after similar allegations of spousal and child abuse by his ex-wife. Not to be confused with Herschel Walker in Georgia, whose ex-wife alleged pervasive abuse during their marriage, including having him hold a gun to her head and threatening to "blow her fucking brains out." Or Max Miller, a congressional candidate in Ohio, who White House comms flack Stephanie Grisham alleges abused her during their relationship.

From Wonkette (if you don't trust it, click through to the sources linked).

* Trump's former chief of staff appears to have engaged in voter registration fraud. "North Carolina state investigators have launched an investigation into Mark Meadows’ voter registration after reports raised questions about the former White House chief of staff’s status." He appears to have engaged in voter registration fraud.

* Mesa County, Colorado Clerk Tina Peters, who is a Republican candidate for Secretary of State (the chief elections officer in Colorado), and her Deputy County Clerk Belinda Knisley, have been indicted (in charges brought by Mesa County's Republican District Attorney) of multiple counts of election administration related crimes. Peters also faces contempt of court charges for violating a court order and then  lying to a judge about it, in a related proceeding. She has a decent chance of becoming the GOP nominee for Secretary of State in Colorado (More details here). The same source notes that:
Another Colorado clerk — Dallas Schroeder of Elbert County — has also admitted to making two copies of his county’s voting system hard drive. Schroeder said he gave one copy to his own attorney and another to an unidentified “private attorney.” 
Griswold filed a lawsuit in February to force Schroeder to name the private attorney, retrieve the copies of the hard drives and provide copies of communications with non-county employees who assisted Schroeder in making the copies. She argued that Schroeder’s behavior had created “an ongoing risk that the copies of the voting system ... are being exploited by unknown actors to uncover system vulnerabilities that might be used to undermine voters’ confidence in Colorado’s secure elections.” 
In court documents, Schroeder’s lawyer has said that he believes his actions were “authorized by law and appropriate under the circumstances to preserve election records of the November 2020 election.”

* A conservative and Republican led school board majority in Douglas County, Colorado, an affluent and conservative exurb of Denver, has been placed under a preliminary injunction for conduct violating the state's open meetings law. 

* Then there is this guy: "Michigan GOP candidate says he tells daughters to ‘lie back and enjoy it’ if rape is inevitable. Robert Regan, a Republican favored to win a seat in the Michigan House, made the comments while trying to make an analogy about abandoning efforts to decertify the 2020 election."

* Colorado's representative in Congress from the 3rd Congressional District (mostly representing Colorado's Western Slope) "Lauren Boebert says, like Ukraine, Canada and U.S. ‘need freedom and need to be liberated’" She didn't get a high school diploma and earned her GED a month before the 2020 primary. She and her husband both have minor criminal records. She disgraced Colorado with disorderly conduct during the State of the Union speech this year. She has been fined for violating U.S. House rules like a ban on carrying firearms on the floor of the U.S. House and not wearing masks on the U.S. House floor. The list of her infamous acts could continue for a long time and include some probably collusive acts with the January 6 capitol rioters (more than 700 of whom are now facing criminal charges). She makes up fake military ranks (note that she votes on the U.S. Defense Budget).

* A former Presidential candidate for the Republican Party despairs that: "'I've got morons on my team': Romney blasts fellow GOP members for attending White nationalist event and supporting Putin":
Republican Sen. Mitt Romney of Utah on Sunday blasted his fellow GOP members who attended a White nationalist event and those who support Russia President Vladimir Putin as the country invades Ukraine. 
"Look, there is no place in either political party for this White nationalism or racism. It's simply wrong ... it's evil as well," Romney told CNN's Dana Bash on "State of the Union." "(Rep.) Marjorie Taylor Greene and (Rep.) Paul Gosar, I don't know them, but I'm reminded of that old line from the 'Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid' movie where - where one character says, 'Morons, I've got morons on my team.' And I have to think anybody that would sit down with White nationalists and speak at their conference was certainly missing a few IQ points." 
The comment from Romney follows criticism from Wyoming Rep. Liz Cheney, a Republican, of Reps. Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia and Paul Gosar of Arizona for speaking at the America First Political Action Conference that took place in Orlando, Florida and was organized by White nationalist Nick Fuentes. Illinois Rep. Adam Kinzinger, also a Republican, criticized Greene and Gosar. Greene spoke at the event in person and Gosar, who attended the same conference last year, appeared through pre-recorded remarks.

"As Rep Marjorie Taylor Greene and Rep Paul Gosar speak at this white supremacist, anti-Semitic, pro-Putin event, silence by Republican Party leaders is deafening and enabling," Cheney tweeted Saturday. "All Americans should renounce this garbage and reject the Putin wing of the GOP now."

Marjorie Taylor Greene was in concert with Lauren Boebert in their State of the Union mischief and has, if I recall correctly, been censured by the U.S. House for violent threats directed at other U.S. House members.

* In El Paso County, Colorado, first-term incumbent GOP Rep. Mary Bradfield representing southeastern Colorado Springs"narrowly missed making this year’s Republican primary ballot, losing at the GOP assembly on Saturday to an intra party challenger [Karl Dent] who was convicted in August of felony trespassing and who currently faces misdemeanor charges including allegedly violating a protection order. . . . In addition to the less than a year old felony conviction for trespassing, Dent is also reportedly facing misdemeanor animal cruelty charges, and yet another charge for violating a protection order granted to an ex-girlfriend."

* And to close today's selective recount, here's a reminder that criminal activity by politicians is not a bipartisan matter, in which both major parties are equivalent:

21 March 2022

U.S. Sentencing Commission Facts

This U.S. Sentencing Commission summary also says a lot about the federal criminal justice system more generally, even though it is out of commission due to vacancies.
The Sourcebook presents information on the 57,287 federal offenders sentenced in FY21 (October 1, 2020 through September 30, 2021)—a sentencing caseload that decreased by more than 7,000 from the previous fiscal year.

* Drug trafficking, immigration, firearms, and fraud crimes together comprised 83% of the federal sentencing caseload in FY21.

* Drug trafficking was the most common federal crime type sentenced, accounting for 31% of the caseload.

* Immigration cases accounted for the next largest group (30%) but decreased by more than one-third from the number of those cases in FY20.

* Methamphetamine continued to be the most common drug type in the federal system, and a steadily growing portion of the drug caseload (up from 31% of drug cases in FY16 to 48% in FY21).

* In FY21, Fentanyl moved into the top five drug types in the federal caseload. The Commission has added it to the Drug Offenses section of the Sourcebook. Methamphetamine trafficking continued to be the most severely punished federal drug crime (90 months).

* Two-thirds (67%) of drug offenders were convicted of an offense carrying a mandatory minimum penalty, holding steady from the previous year.

* 69% of federal offenders were sentenced under the Guidelines Manual (either within range or outside the range for departure reasons in the manual).

* The Annual Report presents an overview of the Commission's work in FY21.
Beginning in FY21 and continuing into FY22, the Commission has operated with only one voting commissioner, lacking the quorum required to promulgate guideline amendments. The Commission’s other statutory duties are unaffected by the lack of four voting commissioners.

Maybe Lower BAC Standards Don't Really Work That Well

Utah's decision to lower the blood alcohol content necessary to constitute a drunk driving offense greatly reduced reported accidents. But a closer look at the data suggests that the main reason is that people are less likely to report minor accidents in urban areas on weekdays, not an actual reduction in accidents.
In March of 2017 Utah became the first state in the United States to lower the legal blood alcohol content (BAC) for driving from 0.08 to 0.05 g/dL. We take advantage of the fact that enforcement was delayed until 2019 to test whether this policy change significantly affected the number of traffic accidents or the severity of those accidents. We employ a difference-in-differences strategy on Utah counties using neighboring states as controls. Results show the policy appears to decrease the total number of accidents in urban counties, limited primarily to property damage only accidents. Surprisingly, the strongest effects are found during weekday days. We confirm our findings using a synthetic control and a doubly robust difference-in-differences estimator. We believe these results may be partially explained by drivers who, after the policy is enacted, avoid reporting property damage only accidents if possible.
Javier E. Portillo, et al., "Drink...then Drive Away: The Effects of Lowering the BAC in Utah" (March 15, 2022).

Pretrial Juvenile Detention Is Common But Clearly Counterproductive

Empirical evidence shows that pre-trial juvenile detention is common and is strongly counterproductive.
Roughly one in four juveniles arrested in the U.S. spend time in a detention center prior to their court date. To study the consequences of this practice for youth, we link the universe of individual public school records in Michigan to juvenile and adult criminal justice records. Using a combination of exact matching and inverse probability weighting, we estimate that juvenile detention leads to a 31% decline in the likelihood of graduating high school and a 25% increase in the likelihood of being arrested as an adult. Falsification tests suggest the results are not driven by unobserved heterogeneity.
E. Jason Baron, Brian Jacob & Joseph P. Ryan, "Pretrial Juvenile Detention" NBER WORKING PAPER 29861 (March 2022) DOI 10.3386/w29861

Colorado Supreme Court Favors Weaker Interpretation Of Governmental Immunity

In the case of Cisneros v. Elder, 2022CO13, the Colorado Supreme Court today chose an interpretation of the state's governmental immunity statutes that is less protective of jail guards. The official syllabus states:
In this case, the supreme court considers whether section 24-10-106(1.5)(b), C.R.S. (2021), of the Colorado Governmental Immunity Act ("CGIA") waives sovereign immunity for intentional torts that result from the operation of a jail for claimants who are incarcerated but not convicted.

The court now concludes that section 24-10-106(1.5)(b) waives immunity both for intentional torts and for acts of negligence resulting from the operation of a jail for claimants who are incarcerated but not convicted. In reaching this determination, the court concludes that the statutory language waiving immunity for claimants who "are incarcerated but not yet convicted" and who "can show injury due to negligence" sets a floor, not a ceiling.

In contrast, in many circumstances, governmental immunity is waived for negligent acts of governments and government officials that cause injury, but not for intentional acts.  

The Colorado Supreme Court also rejected the argument that governments themselves should not be responsible for the intentional wrongs of their employees, basically on that theory the intentional wrongs are beyond the scope of the authority of these officials and that suing particular government employees for "willful and wanton" acts is expressly permitted in Colorado under CGIA. In this case, the court reasoned, the government was not being held vicariously liable for the willful and wanton misconduct of its employees, but for its own intentional wrongs as a matter of policy.

The underlying case involved the El Paso County Sheriff refusing to release an inmate who had posted bail, without authorization to do so, in connection with an alleged immigration hold that was held to be improper in separate litigation  resulting in the inmate's release four months later. 

The inmate was represented by the Colorado ACLU and Holland & Hart, LLP, one of the largest law firms in the state (presumably pro bono).

The decision of the Colorado Supreme Court was unanimous and followed a 2-1 decision against the inmate in the Colorado Court of Appeals which was reversed.

The damages in this individual case aren't huge, perhaps a few hundred thousand dollars at most, and possibly much less. But, the principal will probably significantly influence how sheriffs manage jails in Colorado going forward.

18 March 2022

The War In Ukraine After Three Weeks

The Russian invasions of Ukraine is three weeks old. Enough time has passed to make some preliminary assessments.

The Russian military is "hollow". 

Russia has far fewer guided missiles and "smart bombs" than the U.S. or other developed nations, and apparently used up much of its supply in the first day or two of this conflict.

Russia's pilots are only minimally trained, Russian forces weren't patient enough to wait until they had air superiority, and the widespread availability of MANPADS among Ukrainian forces (infantry carried anti-aircraft missiles) have all worked together prevent Russia from gaining air superiority and control in Ukraine. This deprived Russia of an edge in the conflict could have had a decisive advantage for their forces if it had been secured.

Russia's logistics planning is horrible. Its forces were literally running out of gas, running out of food, and getting lost in the first few days. Ukrainian forces have targeted the "tow trucks" used for heavy military vehicles that are disabled and fuel and supply trucks, that are more vulnerable, for strikes to prevent their advance, and have been quite effective at doing so.

Despite their treads, tanks overwhelmingly stay on main roads, leaving their column exposed to attack.

An expectedly large share of Russian tanks and artillery are very dated models.

The best available data suggests that something on the order of half of Russian tanks deployed in this mission have been destroyed, as well as many armored personnel carriers and some mobile artillery vehicles. The large number of small, anti-tank missiles available to Ukrainian forces have been an important factor on this front.

Russian forces have lost significant numbers of fixed wing warplanes and military helicopters, maybe two dozen, all told.

About one in seven Russian soldiers have been killed or seriously injured in this conflict so far. About one in twenty-five of its generals have been killed.

It does not appear that either side has been able to use their tanks to secure decisive victories.

About a quarter of Russian soldiers are minimally trained and marginally competent conscripts. They are not properly trained to defend themselves against reasonably competent attacks or otherwise.

Inaccurate and indiscriminate unguided howitzer shell attacks that hurt civilian and military targets alike instilling terror in the general population, and indiscriminate bombing by fighter aircraft with "dumb bombs" are shaping up to be some of the characteristic tactics of the Russian invasions. But this has not been cost free. It has painted Russian troops from Putin to the rank and file Russian soldiers in Ukraine as war criminals. These tactics have unified the Ukrainian people against the Russia. These tactics have helped cement global public opinion against Russia.

Russia's substantial Black Sea naval forces have done very little after the first day or two when they were part of a campaign to launch missiles all over Ukraine. They have not been used for fire support for ground troops and do not appear to have been important in making amphibious assaults. There has been essentially no naval warfare so far.

Russia already controlled Crimea and the Donbas region in Eastern Ukraine, immediately prior to its invasion. As shown on the map below, Russia has crept a few miles past the Russian-Belorussian border in the north, has gained control of a narrow strip of Ukraine's Aral Sea coast,  and has gained control of some territory immediately adjacent to Crimea. But they have been stalled in the suburbs of the capital city Kyiv for three weeks. 

Overall Russia's territorial gains over the last three weeks have been very modest and have been largely confined to areas with substantial Russian minorities, despite the very heavy toll that Russian forces have suffered in both casualties to their troops and destroyed major military systems. 

Even if Russia manages to eventually take Kyiv, that would be a pyrrhic victory, as it seems highly unlikely that this would result in regime change in Ukraine or in giving Russia control over the vast majority of Russian territory. It is hard to imagine a scenario at this point in which Russia could secure regime change in Ukraine or could control anything close to the majority of the territory or population of Ukraine.

This is a map of the territory Russia controlled on March 17, 2022 (yellow dots indicate recent battles):


This is a map of territory that Russia controlled on March 7, 2022, ten days earlier, with the shaded and striped areas being territory that Russia controlled immediately prior to the invasion.


It is quite clear that Russia has gains only a little ground in the last ten days, and only a modest share of Russian territory at all since the invasion began.

The credibility of Russia's conventional military forces as a tool in diplomatic negotiations has been dramatically undermined. Unless Russia can make quick and remarkable gains relative to what it has achieved in the last three weeks, the credibility will only be diminished further as time passes.

The losses of equipment and personnel that Russia has suffered in its invasion has significantly degraded the capabilities of Russia's military as a whole, at least in the short term. The longer Russia continues to try to fight in Ukraine, the weaker it military capacity to fight other conventional wars in the near future will be.

Unprecedented international sanctions and boycotts are seriously harming Russia's economy and daily life for ordinary Russians. 

International trade in anything other the natural gas exports, air travel in and out of Russia, foreign investment, and international financial transactions have basically ground to a halt. The ruble has plunged in value. Interest rates have surged to 20%. Russian's can't trade stocks domestically and have only limited access to their bank accounts. Russia narrowly avoided a default on its sovereign debt this week. Foreign Russian assets of Russia, its political leaders, and its oligarchs have been frozen. China is preparing to cooperate with international sanctions against Russia because it needs trade with the rest of the world more than it needs Russia. Russia has been closed out of international sporting and cultural exchanges. Access to foreign media and entertainment has been shut down.

Even if sanctions and boycotts are formally lifted, the developed world and global big business has collectively concluded that the political risk associated with doing business in and with Russia is prohibitively high. As a result, it may take a decade or more for Russia to recover economically from the side effects of its invasion of Ukraine, even if the war ends swiftly, unless Russia experiences regime change.

Russia's "liberal intelligentsia" is fleeing Russia in droves, resulting in a massive brain drain from Russia. They are leaving mostly by car and train to neighboring countries,  some of which were formerly Soviet Republics, before the borders are sealed or these individuals who rarely supported the invasion in the first place and didn't think that Putin would go as far as he did, are persecuted themselves. This may help Putin continue to consolidate power as dissenters self-deport themselves, but it will do grievous harm to the Russia's medium to long term future as a country.

Europe has been given a powerful nudge to reduce its reliance on Russian oil and Russian natural gas in the long run. This will do serious long term, irreversible harm to Russia's predominantly export industry.

Europe and the rest of the world have mostly united around strong opposition to Russia's invasion.

How Russia will use its nuclear arsenal, as it has threatened to do, is the elephant in the room. This is the main reason (together with the dependency of countries like Germany and Italy on Russian natural gas) that other countries haven't directly intervened militarily.

Ukraine is more united as a single country than it ever has been in the past, and pro-Russian political forces in the country pre-invasion, have been completely undermined.

Ukraine is suffering immense property damage, significant although not nation changing loss of life, significant loss of military equipment (although foreign aid is making up for some of that), and an indefinite major refugee crisis that is sending more than 10% of the country's population fleeing abroad.

Global food prices will soar from now until a year or two after the war is over, because Ukraine is a major exporter of food that can't pay attention to farming right now.

Other countries bordering Russia are fortifying collective European defense measures and are studying the tactics hat have been effective against Russia in this war so that they can better repel those tactics in future conflicts.

17 March 2022

Why Does Oklahoma Have A Panhandle?

This meme isn't true. But the real story is interesting.


The Oklahoma Panhandle derives from one of those "how sausages are made" stories of the legislative process and the sustained fights in Congress over slavery prior to the Civil War. It started with the Missouri Compromise (requiring new northern states over a certain line of latitude to be "free states"). 

This affected the efforts of Texas to be admitted to the United States as a slave state, which gave rise to the Compromise of 1850 that had Texas cede the portions of its territory that violated the Missouri Compromise and tweaked eastern boundary of what would become New Mexico.

Also, the drafting of the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 was sloppy. It really should have extended the Kansas border further South to the Missouri Compromise line at the 36°30' parallel north. A bill that passed by both houses of Congress, that was vetoed for some reason that isn't obvious by President Garfield in 1886, would have moved the boundary of the Kansas territory south to the Missouri Compromise line.

If this had been done, then what is now the Oklahoma Panhandle would very likely have become part of Colorado and not Oklahoma.


Wikipedia tells the story of how the Oklahoma Panhandle came to be:
The Oklahoma Panhandle (formerly called No Man's Land, the Public Land Strip, the Neutral Strip, or Cimarron Territory) is the extreme northwestern region of the U.S. state of Oklahoma, consisting of Cimarron County, Texas County and Beaver County, from west to east. 
. . .

The Western history of the Panhandle traces its origins as being part of New Spain. 
The Adams–Onís Treaty of 1819 between Spain and the United States set the western boundary of this portion of the Louisiana Purchase at the 100th meridian. With Mexican independence in 1821, these lands became part of Mexico. With the formation of the Texas Republic, they became part of Texas. When Texas joined the U.S. in 1846, the strip became part of the United States.

. . .

When Texas sought to enter the Union in 1845 as a slave state, federal law in the United States, based on the Missouri Compromise [of 1820], prohibited slavery north of 36°30' parallel north. Under the Compromise of 1850, Texas surrendered its lands north of 36°30' latitude. The 170-mile strip of land, a "neutral strip", was left with no state or territorial ownership from 1850 until 1890. It was officially called the "Public Land Strip" and was commonly referred to as "No Man's Land." The Compromise of 1850 also established the eastern boundary of New Mexico Territory at the 103rd meridian, thus setting the western boundary of the strip. The Kansas–Nebraska Act of 1854 set the southern border of Kansas Territory as the 37th parallel. This became the northern boundary of "No Man's Land." 
When Kansas joined the Union in 1861, the western part of Kansas Territory was assigned to the Colorado Territory but did not change the boundary of "No Man's Land."

After the Civil War, cattlemen moved into the area. Gradually they organized themselves into ranches and established their own rules for arranging their land and adjudicating their disputes. There was still confusion over the status of the strip, and some attempts were made to arrange rent with the Cherokees, despite the fact that the Cherokee Outlet ended at the 100th meridian. In 1885, the U. S. Supreme Court ruled that the strip was not part of the Cherokee Outlet. In 1886, Interior Secretary L. Q. C. Lamar declared the area to be public domain and subject to "squatter's rights". The strip was not yet surveyed, and as that was one of the requirements of the Homestead Act of 1862, the land could not be officially settled. Settlers by the thousands flooded in to assert their "squatter's rights" anyway. They surveyed their own land and by September 1886 had organized a self-governing and self-policing jurisdiction, which they named the Cimarron Territory. Senator Daniel W. Voorhees of Indiana introduced a bill in Congress to attach the so-called territory to Kansas. It passed both the Senate and the House of Representatives but was not signed by President Grover Cleveland. The organization of Cimarron Territory began soon after Secretary Lamar declared the area open to settlement by squatters. The settlers formed their own vigilance committees, which organized a board charged with forming a territorial government. The board enacted a preliminary code of law and divided the strip into three districts. They also called for a general election to choose three members from each district to form a government. The elected council met as planned, elected Owen G. Chase as president, and named a full cabinet. They also enacted further laws and divided the strip into five counties (Benton, Beaver, Palo Duro, Optima, and Sunset), three senatorial districts (with three members from each district), and seven delegate districts (with two members from each district). The members from these districts were to be the legislative body for the proposed territory. Elections were held November 8, 1887, and the legislature met for the first time on December 5, 1887. Chase went to Washington, D.C., to lobby for admission to Congress as the delegate from the new territory. He was not recognized by Congress. A group disputing the Chase organization met and elected and sent its own delegate to Washington. A bill was introduced to accept Chase but was never brought to a vote. Neither delegation was able to persuade Congress to accept the new territory. Another delegation went in 1888 but was also unsuccessful. In 1889, the Unassigned Lands to the east of the territory were opened for settlement, and many of the residents went there. The remaining population was generously estimated by Chase at 10,000 after the opening. Ten years later, an actual count revealed a population of 2,548.

The passage of the Organic Act in 1890 assigned Public Land Strip to the new Oklahoma Territory, and ended the short-lived Cimarron Territory aspirations.

Beaver County encompassed the whole Panhandle from 1890 until statehood. . . . "No Man's Land" became Seventh County under the newly organized Oklahoma Territory and was soon renamed Beaver County. Beaver City became the county seat. When Oklahoma Territory and Indian Territory were combined in 1907 as the state of Oklahoma, Beaver County was divided into Beaver, Texas, and Cimarron counties. 
The Oklahoma Panhandle had the highest population at its first census in 1910, 32,433 residents, compared to 28,729 in the 2020 census.

16 March 2022

Somebody's Not Going To Have Any Difficulty Getting Into College

Glenn Bruda is truly brilliant young man whom I can relate to. I've known a few other math prodigies in his league, although his accomplishments are particularly impressive. 

If I were him, I'd be applying to schools like Cal Tech,  M.I.T., and Princeton, all of which would be thrilled to admit him, rather than the University of Florida. But that's his prerogative, I guess.
Glenn Bruda . . . a [17-year-old] senior at Buchholz High School in Gainesville. He . . .  concocted [what] turned out to be an entirely new calculus technique to solve integral equations. He cross checked it with mathematics professors at Santa Fe College and the University of Florida, who later encouraged him to submit his discovery for publication. On Jan. 30, 2022, it was published to Cornell University’s “arXiv”, an open-access archive for scholarly scientific articles. . . . Bruda titled his integration technique the “Maclaurin Integration” because it is derived from a formula named after Colin Maclaurin, a famous 18th century Scottish mathematician. He is now in the process of writing a second mathematical paper that will propose another original integration technique.

The Maclaurin Integration technique Bruda developed is designed to be “one of the most versatile integration techniques” because, with it, “there is essentially zero human labor involved in calculating integrals.”
Bruda keeps the notebook where he wrote his first original integral calculus technique as a source of motivation. There are visible water stains on the page from when he spilled his glass in excitement. (Photo courtesy of Jennifer Bruda)
Where most integration techniques can only be applied to around 10% to 40% of integral problems, Bruda’s technique applies to approximately 73% of integrals. That means it is almost two times more effective than most mainstream techniques.

Integration techniques are most common in Calculus II courses, which – despite not having graduated high school – Bruda claims as his favorite mathematics course to date. Bruda is a dual-enrolled student at Santa Fe College, where he is currently enrolled in courses like Differential Equations and Physics I with Calculus.. . . He’s now applying for the Davidson Fellows Scholarship, a prestigious scholarship for gifted high school students with rewards of $10,000, $25,000 and $50,000. The scholarship is awarded to students who create a “significant piece of work” at the graduate level. The Davidson Institute defines significant work as work “that experts in the field recognize as meaningful and has the potential to make a positive contribution to society.” . . . He is a Gainesville native who hopes to study mathematics at the University of Florida.

Bruda poses with his dog Leggo while wearing a graduation cap and gown. He graduates from Buchholz soon, and hopes to study mathematics at the University of Florida. (Photo courtesy of Jennifer Bruda)

Fossil Fuels, Geopolitics, And Electric Cars

Overview

The rapidly decreasing price and increasing quality of electric car batteries are on the brink of reaching a tipping point that will dramatically increase the market share of electric vehicles relative to internal combustion vehicles, and with it will dramatically reduce global demand for oil and oil prices. We may be at or near peak oil prices and demand right now.

Falling oil prices over the next decade or so will dramatically decrease the geopolitical clout of Russia and other authoritarian regimes, and of conservative forces in U.S. politics, although their economic contractions may push them to far right militarism driven by this economic malaise. 

These countries will also scramble to find ways to get natural gas to distant markets (oil and natural gas are usually found in nature together). But this will only partially compensate for their lost oil revenue due to shifts to renewable electricity generation and another round of nuclear energy generation development driven by the unwillingness of natural gas importers to rely on authoritarian regimes like Russia and Saudi Arabia for energy security as they were caught doing in the Russian-Ukraine war, and also out of concerns about air pollution and climate change.

Falling oil prices will also easy the process of converting agrarian third-world countries into industrial economies and in strengthening economic growth in the developing world driven by industry. This will tend to strengthen democracy in these countries.

The coal industry is on its death bed in developed nations and is unlikely to rebound.

Oil Is Bad For Democracy

Economies that rely heavily on oil and gas revenues tend to be less democratic. A more than 5-9% of GDP reliance on oil revenues appears to be pretty toxic to the democratic political process.

Oil Revenues as Percentage of GDP (per the World Bank):

Country
Most Recent Year
Most Recent Value
2019
43.9
2019
43.4
2019
42.1
2019
39.6
2019
25.1
2019
24.9
2019
24.2
2019
21.9
2019
18.8
2019
17.8
2019
16.9
2019
16.3
2019
14.4
2019
13.8
2019
7.4
2019
6.7
2019
5.6
2019
4.8
2019
4.7
2019
3.7
2019
3.6
2019
2.8
2019
2.4
2019
2.2
2019
2.0
2019
2.0
2019
2.0
2019
1.8
2019
1.7
2019
1.6

Honestly, even state governments in the U.S. with heavy fossil fuel components to their economies are mostly not paragons of the democratic process.


Even within U.S. states, oil economy driven counties, see, e.g. Weld County, Colorado, are not thriving centers of economic growth.

The Coal Curse And Electricity Generation

Historic Coal Production Slows Economic Development

Coal is also bad news in the long run for economic development. In Europe, "former coal-mining regions are substantially poorer, with (at least) 10% smaller per-capita GDP than comparable regions in the same country that did not mine coal." Similar effects have been observed in India and Australia. 

In the U.S., coal centers in West Virginia and Wyoming probably have bleak futures as coal ceases to be economically relevant because it is such an intense source of air pollution and driver of climate change, as have many other regions in Appalachia that are coal rich but where the coal industry doesn't dominate the entire state's economy to the same degree.

The End Of Coal

Coal was already predominantly used to generate electricity, as other "steam age" technologies were replaced with "diesel age" technologies in other applications, when its decline started in earnest. 

The final blow has come as utility companies replaced coal, first with natural gas (made cheaper and more abundant with "fracking") and wind power. As production costs have fallen and efficiencies have risen, coal has been replaced with solar power as well. 

Tidal power is likely to join the ranks of renewables in the near future and is particularly attractive because it is reliable and predictable enough to be a source of baseline power. 

Electricity is also generated in significant quantities with hydroelectric plants that are near maximum capacity and may be threatened by mega droughts in some areas, and by nuclear fission. Some European countries rely mostly on nuclear power, and there is significant room to expand nuclear power generation in a way that benefits from the technological advances since the 1960s when the first nuclear power plants came online.

Nuclear fusion remains in the distant future and may never be cost efficient due to high plant costs despite negligible fuel costs and essentially creating no pollution in the power generation process.

Naturally, coal prices fall when alternatives like renewable electricity gets cheaper, to match the competition, cutting into the profits of coal producers and owners of coal mineral rights and reducing the erosion of coal's market share. 

But that can only go so far. Pollution controls drive up the cost of coal fueled power plants, and coal prices can't drop below the cost of mining and delivering the coal in the long run. If renewables and other sources of power can get cheaper to make even at negligible prices for the coal mining rights themselves, coal is doomed and can't lower its price to maintain market share any longer. And, that is pretty close to where we are now.

Incidentally, coal can be converted in an industrial process to liquids and gases that are substitutes for oil and natural gas. But this oil substitute is too expensive to make sense relative to cheaper oil conventional oil wells in places like the Middle East. 

Similarly, natural gas is available without the expensive conversion process in many places in the world that currently burn it off or decline to extract it because they can't get it to the consumers inexpensively enough. The transportation and storage problems for natural gas are cheaper to solve than the cost of making natural gas substitutes from coal. So, this too is a dead end for the coal industry.

Some developing nations, most notably China, make heavy use of coal, but are well aware of the extreme price that they are paying for doing so in terms of air pollution. 

Also, these developing nations are well positioned to leap frog to post-industrial technologies less reliant on coal for fuel, without the highly polluting intermediate steps that the developed world went though to get to their current environmental and energy balance, without having to invest in developing those cleaner technologies from scratch.

So, a third-world or developing world surge in coal utilization also seems unlikely.

The Global Oil Markets

Oil is fairly easy to transport cheaply by pipeline, by oil tanker over water, by rail, and by truck. Its easy portability has also made it the fuel of choice for motor vehicles, boats, ships, heavy construction and agricultural equipment, military vehicles, and aircraft. Its transportability and non-perishable nature also means that oil trades in a world market.

For example, even though the United States is a slight net oil exporter, its domestic oil prices and the prices of products derived from oil like gasoline and diesel fuel, are impacted by anything that affects the supply or demand for oil worldwide. So, even though the U.S. itself doesn't actually important more than a de minimus amount of oil from Russia (and mostly low grade petroleum products not suitable for gasoline and diesel refining), when sanctions have cut Russia off from global oil markets reducing supply about 10%, this has driven up oil prices everywhere, because countries that used to buy Russian oil are now trying to buy supplies from elsewhere including U.S. suppliers, and because places that used to buy oil from places that countries formerly reliant on Russian oil supplies are buying from are now looking to U.S. suppliers instead.

The flip side of the oil market being global, however, is that cuts in supply can be offset by increases in production and releases oil stockpiles to make up for the shortfall.

So, while sanctions preventing Russia from selling oil deprive Russia of its dominant source of export revenue, the removal of this supply from the global oil market leaves few countries without viable alternatives to meet their oil consumption needs, and the increase in global oil prices only partially reflects the drop in supply that these sanctions cause due to offsets from other oil suppliers.

In other words, sanctions preventing Russia from selling oil hurt Russia more than they hurt the rest of the world that is imposing the sanctions. And, the harm to the world outside Russia due to the sanctions is spread relatively evenly across the globe, rather than too acutely impacting the countries that usually buy their oil from Russia, although those countries are hurt somewhat worse than other countries.

Regional Natural Gas Markets

Natural gas is another story.

Demand

Natural gas is used mostly to generate electricity and for space heating (e.g. to run furnaces in homes and offices). In places where air conditioning is widely used, peak demand is in the summer to meet peak electricity demands. But Europe makes fairly little use of air conditioning due to its climate. In places that get cold in the winter and not too hot in the summer, like most of Northern, Central and Eastern Europe, peak demand for natural gas is in the winter.

Supply and Trade

Natural gas is sold in a regional, rather than a global marketplace. Mostly, it is delivered by pipeline. It isn't impossible to deliver it by ship, by train, or by truck, and rural areas without pipelines get propane deliveries for household and commercial use in lieu of natural gas. It also isn't impossible to store and its perishable. But it is much more cumbersome and expensive to deliver natural gas by means other than pipelines, and it is much more challenging to store than oil. So, little non-pipeline delivery infrastructure and large scale natural gas storage infrastructure is in place.

So, natural gas is predominantly delivered overland, through a small number of big, regional natural gas pipelines that run from production areas (in Europe, many of which are in Russia), to areas where it is consumed (in Europe, especially to urbanized areas without much nuclear power generation).

Germany gets 55% of its natural gas from Russia and is heavily reliant on natural gas for both electrical power generation and space heating. Italy gets 45% of its natural gas from Russia, with less focus on space heating and more on electrical power generation. Other countries in Europe, for example, Poland, are also heavily reliant on Russian natural gas.

In contrast, France, whose power grid is heavily fueled by nuclear power plants, and countries like the United Kingdom and Norway, which produces oil and natural gas in the North Sea, aren't very reliant on Russian natural gas.

Europe's reliance on Russian natural gas pipelines is second only to Russia's nuclear weapons stockpile, in giving Russia leverage to discourage European countries from intervening in Ukraine.

Unlike oil, finding alternative sources of natural gas for the European countries that rely upon it is very challenging.

While oil price hikes from reductions in Russian supplies are global in impact and hurt the U.S. and Canada as well, for example, even though they don't import meaningful amounts of oil to refine into gasoline and diesel from Russia, interruptions in Russian natural gas supplies have almost no impact on the U.S. and Canada.

The U.S. and Canada are net exporters of natural gas, mostly export to other places in the Americas, and import what little they do import (in the form of liquid natural gas or LNG by ship) about 80% from Trinidad and Tobago in Latin America. They import essentially no natural gas from Russia, and since their natural gas isn't easily sold outside of the Americas, their natural gas prices aren't affected by interruptions in Russian natural gas supplies.

The Economics Of Electric Cars 

The world is in the process of transitioning to electric motor vehicles as improvements in battery technology have made them economically competitive with internal combustion engine vehicles fueled with oil derived gasoline and diesel fuel.

Environmental Impacts

Electric vehicles are zero emission at the point source, not generating the tailpipe air pollution of gasoline and diesel fueled vehicles. The pollution created by generating electricity to power electric vehicles depends upon how the power grid is fueled. But renewables, nuclear fission plants, and natural gas all generate much less pollution per unit of vehicle moving power than gasoline or diesel, although coal is a closer call between being better or worse. Even electric cars on a coal-fired grid aren't unambiguously worse than gasoline or diesel fueled vehicles, because electric cars are more efficient (especially in city driving) than gasoline or diesel fueled vehicles in terms of miles travelled per unit of energy. 

Electric vehicles are also better than internal combustion vehicles even considering the manufacturing related pollution and disposal issues for batteries and electric vehicles themselves compared to conventional internal combustion vehicles.

An Electric v. Internal Combustion Tipping Point

The production costs for electric vehicles relative to internal combustion vehicles is mostly driven by the relative cost of batteries and motors to engines, gas tanks and exhaust systems. The costs of the mature technologies of electric motors, internal combustion engines, gas tanks, and car exhaust systems is more or less fixed in the short to medium run. So, the relative cost of electric vehicles and internal combustion vehicles is functionally, mostly a matter of how much electric car vehicle batteries cost. 

Currently, batteries are expensive enough in early stages of low level mass production, that electric vehicles cost more than internal combustion vehicles, with a price differential that considering fuel costs, leaves electric vehicles a bit more expensive than comparable internal combustion vehicles. 

But we are very close to the tipping point where electric vehicles will be cheaper on a lifetime of the vehicle including fuel and maintenance basis than internal combustion vehicles (and arguably are already there for vehicles with heavy city driving use like taxis). We could reach that point in two to five years.

And progress is being made in battery technology so fast, after a long logjam of glacial progress, that electric vehicles that are no more expensive, even before considering fuel costs, than internal combustion vehicles, are plausible in the medium term of perhaps five to ten years from now.

So, a surge in electric vehicle market share, and a corresponding plunge in petroleum demand worldwide, may be just around the corner.

A 2018 study from the University of Michigan's Transportation Research Institute found the average cost to operate an EV in the U.S. was $485 per year compared with a gasoline-powered vehicle at $1,117. In round numbers, with current economics, the fuel costs per mile driven for electric vehicles if you use residential chargers at night, rather than high speed commercial chargers, are about a third of the cost of internal combustion vehicles.

In the long run, oil prices have been remarkably steady at about $2.10 a gallon in equivalent gasoline prices in 2022 dollars, even though gasoline prices are currently about $4 a gallon due to the Russo-Ukraine war.

If production costs for electric vehicles can fall with mass production to something close to the cost of internal combustion vehicles, then gasoline prices would have to fall to about 70 cents a gallon to maintain market share, which is equivalent to about $18 per barrel oil prices. 

The Geopolitical Impact Of Electric Car Driven Drops In Oil Demand

There are some oil producers out there that can produce oil at that price at a profit. But many more oil producers can't cut their costs enough to make it profitable to produce oil at the $18 a barrel price that a mass shift to electric vehicles could lead to due to falling demand.

Impact On Oil Producers

Oil production costs vary by country and the following analysis is as of 2018:
A world oil price in the range of $55 to $60 per barrel is less than the cost of Russian Arctic oil production, European and Brazilian biofuel production, US and Canadian shale and tight oil production [ed. aka "fracking"], and Brazilian presalt oil production. 

It doesn't take all that much of a downward shift in prevailing oil prices to make a large share of production from some of the world's biggest oil producers uneconomic.

Production in the U.S., Canada, and Brazil, and European biodiesel and ethanol, falls dramatically at below $55 a barrel. Russian and Angolan production falls dramatically at sustained oil prices below $40 a barrel. Production in the Middle East, Venezuela, Ecuador, Kazakstan, and Nigeria (onshore only), in contrast, can remain economic down to only a little more than $20 a barrel.

But some of the high cost oil producers still account for a large share of the global oil market as shown below from the same source:


Also, while it will continue to be economic for the Middle East and a few other countries to continue producing oil even if there are massive reductions in the price per barrel as electric vehicles with cheaper and better batteries contract global demand, the impact on these countries will still be immense, because their profits from selling their oil with decline precipitously. 

All countries that rely heavily on oil revenues will see their economies contract permanently, in the cases of the countries most reliant upon oil revenues, on scales comparable to that of the Great Depression or post-WWI Germany as electric vehicles cross the tipping point.

Countries like Saudi Arabia, UAE, Oman, and Kuwait will suddenly find themselves with economies that look more like Yemen's, unless they can transition away from fossil fuels, or can find a way to shift to natural gas production to meet increased electricity generation demand from electric vehicles in a way that they can get that to market, like LNG shipping or new pipelines.

As their economies shift from relying on economic rents from oil and gas production to more diversified commercial economies, their authoritarian regimes will be undermined. 

Russia, due to its higher cost of oil production, which effectively leverages the relationship between oil prices and its oil industry profits, faces the collapse of the clout of its primary and predominant export industry much more quickly, which could imperil Vladimir Putin's regime, even without the woes Russia is facing due to its ill advised invasion of Ukraine.

Also, European countries reliant on Russia for their oil and gas needs are now acutely aware of the national security risks they face by doing so and will be transitioning away from reliance on oil and natural gas from Russia by all means possible as soon as they possibly can, by adopting extreme conservation measures such as heavily subsidizing transitions to electric vehicles, by boosting investments in renewable and nuclear energy generation, and by developing pipelines and LNG and natural gas storage facilities that make them more independent from a Russian energy supply partner which has proven unreliable.

So, even if Russia extricates itself from its current war in Ukraine and unwinds many current sanctions, European countries and big businesses will be loath to invest more in reliance on Russian oil and gas supplies than they have already, thus permanently reducing Russia's oil and gas revenues. 

Similarly, in the U.S., which will take the hit from lower oil prices and return to being an oil importer if electric vehicle sales don't grow fast enough, even sooner, the power of fossil fuel lobbies in Washington and in state legislatures across the nation will ebb greatly in the next decade or so.

Impact On Developing Countries

On the other hand, cheap oil prices can help fuel economic development, especially in oil-poor countries that are trying to transition to industrial economies, including many of the world's poorest countries in Africa.

These countries may get a boost from reduced developed country oil demand from electric vehicles and in these countries, a shift from a pre-industrial agrarian economy to an industrial economy, may advance the cause of democracy and human rights, rather than impeding it, and this may also hasten the demographic transition that comes with industrialization.