19 January 2007

CA Medical Marijuana Raids Prompt Protest

According to one of my readers "Over the past month, the DEA conducted raids on three dispensaries and several medical cannabis grow facilities across California, restricting safe access to cannabis for bona-fide patients statewide."

Colorado is one of a number of states whose state law permits the distribution of marijuana for medical purposes. It is not alone: "By 1992, 35 states in the United States had endorsed referenda for medical marijuana." This continues to be against federal law, despite some pretty solid evidence that it is safe and effective for the treatment of certain medical projects (discussed in the link).

An organization in favor of medical marijuana has called for a protest of this DEA action and will convene to do so:

Monday January 22nd @ High Noon
Byron G. Rogers Federal Office Building
1961 Stout Street
Denver, CO 80294-3538

For the record, the DEA clearly has the legal authority to conduct the raids. Going after what is clearly the most harmless instances of drug use in the United States, in a breach of comity between the United States government and state governments may not be a wise allocation of resources.

In contrast, while the United States government can prosecute death penalty cases in any state, only five death penalty convictions have been secured in non-death penalty states, largely out of deference to state law preferences.

Presumably, the raids are conducted mostly because they are open violations of federal law and hence, easy from an enforcement prespective and a symbolically important way of upholding a failed policy. In the same way high profile immigration raids are a symbolic way of upholding a failed immigration policy.

The simple solution would be for the Congress to adopt a medical marijuana exception in states where this is allowed under state law and regulations.

Psychopaths, Conservatives and Liberals

Evolving mental health research into the notion that some people are psychopaths has profound moral implications for criminal justice that go to the heart of policy differences between conservatives and liberals on criminal justice issues.

These developments were detailed in a December 9, 2006 issue of Science News (subscription only), an often stodgy weekly publication that mostly abstracts and translates interesting scientific journal papers into layman's language.

Although psychiatrists don't currently label psychopathy as a formal personality disorder, a wave of new research has yielded insights into how psychopaths think and suggested biological and temperamental roots of this condition.


The main conclusions

* Personality traits including "a lack of guilt, an unemotional demeanor, little concern about others' feelings or about school, a refusal to keep promises, and difficulty forming lasting friendships," are manifest in about 1 in 100 children.

* Psychopathy, in adults, involve people who "lack a conscience and are incapable of experiencing empathy, guilt, or loyalty." But, this doesn't prevent them from being "superficially charming, intelligent people."

* "Two conditions—sociopathy and antisocial personality disorder—often get confused with psychopathy. . . . Sociopaths have a sense of right and wrong that is based on the values of their criminal group. Antisocial personality disorder, an official psychiatric ailment, is a diagnosis applied to people who commit a broad range of aggressive and criminal acts. Some qualify as psychopaths, but many don't."

* These traits are manifest, at least, by the time children are elementary school aged, and possibly as early as age three.

* Twin studies show a strong genetic component to pesonality traits associated with psychopathy. Longitudinal studies show that these traits tend to be stable over long periods of time and resistent to education and parental intervention -- while a few percent with "high-quality parenting [who were] living in a wealthy family," showed improvement in a four year period, the vast majority did not. These children tend to respond to rewards, but not punishments.

* Most felons are not psychopaths, and psychopathy appears to be a matter of degree rather than a trait that one does or does not have. A test that tries to measure the trait produces notable results:

PCL-R scores range from 0 to 40. Most people in the general population score no more than 5 on this test. Hare estimates that 1 percent scores at least 30. Researchers typically use scores of 30 and above to indicate psychopathy . . .

The average PCL-R scores for men and women in prisons are 22 and 19, respectively. About 15 percent of male offenders and 10 percent of female offenders score 30 or more.


* Most murders are not committed by psychopaths, but they "committed the bulk of premeditated homicides" and "often applied torture, mutilation, or other forms of extreme violence to their victims." According to the journal article relied upon for the Science News story 93.3% of murders committed by people the author classifed as psychopaths were pre-meditated, while 48.4% of those committed by non-psychopaths fit this description.

Indeed, one way to understand the crime of 1st degree murder is as a crude way to distinguish the sorts of murders that a psychopath would tend to commit from the sorts of murders that a non-psychopath would tend to commit.

* Many crimes committed by psychopaths, however, involve fraud and confidence games that involve lies and the cold hearted manipulation of others. Nothing inherent in psychopathy alone includes violent tendencies, it is simply a personality in which the normal impacts of conscience to restrain those tendencies if they are otherwise present, isn't restrained.

Implications

Rehabilitation v. Incapacitation in Criminal Sentencing

The conservative view of criminal justice policy has at its root the notion that some people are inherently bad, and that we need to protect society from them with long prison terms and executions. The liberal view of criminal justice policy has at its root the notion that crime is overwhelmingly a product of environmental influences and that rehabilitation is often possible. Research on psychopathy suggests that both are right to a degree and provides an avenue for distinguishing the most fruitful approach in each case.

If the numbers cited above are correct about 14% of prison inmates are male psychopaths and about 0.5% of prison inmates are female psychopatha. A significant number of felons are instead borderline psychopaths (i.e. much closer to 30 than the typical person's 5 score on the PCL-R). If the evolving research is correct, rehabilitative efforts and changes in environment may do little to prevent these offenders from reoffending, even if they superficially appear to be complying well with prison rehabilitation programs.

On the other hand, a majority of prison inmates are neither pyschopaths nor borderline psychopaths. These people are quite amenable to rehabilitation and much more influenced by their environment. Also, while they may reoffend, they are less likely to commit the heinous crimes that every politician fears having given an ex-con a chance to commit, a fear eptiomized in the famous and politically notable Willie Horton case. This fear is what, to a great extent, drove the "tough on crime" attitude that has prevailed since the 1980s.

At its best, psychopathy evaluation in sentencing could make prosecutors, judges, legislators, and the public much more comfortable with making rehabilitation oriented sentencing available to a much larger group of convicted felons. Meanwhile, it could also better protect the public from particularly worrisome felons who show strong psychopathic tendencies and have confirmed their high risk of committing crimes in the future associated by committing a serious crime, with imposing long prison sentences for these convicted felons. An ability to make this distinction might be the development that could persaude policy makers to retreat from the mandatory sentencing regimes which so often met out long prison terms to not particularly culpable individuals.

In the sentencing context, where the status quo is so bad at distinguishing the hard core offender from the redeemable one, a less than perfect predictator could still be a great improvement, and the moral imperative to seperate the guilty from the innocent is much greater than the moral imperative to met out a precise punishment for a precise crime. If you commit a felony, one of the risks you take is that you will be convicted and end up with a harsher punishment than you really deserve. It is better to base this distinction on empirical mental health research, even if it is imperfect, than on the gut feeling of a judge in a quasi-theatrical sentencing hearing context influenced by a judge's cultural biases.

Indeed, another major attraction of some way to measure pyschopathy is that it is a risk factor, which, if tested properly, would be distinct from race, ethnicity, or other socio-economic biases. Taken together with other race and ethnicity neutral predictors of recidivism, this holds the promise of reducing expensive prison populations, while increasing the likelihood that the public will be protected from reoffending criminals.

Indeed, what a good measure of pyschopathy offers that other recidivism measures do not, is a chance to distinguish between raw recidivism (many of the most likely offenders to reoffend are those who commit low level, non-violent economically motivated crimes like theft and prostitution and drug dealing), from the kind of recidivism we worry most about, which is commission of violent and highly culpable crimes.

It also suggests the kind of rehabilitation efforst that may help most. Anger management and substance abuse control may be the key issues for the man who impulsively killed or seriously injured someone in an argument at a bar. Both may be useless for someone who committed a serious assault in a premeditated fashion out of boredom.

Likewise, a more refined sense of what pyschopathy is would provide a more reasoned argument for downgrading certain types of first degree murder which are less culpable (e.g. the parent who in a fit of rage shakes a child to death, or a minor accessory in a burglary gone bad who ends up facing felony murder charges) from those who are genuinely unredeemable killers.

Of course, over reliance on a diagnosis of psychopathy, which may often be quite unreliable, could lead to draconian sentences for minor offenses for people who don't have the traits that the tests attribute to them, imposing hellish conditions on criminal defendants more or less at random. Even worse, bad tests could disproportionately impact the wrong people, because psychopaths may be more adept at keeping their cool, lying and gaming the tests and the system than ordinary criminal defendants, once knowledge that these tests are in use becomes widespread.

Then again, would that be any worse than the status quo whose mandatory minimum sentencing laws impose draconian sentences for reasons that hardly even attempt to make sense?

Preventing Predictable Tragedies

An increasingly important policy idea is the notion that predictable tragedies should be avoided. We know that 95% of serious crimes are committed by males. We know that the 1% of males who show traits associated with psychopathy, which manifest at a young age, are far more likely to commit heinous crimes than the general population. We know that very young children, in large part because they lack the ability to do so, rarely commit serious crimes. So, out of the 3,000,000 or so children in any given school grade, say 7th grade for sake of example, at any one time, roughly 15,000 of them are at very high risk of committing serious crimes in the future.

Our long traditions of social justice say that we shouldn't punish people for a mere elevated likelihood that they will commit crimes in the future, particularly when this propensity is simply an accident of birth. Also, the ability of simple tests to distinguish psychopaths from non-psychopaths through psychological tests are nowhere near the accuracy that would justify the risk that a wrong decision could inflict immense personal hardship on an individual who has not committed a crime. But, simply ignoring a high risk of a tragedy that is likely to happen is also problematic.

The morally acceptable response, it seems, it to intervene intensely early on to do whatever is possible to prevent these boys from becoming monsters, even if this is a highly resource intensive project, in addition to considering this tendency when evaluating what sentencing options are appropriate when a crime is committed.

If you have 80 people in a room and know that without intervention that there is a statistical certainty that one of them will commit a pre-mediatated torture-murder, and that many more of them will end up committing serious felonies that do great harm to their victims, how much would you be willing to spend to reduce the likelihood that those crimes will be committed by those people?

But, the temptation to actually punish people who have committed no crime, but are merely likely to according to some test, may be particularly great when and if, for example, it becomes possible to definitively determine that someone does or does not have a "psychopathy gene" or set of genetic markers. Genetic testing technology and research in this area is getting increasingly close to making this kind of test possible, or even routine. This could sorely test our political systems ability to be nuanced in applying our sense of justice.

Distinguishing Incapacitation From Punishment

Of course, there is another way to look at the situation. Our criminal justice system is fundamentally based on the notion that people are informed of what is right and wrong, make voluntary choices to commit wrong acts, and are being punished because they made the wrong choices. We don't see people with a mental illness that destroys someone's ability to know that the act that they are committing is wrong (e.g. due to delusions about the facts they perceive) as culpable.

Suppose we can establish definitively that a major motivating factor for a serious criminal act is a genetic mental illness. Suppose further that this is a mental illness that does not prevent the person afflicted from knowing the difference between right and wrong, but does make it far more difficult for them, than for the average person, to care about that distinction. What does that do to the moral framework of criminal justice?

Does it suggest that criminal sentences for these people, while they should be incapacitating and protect the public, should not be punitive? The legal standard of involuntary mental health commitment is that someone is a great risk to themselves or others. This is surely the case when you have psychopaths who have already committed a violent crime. But, research suggests that these people are particularly incapable of appreciating and changing their behavior in response to punishment.

Conservatives are right that psychopathic felons should not simply be let loose onto the streets because they are mentally ill. But, while "hitting back" at them with cruel conditions (e.g. many conservatives tend to see allowing prison rape to flourish through neglect as a desirable punitive aspect of prison sentences, rather than as the gross betrayal of the warden's obligations that liberals see it as), this may not be a suitable lens with which to view the situation.

One of the ironies of the notion that some felons are psychopathic, is that the punishment interest in sentencing may make the most sense for those felons whom we have not historically considered the most culpable -- i.e. those with enough of a conscience to have felt real qualms about committing, and real remorse for having committed, their crimes.

References

Science News provides bibliographies for its stories. Here are the sources for this one (excluding the individuals, often authors of the sourced materials, who are interviewed):

Babiak, P., and R.D. Hare. 2006. Snakes in Suits: When Psychopaths Go to Work. New York: HarperCollins.

Blair, R.J.R. 2006. The emergence of psychopathy: Implications for the neuropsychological approach to developmental disorders. Cognition 101(September):414-442. Abstract available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2006.04.005.

Dvorak-Bertsch, J.D. . . . and J.P. Newman. In press. Anxiety moderates the interplay between cognitive and affective processing. Psychological Science. Preprint available at http://dionysus.psych.wisc.edu/lit/InPress/BertschFinalRevision.pdf.

Edens, J.F. 2006. Unresolved controversies concerning psychopathy: Implications for clinical and forensic decision making. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 37(February):59-65. Abstract available at http://content.apa.org/journals/pro/37/1/59.

Hare, R.D. 1993. Without Conscience: The Disturbing World of the Psychopaths Among Us. New York: Pocket Books.

Hawes, D.J., and M.R. Dadds. 2005. The treatment of conduct problems in children with callous–unemotional traits. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 73(August):737-741. Abstract available at http://content.apa.org/journals/ccp/73/4/737.

Hervé, H., and J.C. Yuille, eds. 2007. The Psychopath: Theory, Research, and Practice. Mahwah, New Jersey, and London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Viding, E., J.R. Blair, et al. 2005. Evidence for substantial genetic risk for psychopathy in 7-year-olds. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 46(June):592-597. Abstract available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.2004.00393.x.

Woodworth, M., and S. Porter. 2002. In cold blood: Characteristics of criminal homicides as a function of psychopathy. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 111(August):436-445. Abstract available at http://content.apa.org/journals/abn/111/3/436.

Lyman, D.R., and L. Gudonis. 2005. The development of psychopathy. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 1(April):381-407. Abstract available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.clinpsy.1.102803.144019.

18 January 2007

A Growing Health Care Reform Consensus

The Washington Post is reporting on back door negotiations between some of the biggest players in D.C., including big business, labor and seniors, on reforming health care. Steven Pearlstein details the terms of the emerging political consensus on the issue:

It starts with universal coverage, accomplished either through a mandate on everyone to purchase basic health insurance or a mandate on all employers to offer it.

It includes subsidies for families with incomes up to 300 percent of the poverty level to help defray the cost of that insurance and the deductibles and co-payments that go with it.

It involves changes in tax law so that individuals who purchase health insurance enjoy the same tax benefits as those who get it as a fringe benefit at work.

It sets up a pooling arrangement in every state to allow individuals and small businesses to buy health insurance at the same price as large corporations.

Finally, it sets a deadline for physicians and hospitals to switch to computerized health records, along with a program to provide no-interest loans to buy the necessary hardware and software. . . .

Doctors would have to agree to have their compensation from insurers tied, in part, to how well they conform to treatment protocols established by the various medical specialties.

Hospitals and insurers would have to agree that 85 percent of their revenue would go to providing direct care, capping profit and administrative expenses at 15 percent.

Health insurers would have to accept the obligation to sell insurance to everyone, with only modest variation in rates for age and health status.

And to raise some money and hold down the growth in insurance premiums, union members and high-income workers would have to accept a cap on the amount of health benefits they receive tax-free.

To avoid government "negotiated" prices, drug companies would have to submit new drugs to a rigorous cost-benefit test by an independent agency, such as the Institute of Medicine, as a condition for being included on the Medicare and Medicaid formularies.

Conservatives and their small-business allies would have to swallow some form of "pay or play" -- either providing employer-paid health insurance or paying a tax to the state subsidy pool.

And liberals would have to accept a "basic" insurance package that provides full coverage for preventive care and catastrophic illness but requires patient cost-sharing for routine care.


A 2-1 decision by the United States Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit (summarized here) holding that Maryland's requirement to impose minimum health insurance expenditures on Wal-Mart based on payroll pre-empted by ERISA, makes it much harder to implement this kind of consensus at the state level.

16 January 2007

Fire Risk

A big apartment fire in Colorado Springs today got me thinking about the risk presented by residential fires.

The risk is declining. In 2005, there were 396,000 fires in residential structures identified by national statistics, causing 3,055 deaths, 13,825 injuries, and $6.875 billion in property damage. Residential structures for this purpose include one-family and two-family dwellings (including manufactured homes), apartments, hotels, motels, college dormitories, boarding houses, etc.

This is the lowest toll in the period from 1996 to 2005 and the culmination of a trend. In 1996, the worst year in that time period, there were 428,000 residential fires, causing 4,080 deaths, 19,300 injuries and $4.962 billion in property damage (in part a function of lower housing prices then).

Residential fires accounted for approximately 83 percent of all fire deaths and 77 percent of the injuries to civilians from fires in 2005.

Fewer than 15 deaths a year on average are in dormitories, fraternities and sororities.

In 2000, about 82% of residential fire deaths were in single family homes or duplexes, while 16% were in apartment buildings, and 2% were in other residential structures.

According to the Census Bureau, there were about 109 million occupied housing units (apartments, condos, homes, etc.) in the United States in 2005, and the mix doesn't change rapidly from year to year, and a little less than 26 million of them are in multifamily housing structures (including two family structures that are not "single family attached"). Thus, about 24% of occupied housing units are apartments (or in condominium complexes). Owner occupied housing units (overwhelmingly, but not entirely single family homes and duplexes) average 2.7 persons per housing unit. Rental housing units (disproportionately apartments) average 2.39 persons per housing unit. Using those figures to make an estimate, roughly 22% of people live in multi-family housing.

Bottom line: your risk of death from residential fires is slightly lower in an apartment building than it is in a single family home.

Family MLK Lore

Every family has cherished lore. I picked up another piece of that from my father today (I think I had been told before, but forgot it), about our personal connection the the world of our legendary national hero, Martin Luther King, Jr., whose father, Martin Luther King, Sr., was the pastor of Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, Georgia, the city where I was born.

When we moved to Atlanta, we lived downtown, and went to Ebenezer Baptist Church when Mom was pregnant with you. Martin Luther King, Sr., was the pastor, and he was a colorful figure.


This can be added to the stories I remember about my parents days in Atlanta concerning the Hungry Club Forum at the Butler Street YMCA, one of city's famed citywide forums that sought (and still does, so far as I known) to prompt interracial dialog.

My parents were, of course, basically carpet bagger white northern liberals (hailing from the Upper Penninsula of Michigan and Northern Ohio, respectively) at the time they were in Atlanta, a group disproportionately represented among white Democrats in the South. They were brought there after my father's completion of graduate studies in engineering in California, when he took a position teaching civil engineering at Georgia Tech. They left around the time, as family lore goes, that I started counting "one, two, three, four, favh" to take a different life course in Southern Ohio.

Vote For Me!

There is an election on February 1, and there is a good chance that you won't get to vote in it. It is the reorganization election for the Denver Democrats, and only party officials, mostly precinct committee people, get to vote. I'm running to be the treasurer of the county party (in a county party organization that serves more Democrats than any other county party organization in the state). I am currently unopposed, so don't feel shy about endorsing me.

This job involves keeping the Denver Dems in compliance with tax, accounting and campaign finance requirements. It also involves chairing the finance committee that endeavors to develop a budget and raise the $65,000 a year the county party needs to continue functioning in a post-Bingo environment. And, it involves participating in executive commmittee meetings in the hopes that I can talk other members with grandious and expensive ideas from pursuing them unless they can find funding for them. As an attorney who does tax work and advises non-profits and political organizations on campaign finance and compliance issues, I stepped up to the plate.

You should vote for me because I'm running, and the other candidates aren't running. You should also vote for me because I promise to do my level best not to screw up, and because I have vague aspirations of actually improving the financial affairs of the county party with the help of a great group of highly active Democrats who have good ideas.

Of course, if you are a seasoned certified public accountant, who has years of experience running political party financial affairs, live in Denver, think the zero salary suits you, and really want to do the job, I will happily endorse you instead from the floor. If you fit this description, drop me a line.

15 January 2007

Martin Luther King, Jr. Day

Martin Luther King, Jr. was still a young man when he made his famous "I have a dream" speech, and he was younger still as he built up to the stature in the Civil Rights movement that could put a million people in the Washington Mall to hear him speak. He didn't live to be 40 years old.

He accomplished something that simple minded political science says should be impossible. He convinced a group with a political majority to end the legalized oppression of blacks in a country where the formal barriers to black political power seemed insurmountable. It would have been impossible if he had simply played by the rules.

He isn't the first to accomplish this end. Suffragists had done it. The people of India had done it. The lower classes of English had accomplished it. His own efforts were rooted in the knowledge of history that this was possible and he studied the methods used to achieve it. Those aged 18-20 achieve it.

Martin Luther King, Jr. won, ultimately, because he triumphed in the world of ideas, and because he got people to pay attention. The economist's notion that people always act in their own self-interest, while very useful in the economic sphere, is a less than accurate description of how people act in the world of politics. People routinely favor policies, good and bad, which are not in their narrow self-interests, out of a belief that it is the just stance to take.

These days, we still have young stand outs in the world of politics. But, today, most of these people, Andrew Romanoff in Colorado, for example, are remarkable as much for their mastery of the rules of the game and the players in it, as for changing ideas. Our political system has largely co-opted or defeated the rebels who seek to accomplish the impossible through direct action. Political outsiders capable of rallying crowds, bringing about change, and changing the psyche of a nation are rare. I'm hard put to identify any today, although perhaps there are some, and there are many who aspire to King's model.

Elaine Gantz Berman Takes State Ed Board Post

Elaine Gantz Berman was elected yesterday to the 1st Congressional District position on Colorado's Board of Education, filling a vacancy created when Rico Munn tendered his resignation in connection with his appointment to lead the Department of Regulatory Affairs in the Ritter Administration.

She will join a fiercely partisan board with 4 Republicans (the most polarizing of whom is Bob Schaffer) and 3 Democrats (including herself). Almost every Democrat present at the vacancy committee meeting soundly criticized the current Commissioner of Education, who is appointed by the Board and has served for the past ten years, as a serious impedement to positive change in the Department of Education.

Berman served eight years on the Denver School Board, ending two years ago. Half of those years, she served as President of the Board. She was nominated by Ken Gordon, who stressed her facility at working with a Republican Governor and legislature to accomplish something for Denver schools. She was a commanding orator herself, in a field of seven candidates for the post.

She won on the third round of balloting over Beverly Ausfahl, who served for six years as President of the Colorado Education Association, and took the hardest line against charter schools. All candidates expressed opposition to vouchers, but all but Ausfahl took a moderate line on charter schools (no candidate absolutely ruled them out in all cases).

Polly Baca, a former state senator with a long standing focus on education policy and current executive director of LARASA was removed from the running on the second ballot, despite numerous endorsements from sitting state legislators, as was Shawn Morris, a policy expert with two young children about to start school.

Three men, one with a policy consultant background, and the other two with experience as involved parents, also ran and were eliminated in the first round of voting.

The meeting was run, extraordinarily efficiently, by former Mayoral candidate Penfield Tate, in exactly two hours after check in was completed. About 54 people, easily a quorum, were present when the meeting convened, although the number present increased a little as stragglers came in slightly late. Each candidate had five minutes to speak (divided between any nominators and the candidate personally), and another two minutes to respond to a question about charter schools, vouchers and the candidate's priorities. Voting was by paper ballots pre-printed with the candidate's names and prepared on the spot. A large share of the elected officials and party notables in the 1st Congressional District were present.

Vote tallies at each round were not released publicly at the meeting. My understanding is that the top two candidates in the first round of voting were identical to those who made it to the final round of voting, and that the final round of voting was very close.

Honestly, there weren't huge differences on policy between the candidates. Experience was clearly important in the eyes of the vacancy committee members (myself among them), and Berman, Ausfahl and Baca all had a clear lead in this regard.

Berman joins the Board with basically two, non-exclusive, options: win the support of swing votes within the Republican majority, and use the threat of action from a united Democratic Governor and legislature to persaude the Republicans on the Board to be reasonable. It will be a challenging job.

Denver Special Election

My wife and I, and every other registered voter in Denver, should have recently received a mail in paper ballot for Denver's special election. If you haven't you should in the next couple of days. Thankfully, it is short. The only question posed on the ballot I received is whether Denver's Election Commission should be replaced by an Elected Clerk and Recorder. The returned ballot must be received by Denver officials by the end of January.

I urge you to vote no. Why?

1. The problem in Denver's most recent election were caused because the people in the positions did a bad job, not because having two elected and one appointed person, is worse than having one elected person. The Blue Ribbon panels that have looked into the matter have specifically found that the election commission structure wasn't the problem, and the proposal on the ballot ignores that advice. We have election commission elections to replace bad people, that doesn't require a change in the city charter.

2. Why should an election that went bad encourage us to put ministerial responsibilities that weren't screwed up by an elected official, like recording deeds and keeping track of city council business and issuing marriage licenses, under the authority of an elected official? This proposal exempts the DMV from the new clerk and recorder position, but not other similar duties of a clerk and recorder. If we are to have one elected official run elections, that official should be limited in authority to elections only.

3. Elected clerks and recorders screw up (as Douglas County proves) just as badly as an Election Commission does, but can do so without holding public meetings that warn us and give us a chance to try to head off disaster. An Election Commission, in contrast, operates publicly. This still can't head off bull headed commissioners who won't listen to advice from the public, but it can prevent accidental screw ups.

4. The political norms that discourage Democrats from challenging incumbent Democrats, in a jurisdiction dominanted by Democrats will make it harder to oust a bad clerk and recorder, because people have a very strong tendency to vote on party lines in general elections. Look at the voters of Arapahoe County who voted in Republican Tracy Baker to be their clerk and recorder, even when he was known to be a sexually harassing screw up who later had to be recalled. I understand that the election in Denver, unlike that elsewhere in the state, will be non-partisan. But, that will likely be only a sham.

This is a bad idea. Fortunately, even if Denver voters screw up and vote for it, the consequences may not be terribly serious. Either way, elections will go on being conducted in Denver, and when good people are elected to run them, they will go well. But, going from a less than ideal system, to one that is worse, won't help the matter at all.

11 January 2007

Sunni Exodus From Iraq?

The conservative military website Strategy Page is making some strong assertions about what is going on in Iraq right now. The more political it gets, the less accurate it tends to become, but it is worth getting this version of the story out there to discuss.

It argues that ethnic cleansing of Sunni Arabs has proceeded at a scale much greater than press accounts have previously suggested, and is essentially a fait accompli in Baghdad itself.

[R]adio and print calls to arms [have been] circulating in Sunni neighborhoods recently. Armed Sunni Arabs are urged to go to Baghdad, to fight the decisive battle to keep Baghdad Sunni. That battle has already been lost, but the noise level on the Sunni side has reached epic levels because the Shia death squads are now invading solidly Sunni neighborhoods. There are no more safe havens for Sunnis in Baghdad. The men of Anbar (the Sunni heartland west of Baghdad) are being called in to save Baghdad. That has led to some spectacular street battles in the last few days. But all of these have ended with a lot of dead Sunnis. The Battle of Baghdad has been lost, but the fighting will go on for a while. The Sunni Arabs are dead-men-walking, and more of them will have to be put in the ground before the majority admit they are beat.

What the United States is trying to avoid is a massacre of the Sunni Arabs. The new military operation will disarm many of the Sunni Arabs who guard Sunni Arab neighborhoods. Unless the Shia militias, and their death squads are also crippled, the Shia will kill and terrorize Sunni Arabs on a large scale. . . .

About half the Sunni Arabs of Iraq have been driven from their homes so far. Some 60 percent of those have left the country, while the others have taken refuge in areas where Sunni Arabs are the majority. There are far fewer "mixed" (Sunni and Shia) neighborhoods in Iraq today, and there will be a lot fewer in the future. In 2006 alone, about ten percent of the Sunni Arab population was driven from their homes, and either left the country or settled elsewhere in Iraq.

Each month, 50-100,000 Iraqis, mostly Sunni Arabs, leave the country. There are nearly a million Iraqi refugees in Syria, about 700,000 in Jordan, nearly 100,000 in Egypt, about 40,000 in Lebanon, and about 20,000 in Turkey. Over a hundred thousand have fled further still, to Europe and the Americas. The U.S. is trying to keep Sunni Arab refugees out, as it is believed many of them would be inclined to support Sunni Arab terrorist groups like al Qaeda, and seek revenge against the United States.


If 30% of Sunni Arabs have become external refugees (dropping their share of the nation's population from about 20% to about 14%), and another 20% are internal refugees (from "mixed areas" to predominantly Sunni areas), and a large share of all Sunni Arabs who aren't refugees lived in predominantly Sunni Arab places in the first place, this has immense implications for a political solution.

The impact on Syria, Lebanon and Jordan, already awash in Palestinian refugees, could be particularly intense. And, with many internally displaced Sunnis pouring into strongholds in Western Iraq and leaving behind mostly Shiites in the Southeast and central part of the country, the prospects of a Syrian annexation of West Iraq and Iranian annexation of East Iraq, with the North becoming an independent Kurdistan doesn't seem as out of the question as it did when the conflict began and the population was much more ethnically mixed.

Other accounts I've heard about those leaving the country suggest that those going abroad are primarily the middle and upper middle professional and managerial class of Iraq, which is particularly a blow to Baghdad, one of the few centers of the Islamic Middle East which is economically vibrant based upon its people, rather than its oil alone. So, the refugees may not be all bad news for Syria, Lebanon and Jordan. But, the people who would be the most plausible targets for Sunni political buy in to a new regime, may be irrevocably gone already. Also, notably, almost none of the Iraqi Sunni Arab migration appears to be to the oil rich Sunni Arab monarchies to the South.

Like Bosnia, Iraq was not strictly divided on ethnic lines when the war began, but if this account is correct, it looks likely that it will, like Bosnia, be almost completely divided on ethinc lines by the time the war is over.

Partition is happening, with or without a formal governmental sanction for it. At this rate, by the time President Bush leaves office, diplomacy and a political solution may simply be a matter of ratifying a de facto partition already carved out in blood, and the Sunni Arab Iraqi disaspora may become as permanent a part of the world political situation as the intractable status of the Palestinians.

The Bush Administration, of course, has not so much as mentioned the ethnic cleansing dynamic that is going on in Iraq, and indeed, doesn't seem to have much of a grip on what dynamics, if any, are driving the country.

Polis, Rico Munn's Vacancy and 41

Yesterday, I returned a call I'd received from Jared Polis. Polis had the grace and generousity to a candidate in a vacancy race he was calling to support, to take time out of his own retirement party to take my call, which speaks well of his commitment to public service. I, of course, recognized him as a state board of education member, a leading patron of the Colorado Democratic Party and the principal financial and intellectual force behind the flawed Amendment 41 passed by voters last fall. He recognized me as a blogger, although he was calling me in my capacity as one of the Democratic Party muckety mucks who is on the vacancy committee for Denver's state board of education seat.

Attorney Rico Munn has joined Governor Ritter's cabinet as executive director of the Department of Regulatory Affairs, largely a consumer protection post. This created a vacancy on the board. The vacancy election will be held January 14th (this Sunday) in the afternoon, at the State Democratic Party headquarters on Sante Fe drive in Denver.

Polis backed Polly Baca, who had previously called me personally seeking my support for the post. I've been through the vacancy fire drill several times before and provided the standard operating procedure response. I heard each one out, asked a question or two, and stated that I appreciated hearing their plea, but would not commit. This is almost always the right thing to do because unless you know someone personally and are already very familiar with the candidates in the race, you never know who else might be running. Voting in vacancy elections is generally preceded by speeches from each candidate, and those speeches often say a lot about each person's agenda and character, so it pays to wait before committing.

Between the two calls, I know something about her now, but since I don't know who else is running, I'm not sure whether she is one of the better candidates in the race or not. She is a political veteran and has fire in her belly, but a hear that she isn't terribly popular with the Colorado Education Association.

Polly Baca's approach is the usual way one campaigns for a vacancy. The campaign experience she developed as a state senator and community organizer shows she is aware of how things are usually done. There are only a few hundred potential voters on the vacancy committee, and one's objective is to call as many people as you can before the election. I haven't yet heard from the other candidates for the post, but have heard through the grape vine that at least two or three other candidates are running.

Between hearding directly from Ms. Baca, and hearing from Polis, I received another rumor that Baca was a strong voucher supporter, so I raised the issue with him. He advised me that this was not true (in considerably stronger language than that) even though he'd been the target of similar accusations, but that both he and Baca did favor charter schools and generally favored making more choices available to school children.

Polis largely pitched the asset Baca would offer the board as a strong representative of the state's Hispanic community (not the world's most impressive qualification standing alone, even though it is not meaningless, what really matters about a candiate is what he or she plans to do if elected), and also noted the name of another candidate who is quite solid if I was set against Baca.

This was interesting, although even in a brief conversation with Polis, you quickly get the feel that he has an instinct for the compromises that make sense in the business world, but fails to recognize that compromise plays out differently in politics, and it is clear that he lacks the strong persausive ability to close the deal that some politicians naturally possess.

* * * *

Jared Polis is one of those notable Colorado political figures about whom it is easy to have mixed feelings.

I've spoken to him personally and heard him speak at political events a few other times, all briefly, as well as yesterday. He is a sincerely nice guy, who really does care. He is willing to be bold in taking action, and he isn't stupid -- he graduated from Princeton and has run several successful businesses. But, this isn't to say that he is always on the ball either.

The state board of education, upon which he is a vice chair, while weak in any case, has not been particularly effective during his tenure. Reports I've had heard from various people who have attended the board's meetings have been tinged with disgust at a board that is disorganized, politically overheated, and hasn't shown much respect to the real tasks before them or the people who have come to testify on those matters. Part of this has come from an even partisan divide between Democrats and Republicans on the Board (my understanding, which may be incorrect, is that the at large seat held by Polis is being phased out this year, returning the board to an odd number of seats and Republican control), but this is only part of the issue. Personalities matter and when the group doesn't function well, this is a shared responsiblity.

Polis, while I don't doubt he was well intentioned, has done a deep disservice to this state by proposing and securing approval for Amendment 41. This ethics in government measure imposes a strict gift ban and other restrictions on elected officials, senior appointees and their family members, and this is all well and good, and is the reason that Colorado voters backed the measure. The basic idea has some merit.

But, Amendment 41, which can be clarified by legislation, but only amended or repealed by a vote of the people, also imposes the same extremely strict gift ban on every single ordinary government employee or government independent contractor in the state and their families, no matter how mundane their post, without requiring any nexus between the gift and official action of that person.

This insidious provision has the effect of making public employment far less desirable in the State, and it is likely to work a real hardship on ordinary people with innocent motives. It is an aburd provision that voters approved only because few of them were not aware of it -- a classic flaw in the process of making law by initiative. So, Amendment 41 bans not only gifts to state legislators, but also gifts, for example, to the child of a state file clerk, or the spouse of state patrol officer, or contact website developer for the state.

On the other hand, Polis has provided a lynch pin of support for the Democrats in Colorado which deserves credit as a substantial force that has helped bring the party to control of both houses of the Colorado General Assembly, and the Governorship. And, I don't doubt that he was well intentioned, even in measures like Amendment 41 and his efforts on the state board of education. Indeed, had he not won the at large seat on the state board, which his background of stunning business success and willingness to support his own campaign helped secure, there is a real likelihood that rather than merely being ineffectual, it would have actually screwed up education in the state. Now, with Democrats in charge of the levers of state power, this is far less of a concern. Legislation can circumvent most bad decisions of the Board.

The book isn't closed, but this political scion's track record and credibility are mixed at this point. It will be interesting to see if Polis does anything to redeem himself in the next few years. As it stands, his stumbles have made him an unattractive candidate to replace Mark Udall in Colorado's 2nd Congressional District, a post he is rumored to have an eye on.

* * * *

I received another call asking for support from Shawn Morris. Her background is in public policy and Texas politics, she has children currently too young to be in the Denver Public Schools, and she has taught undergraduates at Denver's Auraria Campus. In short, her resume certainly isn't up there with Baca, but she clearly has a clue.

She said she was anti-voucher, expressed skeptism about charter schools not subject to the same rules that other Colorado schools were held to (although she was not against them) and felt that the high school system in Colorado needs to be greatly reformed to make students better prepared for college if they are going, and to bring education in skilled trades back into the education system.

* * * *

I'll try to write more about the vacancy race when and if I know more about the other candidates. If you have anything to say about any of the candidates, feel free to offer it in the comments. Either way, I'll offer a report on the fireworks on Sunday once its over, and I suspect that this will be more heated than many vacancy elections.

But, it is worth saying that the result won't make or break many political equations in the state. Any replacement will, of course, be a Democrat, so the partisan balance of the board will be unchanged. It is also a weak political body.

Unlike state boards of education in many states (Ohio, Texas and Kansas come to mind), Colorado's state board of education can't dictate textbooks or curriculums to local school boards. It can't, for example, impose creationism on the state.

The most important K-12 state level education decisions each year, those contained in the state budget (the education budget has to be completed before the rest of the budget, to allow boards time to make personnel decisions for the coming school year), are made by the legislature and not the state board of education. The most important powers that the state board of education does have in Colorado are to:

1. License teachers.
2. Handle appeals of local school district refusals to grant school charters.
3. Supervise the CSAP (state testing) and school report card process.
4. Coordinate the process of awarding state and federal grant money to school districts.

10 January 2007

Opening Day

Colorado's General Assembly convened today. I watched from the House gallery.

Most of the affair is pomp, circumstance, uncontroversial organizing votes and scripted formalities. The most notable piece of that was the insistance of a freshman Republican on having the election results read aloud, and the choice of a rather liberal Rabbi to give the invocation.

The main events on opening day are the Speaker's speech and the Minority Leader's speech. Both men, Andrew Romanoff and Mark May, kept the powder dry, in stark contrast to a more combative speech by Joe Stengle last year.

Andrew Romanoff's speech echoed the priorities which Governor Ritter has set -- a bread and butter agenda of education, health care, fiscal responsiblity, dealing with Amendment 41 and renewable energy. May's speech chose to identify largely the same issue priorities, and emphasize a different, but not radically different approach to the issues. He also made a big strategic move by getting religion on the question of campaign finance and ethics reform.

He continued discussion of the need to rethink education in ways that he conceded were "radical." Few of the proposals were starkly partisan. He favored shifting the focus of evaluating schools on the value added by the school, not the absolute test scores of a school's children. May's speech emphasized the importance of maintaining accountability and of protecting the role of alternatives to traditional public schools like charter schools, home schooling and online learning.

Both men expressed the notion that improvements could be made in health care costs and that the number of uninsured people was a problem. Both felt that some action could be taken in advance of a report from the state blue ribbon commission working on the issue. Neither was terribly specific. Romanoff's most concrete proposal was one to use the state's buying prices to buy generic drugs for the elderly and uninsured at a good price.

Both the Speaker and Minority Leader identified transmission lines, to take alternative energy from rural areas to cities where it is needed, as a lynch pin of their renewable energy agenda. The Speaker favored expanding the voter approved mandate for renewable energy percentages, the Minority Leader emphasized the importance of using incentives rather than mandates. These are differences to be sure, but are hardly the stuff of political fireworks.

Both men expressed a strong desire to control spending. The Speaker called any attempt to introduce a bill requiring an appropriation without a way to pay for it irresponsible. The Speaker framed the issue of changing criminal laws to better prevent recidivism as a fiscal issue.

The games have begun. Now, we will see what comes of them.

04 January 2007

Zombies and Us

Shopping for my dad this winter on Amazon, I was presented with two books providing advice on how to survive a zombie attack. My radio this morning brought me a ballad recounting a zombie attack in an American suburb. I actually rather enjoyed both encounters with this non-existent threat.

The human race spent 90,000 years as hunters and gatherers (and our predecessor species spent many more hundreds of thousands of years doing the same -- the technologies we read about in comic book stereotypes of the stone age like stone tools, spears and fire were invented even before the human race arose).

We've had another 10,000 years or so (about 400 generations) of life in small agricultural villages, cities and outposts to evolve out of the roughest edges of our hunter and gatherer lifestyle. For example, people who had such intense wanderlust that they couldn't stick around for the next season's crops mostly died, except for a few gypsies who have paid dearly for their indulgence of that tendency. Likewise, people who failed to adapt biologically and socially to the demands of exposure to the diseases that come from close and frequent exposure to farm animals and living in settled quarters died off.

But, the last dozen or so generations, coupled with improved healthcare, have left the hard wiring in place. Instincts acquired for in millions of years of mammalian evolution (most of the traits poetically associated with being truly human, our raw emotional capacities, we share with almost all mammals), and then in years of violent primative societies wear war was a fact of life and war meant fighting face to face within walking distance of your home, are still there.

We haven't outgrown them. Action movies appeal to our hard wired mammalian fight and flight instinctual systems. Horror movies too bypass our rational thinking process to go right for our hard wired fear triggers. And, T&A appeals in romances are also appeals to our instincts -- instincts still working well enough that only about 2% of us die virgins. Before we had movies and TV, civilization turned to gladiators performing live in stadiums and orgies in pagan temples to funnel those instincts safely.

The trouble is, that we've used the brain power that has set us apart from other mammals to conquer the planet. We've created a world for ourselves where our natural instincts don't work anymore. We're built to fight wars with legions of slow moving, walking assailants, using hand held weapons and shields, wars againt zombie-like foes. But, our engineers have made war a far more cerebral affair. Now, the winner is, as often as not, determined by technological preparations made in cold blood long before the battle, not primarily through extraordinary heart. We still honor heros with medals, but heros are no longer the primary means by which wars are won.

If we want our conquest to end up in something other than a dramatic decline and fall, we are going to have to grow up as a society, evolve socially that is, and find a way to societally develop instincts that individually don't come naturally to us. We have to master war and learn to plan ahead to stop us from outrunning our resources or devistating the world we live in. This is the biggest challenge facing us in the 21st century as a society. Unless we can keep our intellect focused on facing the problems created by our mature society, and our instincts diverted by fantasy wars with zombies, we really are in trouble.

03 January 2007

New European Union members

On January 1, Bulgaria and Romainia became the newest members of the European Union (EU), bringing the EU's population to 493 million.


From here.

The European Union has more people than the United States, Canada and Mexico combined. It has economic divides almost as stark as the NAFTA three. It does so with no internal limitations on immigration in the long term. There are some limits for a transitional period however:

Worried about the potential of being overwhelmed by workers moving from poorer, new Member States to richer old ones, the treaties governing the accession of new members have a "transitional" clause that allows existing Member States to restrict the free movement of "accession" workers for up to seven years.

This is the same provision that enabled 12 of the then-15 existing EU members (EU-15) to place limitations on workers from eight eastern European accession countries that joined the EU in 2004 (the A-8). There were no restrictions for nationals from Malta and the Greek-controlled portion of Cyprus, the two other countries that joined in 2004.

As in 2004, the majority of the EU-15 have placed short-term limitations on the number of new eastern European accession nationals they will allow into their labor markets. Of the EU-15 who chose restriction in 2004, only Finland has decided to allow free access in this round of enlargement. Sweden, which had a liberal regime in 2004, will again be open to labor migrants.

The UK and Ireland, which allowed free movement to A-8 workers, have announced restrictive measures.


Who is in the E.U. and when did they join?

1952–58 – Belgium, France, Italy, Luxembourg, West Germany*, Netherlands (*in 1990 reunified with former East Germany, Algeria was an integral part of France until 1962)
1973 – Denmark, Ireland, United Kingdom (*Greenland leaves 1985)
1981 – Greece
1986 – Portugal, Spain
1995 – Austria, Finland, Sweden
2004 – Czech Republic, Cyprus, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia
2007 – Bulgaria, Romania

The transition period for the 2004 entrants ends in 2011. The transition period for this year's entrants ends in 2018.

Agency Costs

When managers of a company act in a way that is at odds with the interest of the owners of a company, in economics, this is called "agency costs."

Dale Oesterle at the Business Law Profs blog, looks at transactions in which senior management and venture capitalists have made huge profits by taking a public company private, refinancing it, and then making a new public offering of the same company, has some pointed questions to ask about agency costs.

The troublesome question: Why are the assets not better managed in the hands of the public firm managers for the benefit of the public firm shareholders? Is the agency cost in publicly traded firms as large as is suggested by the profits of private equity funds? Or have the private equity funds just picked the low hanging fruit? If the problem is endemic, where have regulations failed? Henry Manne argues in todays WSJ that we have over regulated takeovers. Others argue that we have under regulated public company managers. It does suggest that our fixation on executive salary excess is a drop in the bucket compared to losses due to sloppy management of many of our publicly traded companies.


My conclusion: The single biggest problem is that members of the boards of directors of publicly held companies are elected on Soviet style ballots. There is no meaningful legal way for shareholders to control publicly held corporations short of having a single individual or small consorstium of new buyers purchase a majority of the stock.

The elections themselves are clean, but they are shams, because there is no meaningful opportunity for shareholders to nominate board members who will appear on the ballot.

Incidentally, I also agree that "executive salary excess is a drop in the bucket compared to losses due to sloppy management of many of our publicly traded companies", although I think the former is a symptom of the latter.

New Hopes For A New Year

Capitol Hill in Denver isn't Washington D.C., but it is a place where change is possible. It runs on hope. It is driven by people who believe change in possible. Its natural instinct is to reform.

And, the natives of this power center couldn't be happier when Denver Post columnist Al Knight, a conservative crummudgen, is talking about the merits of Governor-elect Ritter's Colorado Promise positions on ethanol. The subject of the story, and not its content, is the message. Democrats are setting the agenda now. The punditocracy, in turn, is responding to it.

His arguments are interesting too. Knight opposes ethanol is large part by decrying huge federal subsidies for corn, maintained by Republicans, which are currently one factor that makes E-85 cost competitive. At the same time, Knight is arguing that ethanol may be a problem because it is driving up the cost of corn which impacts supermarket prices.

Al Knight doesn't connect the dots, but his criticism of the Colorado Promise invites a win-win solution. The obvious conclusion is that some of the $25 billion a year in farm subsidies which Republicans have maintained over the past twelve years in Washington, might be unnecessary is ethanol demand made rural corn production more profitable.

Moreover, this is no coincidence. While Knight is stuck in old mindsets, Ritter's agenda has very much focused on ways to make the rural economy profitable not by clinging to increasingly economically unsustainable business models, but by finding new profit centers many of which are rooted in a new energy economy.

If it works, Democrats might have a formula for winning back the rural voters it held fast during the very rural oriented New Deal, but subsequently lost as the parties differences on rural economic issues dissolved, and conservative religious sentiment on social issues in rural areas and a general hostility to regulation and taxation of small businesses became the driving force behind the transition to the Republican party. There aren't all that many farmers in the electorate, but the intensity of their tendency to vote against Democrats makes them a force to be reckoned with. Ritter and both Salazars in Colorado have started to break this monolithic opposition to Democrats.

Of course, it also adds hope to your day when the Governor-elect is having his coffee at the table over from you in your neighborhood coffee shop, as he was this morning (although nothing in this post is a result of that coincidence) and lives in your state house district. While I don't always see eye to eye with him, I can be very comfortable that he is aware of the reality I see and live in every day.

Ritter is someone who has come from rural roots to live in the City and can see both sides of the fence. That is a valuable thing in a Governor, which is why the seemingly silly debate in the 2006 campaign over who had more cow milking experience mattered.

29 December 2006

Animal Taxonomy

From Wikipedia again (with related links):

Subregnum Parazoa
--Phylum Porifera (sponges) (5000 species, including 150 fresh water species)
--- Class Calcarea (bony)
--- Class Hexactenellida (glass)
--- Class Demospongiae (spongin) (90% of sponges)
Subregnum Eumetazoa
---Phylum Placozoa (2 species, 1 seen only once in 1896 (doubtful), soft-bodied, about 0.5 mm across, and somewhat resemble a large amoeba)
---Phylum Orthonectida (2 families, 5 genus, 20 species, tiny parasits of marine invertibates)
---Phylum Rhombozoa (cephalopod parasites under 1 cm in salt water)
-----Family Conocyemidae
-----Family Dicyemidae.
-Radiata (unranked)
---Phylum Ctenophora (comb jellies) (100 species)
-----Class Tentaculata (tenticles, make up by far the largest number of species)
------Order Cydippida, which includes the sea gooseberry (Pleurobrachia pileus)
------Order Platyctenida
------Order Ganeshida
------Order Thalassocalycida
------Order Lobata
------Order Cestida, which includes the Venus' belt (Cestum veneris)
-----Class Nuda (no tenticles)
------Order Beroida (includes the melon jelly (Beroe gracilis))
---Phylum Cnidaria (sea anemones, corals, and jellyfish) 11,000 species
-----Class Anthozoa (anemones, corals, etc.)
------Subclass Alcyonaria (= Octocorallia) (eight tentacles)
-------Order Alcyonacea (soft corals)
-------Order Gorgonacea (sea fans, sea feathers)
-------Order Helioporacea (Indo Pacific blue coral)
-------Order Pennatulacea (sea pens and sea pansies)
-------Order Stolonifera (organ pipe coral)
------Subclass Zoantharia (= Hexacorallia) (more than 8 tentacles - typically 12)
-------Order Antipatharia (black corals, thorny corals)
-------Order Scleractinia (=Madreporaria) (stony corals)
-------Order Corallimorpharia
-------Order Ptychodactiaria
------Subclass Hexacorallia (Sea anemones)
-------Order Actiniaria (4 suborders, 46 families)
--------Suborder Endocoelantheae
--------Suborder Nyantheae
--------Suborder Protantheae
--------Suborder Ptychodacteae
-----Class Scyphozoa (jellyfish)
------Order Stauromedusae (stalked jellyfish)
----------Family Cleistocarpidae
----------Family Eleutherocarpidae
----------Family Kyopodidae
----------Family Tesseranthidae
------Order Coronatae (crown jellyfish)
----------Family Atollidae
----------Family Atorellidae
----------Family Collaspididae
----------Family Linuchidae
----------Family Nausithoidae
----------Family Paraphyllinidae
----------Family Periphyllidae
----------Family Tetraplatidae
------Order Semaeostomeae (flag mouth jellyfish)
----------Family Cyaneidae
----------Family Depastridae
----------Family Halicyathidae
----------Family Pelagiidae
----------Family Ulmaridae
------Order Rhizostomae (no tenticles jellyfish)
--------Suborder Daktyliophorae
----------Family Catostylidae
----------Family Lobonematidae
----------Family Lychnorhizidae
----------Family Rhizostomatidae
----------Family Stomolophidae
--------Suborder Kolpophorae
----------Family Cassiopeidae
----------Family Cepheidae
----------Family Mastigiidae
----------Family Thysanostomatidae
----------Family Versurigidae
-----Class Cubozoa (box jellies including sea wasps)
----------Family Chirodropidae (4 genus, 7 species)
----------Family Carybdeidae (5 genus, 12 species)
-----Class Hydrozoa (Obelia, Aequorea, Portuguese Man o' War, etc.)
------Subclass Anthomedusae
------Subclass Laingiomedusae
------Subclass Leptomedusae
------Subclass Limnomedusae
------Subclass Siphonophorae
------Subclass Actinulidae
------Subclass Narcomedusae
------Subclass Trachymedusae

-Bilateria (unranked)
---Phylum Acoelomorpha
----Class Acoela (gutless flatworms)
----Class Nemertodermatida
---Phylum Myxozoa tiny, multistage fish and worm parasites)
----Class Malacosporea
----Class Myxosporea
---Phylum Chaetognatha (predatory marine worms in plankton, 3-120mm, 15 genus, 100 species)
----Class Archisagittoidea
----Class Sagittoidea
--Superphylum Deuterostomia
---Phylum Chordata (see separate post)
---Phylum Hemichordata (100 species)
----Class Enteropneusta (acorn worms)
----Class Pterobranchia
----Class Planctosphaeroidea (1 species, seen in one life cycle stage only)
---Phylum Echinodermata (7000 species)
----Class Asteroidea (asteroids, starfish, or sea stars): about 1,500 species that capture prey for their own food.
----Class Concentricycloidea (sea daisies), notable for their unique water vascular system; two species; recently merged into Asteroidea.
----Class Crinoidea (crinoids, feather stars or sea lilies): about 600 species that are suspension feeders.
----Class Echinoidea (echinoids, sea urchins and sand dollars): notable for their movable spines; about 1,000 species.
----Class Holothuroidea (sea cucumbers): elongated animals resembling slugs; about 1,000 species.
----Class Ophiuroidea (brittle stars and basket stars), the physically largest of echinoderms; about 1,500 species.
---Phylum Xenoturbellida (two marine worm-like species in one genus)
--Superphylum Ecdysozoa
---Phylum Kinorhyncha
---Phylum Loricifera (marine sediment-dwelling animals with about a twenty-one known species in six genera)
---Phylum Priapulida (penis worm, lives in mud in shallow sea water, 7 genera)
----Class Priapulimorpha
-----Order Priapulimorphida
------Family Priapulidae
-------Genus Acanthopriapulus
-------Genus Priapulopsis
-------Genus Priapulus
------Family Tubiluchidae
-------Genus Meiopriapulus
-------Genus Tubiluchus
----Class Halicryptomorpha
-----Order Halicryptomorphida
------Family Halicryptidae
-------Genus Halicryptus
----Class Seticoronaria
-----Order Seticoronarida
------Family Maccabeidae
-------Genus Maccabeus
---Phylum Nematoda
---Phylum Nematomorpha
---Phylum Onychophora
---Phylum Tardigrada
---Phylum Arthropoda
--Superphylum Platyzoa
---Phylum Platyhelminthes
---Phylum Gastrotricha
---Phylum Rotifera
---Phylum Acanthocephala
---Phylum Gnathostomulida
---Phylum Micrognathozoa
---Phylum Cycliophora
--Superphylum Lophotrochozoa
---Phylum Sipuncula
---Phylum Nemertea
---Phylum Phoronida
---Phylum Ectoprocta
---Phylum Bryozoa
---Phylum Entoprocta
---Phylum Brachiopoda
---Phylum Mollusca
---Phylum Annelida

Cordata Taxonomy

Cordata Taxonomy From Wikipedia (exitinct branches of the taxonomy suppressed), some information from links to the link above:

Phylum Chordata

-Subphylum Urochordata - Tunicates (tadpole like in youth, adults are fixed to a single location)
--Class Ascidiacea (Aplousobranchia, Phlebobranchia, and Stolidobranchia),
--Class Thaliacea,
--Class Appendicularia (Larvacea)
--Class Sorberacea.
[Newer evidence indicates that the Ascidiacea is an artificial group. The new classification would then look like this.]
-- Class Stolidobranchia,
-- Class Phlebobranchia and Thaliacea,
-- Class Aplousobranchia and Appendicularia,
-- Class Sorberacea would belong somewhere in Ascidiacea, or be in a taxon on its own

-Subphylum Cephalochordata - Lancelets (minnow sized sand worm like creatures)
Other sources show that there are up to thirty species.
--Family Asymmetronidæ (3 species in 2 genus)
--Family Branchiostomidæ (8 species in 1 genus)

-Subphylum Vertebrata (Vertebrates - animals with backbones)

--Infraphylum Agnatha (jawless vertebrates) (91 species)
---Class Myxini or Hyperotreti (hagfish) (50 species in 7 genus)
---Class Hyperoartia (Lampreys)
----One Class Cephalaspidomorphi, Order Petromyzontiformes and Family Petromyzontidae
-----Subfamily Geotriinae (1 species in 1 genus)
-----Subfamily Mordaciinae (3 species in 1 genus)
-----Subfamily Petromyzontinae (37 species in 7 genus)

-Infraphylum Gnathostomata (jawed vertebrates)

--Class Chondrichthyes (cartilaginous fish)
---Subclass Elasmobranchii (sharks, rays and skates)
----Superorder Batoidea (rays and skates)
----- Order Rajiformes (common rays and skates)
------ Family Anacanthobatidae (smooth skates)
------ Family Dasyatidae (stingrays).
------ Family Gymnuridae (butterfly rays)
------ Family Hexatrygonidae (sixgill stingrays)
------ Family Myliobatidae (eagle rays).
------ Family Plesiobatidae (deepwater stingrays)
------ Family Potamotrygonidae (river stingrays)
------ Family Rajidae (skates)
------ Family Rhinobatidae (guitarfishes).
------ Family Urolophidae (round rays)
----- Order Pristiformes (Sawfishes) (7 species in 2 genus)
----- Order Torpediniformes (electric rays) (69 species in 4 families)
----Superorder Selachimorpha (sharks)
----- Order Hexanchiformes
------ Family Chlamydoselachidae (1 species in 1 genus)
------ Family Hexanchidae (4 species in 3 genus)
----- Order Squaliformes (More than 80 species)
------ Family Echinorhinidae (bramble sharks) (2 genus, at least 3 species)
------ Family Centrophoridae (gulper sharks) (2 genus, 15 species)
------ Family Dalatiidae (sleeper sharks) (4 subfamilies, 17 genus)
------ Family Squalidae (dogfish sharks) (2 genus, 17 speciees)
----- Order Pristiophoriformes One family, 2 genus, 9 species.
----- Order Squatiniformes (angel sharks) One family, 1 genus, 19 species.
----- Order Heterodontiformes (horn sharks) One family, 1 genus, 10 species.
----- Order Orectolobiformes (carpet sharks) Seven families.
------Order Carcharhiniformes (ground sharks) Eight families and almost 200 species.
----- Order Lamniformes (Marckerel sharks)
-------Family Alopiidae (thresher sharks) (4 species)
-------Family Cetorhinidae (basking shark) (1 species)
-------Family Lamnidae (mackerel sharks) (3 genus with a total of 5 species)
-------Family Megachasmidae (megamouth shark) (1 species)
-------Family Mitsukurinidae (goblin shark) (1 species)
-------Family Carchariidae (sand tigers) (2 species)
-------Family Odontaspididae (Raggedtooths) (2 species)
-------Family Pseudicarchariidae (crocodile shark) (1 species)
---Subclass Holocephali (chimaera aka ghost sharks)
-------Family Callorhinchidae (3 species in 1 genus)
-------Family Chimaeridae (29 species in 2 genus)
-------Family Rhinochimaeridae (9 species in 2 genus)

-Superclass Osteichthyes (bony fishes)
--Class Actinopterygii (ray-finned fish) (27,000 species)
---Subclass Chondrostei
------Order Polypteriformes, including the bichirs and reedfishes
------Order Acipenseriformes, including the sturgeons and paddlefishes
---Subclass Neopterygii
----Infraclass Holostei
------Order Lepisosteiformes, the gars
------Order Amiiformes, the bowfins
----Infraclass Teleostei
-----Superorder Osteoglossomorpha
------Order Osteoglossiformes, the bony-tongued fishes
------Order Hiodontiformes, including the mooneye and goldeye
-----Superorder Elopomorpha
------Order Elopiformes, including the ladyfishes and tarpon
------Order Albuliformes, the bonefishes
------Order Notacanthiformes, including the halosaurs and spiny eels
------Order Anguilliformes, the true eels and gulpers
------Order Saccopharyngiformes, including the gulper eel
-----Superorder Clupeomorpha
------Order Clupeiformes, including herrings and anchovies
-----Superorder Ostariophysi
------Order Gonorynchiformes, including the milkfishes
------Order Cypriniformes, including barbs, carp, danios, goldfishes, loaches, minnows, rasboras
------Order Characiformes, including characins, pencilfishes, hatchetfishes, piranhas, tetras.
------Order Gymnotiformes, including electric eels and knifefishes
------Order Siluriformes, the catfishes
-----Superorder Protacanthopterygii
------Order Salmoniformes, including salmon and trout
------Order Esociformes the pike
------Order Osmeriformes, including the smelts and galaxiids
-----Superorder Stenopterygii
------Order Ateleopodiformes, the jellynose fish
------Order Stomiiformes, including the bristlemouths and marine hatchetfishes
-----Superorder Cyclosquamata
------Order Aulopiformes, including the Bombay duck and lancetfishes
-----Superorder Scopelomorpha
------Order Myctophiformes, including the lanternfishes
-----Superorder Lampridiomorpha
------Order Lampriformes, including the oarfish, opah and ribbonfishes
-----Superorder Polymyxiomorpha
------Order Polymixiiformes, the beardfishes
-----Superorder Paracanthopterygii
------Order Percopsiformes, including the cavefishes and trout-perches
------Order Batrachoidiformes, the toadfishes
------Order Lophiiformes, including the anglerfishes
------Order Gadiformes, including cods
------Order Ophidiiformes, including the pearlfishes
-----Superorder Acanthopterygii
------Order Mugiliformes, the mullets
------Order Atheriniformes, including silversides and rainbowfishes
------Order Beloniformes, including the flyingfishes
------Order Cetomimiformes, the whalefishes
------Order Cyprinodontiformes, including livebearers, killifishes
------Order Stephanoberyciformes, including the ridgeheads
------Order Beryciformes, including the fangtooths and pineconefishes
------Order Zeiformes, including the dories
------Order Gobiesociformes, the clingfishes
------Order Gasterosteiformes including sticklebacks, pipefishes, seahorses
------Order Syngnathiformes, including the seahorses and pipefishes
------Order Synbranchiformes, including the swamp eels
------Order Tetraodontiformes, including the filefishes and pufferfish
------Order Pleuronectiformes, the flatfishes
------Order Scorpaeniformes, including scorpionfishes and the weaver fish
------Order Perciformes 40% of all fish including anabantids, bass, cichlids, gobies, gouramis, mackerel, perches, scats, whiting, wrasses

--Class Sarcopterygii (lobe-finned fish)
---Coelacanths (1 subclass, 1 order, 1 family, 1 genus, 2 species)
---Subclass Dipnoi (Lungfish) (6 species)
-----Order Ceratodontiformes (1 family, 1 genus, 1 species)
-----Order Lepidosireniformes
-------Family Lepidosirenidae - South American lungfish (1 species)
-------Family Protopteridae - African lungfish (4 species)

-Superclass Tetrapoda (four-legged vertebrates)

--Class Amphibia (amphibians)
---Subclass Lissamphibia (frogs, salamanders, etc)
----Superorder Salientia
-----Order Anura (frogs and toads) 5,296 species
------Suborder Archaeobatrachia, which includes 28 species of primitive frogs
-------Family Ascaphidae
-------Family Bombinatoridae
-------Family Discoglossidae
-------Family Leiopelmatidae
------Suborder Mesobatrachia, which includes 6 families of more evolutionary intermediate frogs, 20 genera and 168 species
------Suborder Neobatrachia, 24 families of "modern" frogs, 5000 species (96% of frogs)
-------Family Allophrynidae
-------Family Arthroleptidae
-------Family Astylosternidae
-------Family Brachycephalidae
-------Family Bufonidae
-------Family Centrolenidae
-------Family Dendrobatidae
-------Family Heleophrynidae
-------Family Hemisotidae
-------Family Hylidae 800 species
-------Family Hyperoliidae
-------Family Leptodactylidae 1100 species
-------Family Limnodynastidae
-------Family Mantellidae
-------Family Microhylidae
-------Family Myobatrachidae
-------Family Nasikabatrachidae
-------Family Petropedetidae
-------Family Ranidae 750 species
-------Family Rhacophoridae
-------Family Rheobatrachidae
-------Family Rhinodermatidae
-------Family Sooglossidae
-----Order Caudata or Urodela (salamanders): 555 species
------Suborder Cryptobranchoidea (Giant salamanders)
-------Family Cryptobranchoidea (Giant salamanders)
-------Family Hynobiidae (Asiatic salamanders)
------Suborder Salamandroidea (Advanced salamanders)
-------Family Ambystomatidae (mole salamanders)
-------Family Amphiumidae (Congo eels)
-------Family Dicamptodontidae (Pacific giant salamanders)
-------Family Plethodontidae (lungless salamanders)
-------Family Proteidae (mudpuppies)
-------Family Rhyacotritonidae (torrent salamanders)
-------Family Salamandridae (true salamanders)
------Suborder Sirenoidea (Sirens)
-------Family Sirenidae
-----Order Gymnophiona or Apoda (caecilians --legless): 171 species
-------Family Beaked Caecilians (Rhinatrematidae) - 2 genera, 9 species
-------Family Fish Caecilians (Ichthyophiidae) - 2 genera, 39 species
-------Family Indian Caecilians (Uraeotyphlidae) - 1 genus, 5 species
-------Family Tropical Caecilians (Scolecomorphidae) - 2 genera, 6 species
-------Family Aquatic Caecilians (Typhlonectidae) - 5 genera, 13 species
-------Family Common Caecilians (Caeciliidae) - 26 genera, 99 species

-Series Amniota (amniotic egg)

--Class Sauropsida - (reptiles)
---Subclass Anapsida (= Parareptilia)
----Order Testudines (turtles) 300 species
-----Suborder Cryptodira
-------Family Chelydridae (Snapping Turtles)
------Superfamily Testudinoidae
-------Family Testudinidae (Tortoises)
-------Family Geoemydidae (Asian River Turtles, Leaf and Roofed Turtles, Asian Box Turtles)
-------Family Emydidae (Pond Turtles/Box and Water Turtles)
------Superfamily Trionychoidae
-------Family Carettochelyidae (Pignose Turtles)
-------Family Trionychidae (Softshell Turtles)
------Superfamily Kinosternoidae
-------Family Dermatemydidae (River Turtles)
-------Family Kinosternidae (Mud and Musk Turtles)
-------Family Platysternidae (Big-headed Turtles)
------Superfamily Chelonioidae (Sea Turtles)
-------Family Cheloniidae (Green Sea Turtles and relatives)
-------Family Dermochelyidae (Leatherback Turtles)
-----Suborder Pleurodira
-------Family Chelidae (Austro-American Sideneck Turtles)
------Superfamily Pelomedusoidae
-------Family Pelomedusidae (Afro-American Sideneck Turtles)
-------Family Podocnemididae (Madagascan Big-headed and American Sideneck River Turtles)
---Superorder Lepidosauria
----Order Sphenodontida (tuatara) (1 family, 1 genus, 2 species)
----Order Squamata (lizards and snakes)
-----Suborder Iguania (the iguanas and chameleons)
-----Suborder Scleroglossa
------Infraorder Gekkota (the geckos)
-------Subfamily Diplodactylinae
-------Subfamily Eublepharinae
-------Subfamily Gekkoninae
-------Subfamily Aeluroscalabotinae
-------Subfamily Teratoscincinae
------Infraorder Anguimorpha (the monitors, goannas, Komodo dragon, Gila monster, and slow-worms)
------Infraorder Scincomorpha (skinks and common European lizards)
------Infraorder Serpentes (the snakes)
-------Family Elapids - cobras, king cobras, kraits, mambas, Australian copperheads, and coral snakes.
-------Family Viperids - vipers, rattlesnakes, copperheads/cottonmouths, adders and bushmasters.
-------Family Colubrids - boomslangs, tree snakes, vine snakes, mangrove snakes, and many others, though not all colubrids are venomous.
-------Family Hydrophiidae - sea snakes
------Infraorder Amphisbaenia (worm lizards)
-------Family Amphisbaenidae
-------Family Trogonophidae
-------Family Bipedidae (1 genus, 3 species, only in Mexico)
-Infraclass Archosauromorpha (23 species)
---Superorder Crocodylomorpha
----Order Crocodylia (crocodiles and relatives)
-----Superfamily Gavialoidea
-------Family Gavialidae - Gharials & False Gharials (2 genus, 2 species)
-----Superfamily Alligatoroidea
-------Family Alligatoridae
--------Subfamily Alligatorinae - Alligators (1 genus, 2 species)
--------Subfamily Caimaninae - Caimans (3 genus, 6 species)
-----Superfamily Crocodyloidea
-------Family Crocodylidae
--------Subfamily Crocodylinae - Crocodiles (2 genus, 13 species)
--Class Aves (birds) 8,800–10,200 species
--- Superorder Paleognathae ("old jaws") (60 species)
----- Order Struthioniformes (flightless)
-------Family Struthionidae (ostriches) (1 species)
-------Family Rheidae (rheas) (2 species)
-------Family Casuariidae (emus etc.) (2 genus, 4 species)
-------Family Apterygidae (kiwis) (6 species)
----- Order Tinamiformes (primative flying) (1 family, 9 genus, 47 species) (Latin America only)
--- Superorder Neognathae
----- Order Anseriformes, waterfowl
----- Order Galliformes, fowl
----- Order Gaviiformes, loons
----- Order Podicipediformes, grebes
----- Order Procellariiformes, albatrosses, petrels, and allies
----- Order Sphenisciformes, penguins
----- Order Pelecaniformes, pelicans and allies
----- Order Ciconiiformes, storks and allies
----- Order Phoenicopteriformes, flamingos
----- Order Falconiformes, falcons, eagles, hawks and allies
----- Order Gruiformes, cranes and allies
----- Order Charadriiformes, gulls, button-quail, plovers and allies
----- Order Pteroclidiformes, sandgrouse
----- Order Columbiformes, doves and pigeons
----- Order Psittaciformes, parrots and allies
----- Order Cuculiformes, cuckoos, turacos, hoatzin
----- Order Strigiformes, owls
----- Order Caprimulgiformes, nightjars and allies
----- Order Apodiformes, swifts and hummingbirds
----- Order Coraciiformes, kingfishers
----- Order Piciformes, woodpeckers and allies
----- Order Trogoniformes, trogons
----- Order Coliiformes, mousebirds
----- Order Passeriformes, passerines
--Class Mammalia (mammals) (see separate post).

28 December 2006

2000 Posts

This is my 2000th post at Wash Park Prophet, which is now about a week short of a year and a half old.

On top of this blog, I have also posted a couple of hundred stories at Colorado Confidential (some of which, like a list of endorsements in the state, were regularly updated for a prolonged period), a small number of posts at Wash Park Poet (about 165 text pages worth, although most were written before I started Wash Park Prophet and only modestly editted before publishing them online), and a number of diaries at Daily Kos, Square State and Colorado Pols in this time period.

This is over 4 posts a day, every day, for the past year and a half. While I don't necessarily agree with one fellow blogger's characterization of my posts as "long winded," I do like to write in paragraphs rather than sentence fragments attached to links. It isn't unusual for a Wash Park Prophet post or Colorado Confidential story to have several hundred words.

On top of these posts and diaries, I've made often lengthy comments on other people's posts and diaries at those blogs, and several others, including a number of comments at Creative Destruction, SCOTUS blog, various law profs blogs, and the Physics Forums, have contributed to both dkospedia and Wikipedia, and have done a little copy editing of the free fiction Kelley Armstrong makes available at her website.

In addition I have written often lengthy responses to e-mail from readers and fellow Colorado Confidential writers with questions and comments, spent considerable time on the Internet looking for new stories to write about, helped with some state legislative issues, and done a day job as an attorney in a small firm, which also involves a lot of typing.

On top of this I've written 360 pages in long hand journals since this blog began, written quite a few miscellaneous ideas in lengthy computer documents that never ended up as blog material and was never included in a long hand journal, and have had a very small anonymous online writing project.

It is too much. I could certainly continue to generate new ideas at the same pace, despite some rare dry spells, which are terrifying. It is also nice to no longer have countless bankers boxes and file cabinet drawers filled with little scraps of paper with ideas written on them, as I had for years before I started blogging. But, I don't think it is good for my continuing physical health to do so much writing. I am feeling the very early stages of repetitive stress injury in my hands, and if I don't take some pretty bold action to address it, I will pay dearly for that choice. It also simply takes too much time do to this somewhat scatter shot kind of writing, which should probably be more focused on writing more polished and longer pieces for old fashioned print publications, and on getting more exercise (suffice it to say that I weigh a lot more than I did when I graduated from high school).

In 2007, I'll be scaling back my participation at Colorado Confidential, and also plan on cutting back the amount that I post here and elsewhere.

This is not a Goodbye Cruel World post. I'm not discontinuing Wash Park Prophet (although my New Year's Resolutions include an upgrade of this blog to a different platform than old style Blogger, in addition to some other nuts and bolts issues like a possible conversion of my laptop to Linux and some neglected virus protection software installation on another home computer). And, I'm not planning to end my association with Colorado Confidential either, although I will write there less often.

I may even increase my fiction writing a little to the point where it is a regular weekly activity, although not nearly as much as I'm decreasing my other kinds of writing. And, another of my New Year's Resolutions is to get an article or two, at least, published in print.

As always, feel free to add any comments you may have on meta issues related to this blog. Comments are always, well, almost always, appreciated.

Mammal Diversity

Let's face it. You probably don't give a rats ass if a rare species of beetle goes extinct, even though you know that you should care. Veterbrates get more respect. By the time you get to mammals, it gets personal.

What mammals are out there, and how likely is it that they will stay around?

There are three subclasses of mammals.

Monotremes

The monotremes make up by far the smallest subclass of mammals, with just three species, found in Australia, Tasmania, and New Guinea. One of these is the duck-billed platypus, and the remaining two are the echidnas, or spiny anteaters.


Marsuplials

There are about 250 species of marsupials, and they are found in a variety of habitats. About two-thirds of them live in Australia, Tasmania, or New Guinea, where they have evolved into a wide variety of forms, including plant-eaters such as kangaroos, koalas, and wombats, and also animals such as bandicoots and quolls, which have sharp teeth and feed largely on insects and other invertebrates. The remainder of the world's marsupials live in the Americas. They include about 70 different kinds of opossum, one of which—the Virginia opossum—is the only marsupial found in North America.


Placental Mammals

The third subclass of mammals, called placentals, includes about 4300 species, making it by far the largest of all three mammal groups. . . .

Biologists classify placental mammals into about 19 groups called orders (the exact number varies in different classification systems). The largest group, with about 1500 species, contains the rodents, such as rats, mice, squirrels, and porcupines. . . . Another major group of mammals, with about 1000 species, contains the bats. . . . Most large predatory land mammals belong to a group called the carnivores, which contains about 240 species. . . . Primates include animals such as lemurs, monkeys, apes, and humans, and most of the 230 species live in trees.

The world's large plant-eating mammals are divided into two major groups. One group, called the artiodactyls, contains animals such as hogs, deer, cattle, and antelope, which have hoofed feet with an even number of toes. The other, a much smaller group called the perissodactylas, includes horses, tapirs, and rhinoceroses, which have an odd number of toes.

Some mammals have adapted to life in the water. The seals, including sea lions and walruses, can sleep and feed in the open ocean but must return to land in order to reproduce. Manatees and dugongs are large, plant-eating mammals that spend their entire lives in the water. The whales, including the huge baleen whales and the dolphins, are well adapted as fast, open-ocean predators. Still, like all other mammals, aquatic mammals would drown if they could not reach the surface to breathe.


The orders of placental mammals are as follows (emphasis added):

Order Artiodactyla (even-toed hoofed animals)
Hoofed animals with an even number of toes include those that ruminate, or digest their food in four-chamber stomachs and chew cuds, and those that do not ruminate. Those that ruminate are the families Girrafidae (giraffes). Cervidae (deer, moose, reindeer, elk). Antilocapridae (pronghorn antelope), and Bovidae (cattle, bison, yaks, waterbucks, wildebeest, gazelles, springboks, sheep, musk oxen, goats). Nonruminators include the families Suidae (pigs), Tayassuidae (peccaries), Hippopotamidae (hippopotamuses), and Camelidae (camels, llamas).

Order Carnivora (meat-eaters)
There are two suborders of these toe-footed creatures. They include the Canidae (wolves, dogs, jackals, foxes), Ursidae (bears, giant pandas), Procyonidae (coatis, raccoons, lesser pandas), and Mustelidae (martens, weasels, skunks, otters), all part of one superfamily that is characterized by long snouts and unretractable claws; and Felidae (cats, lions, cheetahs, leopards) Hyaenidae (hyenas), and Viverridae (mongooses, civets), all of which have retractable claws.

Order Cetacea (whales and purpoises)
Two suborders of Order Cetacea are the toothed whales, which have regular conical teeth, and the baleen, or whalebone, whales, which have irregular whalebone surfaces instead of teeth. Toothed whales include the families Physeteridae (sperm whales), Monodontidae (narwhals, belugas), Phocoenidae (porpoises), and Delphinidae (dolphins, killer whales). Baleens are in the family Eschrichtiidae (gray whales), Balaenidae (right whales), or Balaenoptridae (fin-backed whales, hump-backed whales).

Order Chiroptera (bats)
There are two suborders of bats, the only mammals that can fly. Suborder Megachiroptera contains one family, the Pteropodidae (flying foxes, Old Worm fruit bats). Suborder Microchiroptera contains 17 families, including: Rhinopomatidae (mouse-tailed bats), Emballonuridae (sheath tailed bats), Craseonycteridae (hog-nosed or butterfly bats), Noctilionidae (bulldog or fisherman bats), Nycteridae (slit-faced bats), Megadermatidae (false vampire bats), and Rhinolophidae (horseshoe bats).

Order Dermoptera (colugos or flying lemurs)
These gliding tree mammals from Asia do not fly and are not lemurs, but they are known as flying lemurs, or Family Cynocephalidae .

Order Edentata (toothless mammals)
Three families of mammals get by without teeth: Dasypodidae (armadillos), Bradypodidae (sloths), and Myrmecophagidae (hairy anteaters).

Order Hyracoidae (hyraxes, dassies
Order Hyracoidae is one of three orders that has only one modern family remaining. Procavia capensis (the African rock hyrax) is one of nine living species in the Family Procaviidae .

Order Insectivora (insect-eaters)
The three members are the families Talpidae (moles), Soricidae (shrews), and Erinaceidae (hedgehogs).

Order Lagomorpha (pikas, hares, and rabbits)
Two families make up this order: Ochotonidae (pikas) and Leporidae (hares and rabbits of all sorts).

Order Marsupialia (pouched animals)
Included among these are the families Caenolestidae (rat opossums), Diddeelphidae (true opossums), Dasyuridae (native cats, native mice), Notoryctidae (marsupial moles), Myrmecobiidae (numbats), Peramelidae (bandicoots), Phalangeridae (koalas), Vombatidae (wombats), and Macropodidae (kangaroos and wallabies).

Order Monotremata (egg-laying mammals)
These more primitive mammals make up the families Tachyglossidae (echidnas, also called spiny anteaters) and Ornithorhynchidae (platypuses).

Order Perissodactyla (odd-toed hoofed animals)
The two suborders, Hippomorpha and Ceratomorpha, include creatures that have an odd number of toes. Families in this order are the Equidae (horses, donkeys, zebras), the Tapiridae (tapirs), and the Rhinocerotidae (rhinoceroses).

Order Pholidata
Family Manidae (pangolins) is the sole family in this order.

Order Pinnipedia (seals and walruses)
In the fin-footed order there are Otariidae (eared seals, sea lions), Odobenidae (walruses), and Phocidae (earless seals).

Order Primates (primates)
The order to which people belong is divided into two suborders: The Prosimii , who have longer snouts than their relatives, and the Anthropoidae . The first group includes the families Tupalidae (tree shrew), Lemuridae (lemurs), Daubentonlidae (aye-ayes), Lorisidae (lorises, pottos), and Tarsiidae (tarsiers). The anthropoids include the families Callitrichidae (marmosets), Cebidae (New World monkeys), Cercopithecidae (baboons, Old World monkeys), Hylobatidae (gibbons), Pongidae (gorillas, chimpanzees, orangutans), and Hominidae (human beings).

Order Proboscidea (elephants)
Large enough to have an order all to itself is Family Elephantidae .

Order Rodentia (gnawing mammals)
The most prolific mammals, Order Rodentia includes three suborders. It takes in the families Aplodontidae (mountain beavers), Sciuridae (chipmunks, squirrels, marmots), Cricetidae (field mice, lemmings, muskrats, hamsters, gerbils), Muridae (Old World mice, rats), Heteromyidae (New World mice), Geomyidae (gophers), and Dipodidae (jerboas).

Order Sirenia (dugongs and manatees)
The families Trichechidae (manatees) and Dugongidae (dugongs and other sea cows) make up the Order Sirenia .

Order Tubulidentata (aardvarks)
Another mammal in an order by itself is Family Orycteropodidae.