14 December 2016

Past Decade Good For Amazon, Bad For Department Stores

The retail industry needs to move to digital faster.Shocking how the brick and mortar have lost market value and Amazon has gained.

Note that Sears includes Kmart, as the two firms merged in 2004. Other notable brick and mortar retailers, such as Circuit City and Sports Authority have gone out of business entirely in the meantime.

Quote of the Day

What's the speed of dark?
- Fortune Cookie

13 December 2016

Autism Mutation Study Discovers The Obvious

To the surprise of no one, mutations in people with autism tend to effect the "essential genes" in a person as opposed to the not very important, you could do just fine without them, genes in the human genome. Who knew?

A paper with the same theme, but a less obvious conclusion has the following abstract and citation:
Genetic susceptibility to Intellectual disability (ID), autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and schizophrenia (SCZ) often arises from mutations in the same genes, suggesting that they share common mechanisms. We studied genes with de novo mutations in the three disorders and genes implicated by SCZ genome-wide association study (GWAS). Using biological annotations and brain gene expression, we show that mutation class explains enrichment patterns more than specific disorder. Genes with loss of function mutations and genes with missense mutations were enriched with different pathways, shared with genes intolerant to mutations. Specific gene expression patterns were found for each disorder. ID genes were preferentially expressed in fetal cortex, ASD genes also in fetal cerebellum and striatum, and genes associated with SCZ were most significantly enriched in adolescent cortex. Our study suggests that convergence across neuropsychiatric disorders stems from vulnerable pathways to genetic variations, but spatiotemporal activity of genes contributes to specific phenotypes.

Fake U.S. Embassy Operated For Ten Years

It is stunning that organized criminals were able to operate a fake U.S. embassy issuing fake visas at $6,000 each in Ghana for ten years without anyone doing anything about it. Action was taken this year to shut it down.

Options And Tradeoff In Energy Policy

* Fracking pollutes local groundwater, causes earthquakes in places far from fault lines, uses scarce freshwater resources that could otherwise provide water for people, animals and plants, pollutes the areas where drilling takes place, and is one of the most hazardous industries for workers (in part because worker safety in the industry is regulated by underfunded OSHA instead of adequately funded MSHA). Setting up drilling sites can destroy natural habitats.

But, fracking increases the supply of oil and natural gas at lower prices than conventional extraction methods. This lowers the price of oil and natural gas which have consequences discussed below, reduces U.S. dependency on foreign oil which frees us to oppose abhorrent practices of oil rich countries, and boosts the U.S. economy not only because oil and gas prices are lower, but also because oil and gas production jobs are in the U.S. and not elsewhere.

* High petroleum (i.e. oil and gasoline and diesel) prices encourage energy conservation measures like fuel efficient cars and encourage oil users in industrial and home heating uses to switch to alternative fuels that are cleaner like natural gas and non-coal derived electricity. Moving away from oil reduces air pollution, from oil spills at sea and on land, and slows man made climate change leading to global warming. 

High oil prices also drive up the costs of fertilizer and pesticides which makes organic farming economically competitive with conventional farming.

There is a limited world supply of oil, someday  we will run out, and that could be a huge problem for our economy if we don't transition away from it.

But, high oil prices also provides more funds to oil rich despots and conservative elites in the Middle East like Saudi Arabia and Iran whose funds are the lifeblood of ISIS and fundamentalism Islam, it funds economically irrational authoritarians in Venezuela, it funds conservative Evangelical Christians in places like Texas, and it allows governments in places like Mexico to rely on natural resources as a crutch instead of focusing on building a productive middle class.

High oil prices slow down the economy and sends U.S. money out of the country. Low oil prices lead to economic growth, lower real prices, and easy the lives of the working and middle class.

* Natural gas is the least polluting fossil fuel when used, by far, although extracting it (often via fracking) can lead to environmental harms, and the total production process including transporting natural gas by pipelines lead to far fewer injuries, although occasionally natural gas leaks can lead to huge explosions anywhere it is used.

Natural gas is a cleaner alternative to heating oil, it is a cheaper fuel for heating homes and offices than electricity, it is a cleaner fuel for generating baseline electricity than coal, and a cleaner alternative to gasoline and diesel in converted vehicles.

Natural gas used in the U.S. is mostly produced in North America, which reduces U.S. economic dependency upon and the need to politically defer to politically questionable overseas and Latin American suppliers who are largely also oil suppliers.

Lower natural gas prices boost the economy and encourage energy users to switch to natural gas from more polluting fuels.

While we are less close to running out of natural gas than we are to running out of oil, the global supply of natural gas is also finite, so in the long term we need to transition away from it.

* Pipelines pose risks of environmental harm when they break and spill oil or flare natural gas, for example, poisoning water supplies and destroying habitats, and they can cross environmentally and culturally sensitive areas without much flexibility. But, pipelines are generally safer in terms of accidents, less likely to cause environmental harm, and cheaper than transporting oil or natural gas by truck, by train or by ship, and rail lines and roads pose similar habitat concerns.

* Coal is the most polluting fossil fuel. Mining it is dangerous to workers. Transporting it by truck or train or boat causes more deaths and prevents rail traffic from being used for alternative means of transportation. A huge share of all train and river barge transportation is of coal. Most coal is strip mined which completely destroys habitats. Mined coal is accompanied by a host of toxic and radioactive wastes that poison ground water and the land where it is stored. Coal creates more air pollution than any other form of fossil fuel speeding man made climate change leading to global warming. The number of deaths caused by air pollution from coal is immense.

Coal is more awkward to use, due to its solid form, than oil or natural gas or electricity. It is predominantly used by utilities to generate electricity, although it is also used in coke form, in steel production, and in a few other minor uses.

Coal's main advantages are that it is the most abundant fossil fuel, it has historically been cheap (until pollution mitigation or carbon taxes and pollution related illnesses are considered), its prices have been stable over time, it created good paying domestic jobs and it doesn't have to be imported increasing energy independence.

If oil and natural gas are sufficiently expensive, it is possible to create synthetic liquid and synthetic gas alternatives to oil and natural gas from coal (the Nazi regime did so briefly at the end of World War II and a few proof of concept plants were established when oil prices were $100 a barrel). These processes could postpone the need to transition the economy away from oil and natural gas as those resources run out and limit price increases when and if supplies of oil and gas grow scarce.

* Biomass, biodiesel, ethanol and incineration of trash as energy sources, unlike traditional fossil fuels, are renewable and could provide supplies of fossil fuels in applications like lubricants, plastics, nylons, aircraft fuel, farm equipment fuel, fertilizers, pesticides, fuel for fishing boats, and the like that have no good alternatives when oil supplies run out. Many of these recycle waste into valuable energy, reduce dependency on foreign oil and reduce oil prices somewhat.

But, these sources are frequently as polluting when used as oil and coal, trash incineration as as awkward or more so than coal as a solid fuel source, and there is a limited supply of recycled grease and other combustible wastes that can be made into biodiesel.

You can grow plants specifically for the purpose of creating fuel oils, but this drives up the price of food that could be grown with the same resources, and it is basically not viable to generate more than a modest fraction of current oil consumption this way even with maximally efficient food production.

* Co-generation is a system that uses waste heat from generating fossil fuels or nuclear power for space heating in nearby buildings, making systems more efficient. But, it only works in close proximity to power plants.

* Geothermal energy (basically tapping into the same kind of heat from the Earth that generates hot springs and geysers) is renewable, doesn't create any pollution that wouldn't be created already, and can be reasonably cost effective. But, there are only a few isolated places where it is available as a natural resource, it isn't abundant enough to export for long distances and use as a major share of total energy supplies, and geothermal energy facilities make natural wonders like hot springs and geysers less vibrant.

* Nuclear fission has immense energy density, so the amount of fuel that needs to be mined, transported to power plants, and stored at power plants is stunningly tiny compared to any form of fossil fuel. Nuclear fission plants need to be refueled only on the order of once per one to three decades. These plants generate no air pollution when working properly. The number of worker injuries and injuries to the public associated with mining uranium and transporting it are tiny relative to any fossil fuel. There is basically no radiation risk to neighbors or workers in a nuclear fission plant when it is operating properly. And, the fuel costs of a nuclear power plant are quite low.

The main down sides to nuclear fission power are:

1. It is pretty much useless for any purpose other than generating electricity that is added to the grid, although if designed properly, waste heat can be utilized productively rather than constituting heat pollution to local rivers and clouds. This is mostly a question of scale. Nuclear power plants can be made small enough for a large submarine (ca. 8,000 tons), or ship, or as a village power plant, but not small enough to put in a car, truck, aircraft or locomotive on a train.

2. Nuclear power does impose demands on local water supplies in most plant designs.

3. Because the technology is relatively new, because public safety concerns are great (whether this is justified or not), and because there hasn't been much mass production of plants on the same design, nuclear power plants are the most expensive kind of power plant to design and build.

4. Public fear of radioactive materials has led to fierce opposition to sensible nuclear waste storage facilities for high and low level nuclear wastes, and unrealistic demands on nuclear waste storage facility standards that have left far more troublesome interim solutions in place. The U.S. has also been slow to adopt uranium reprocessing technologies that would greatly reduce the amount of high level nuclear waste in existence by recycling rather than throwing away a valuable potential source of nuclear fission energy.

5. Nuclear power plant fuel and high level nuclear waste must be carefully guarded against diversion by terrorists or rogue nations to create catastrophically deadly nuclear weapons.

6. While the failure of a nuclear power plant is extremely rare and can be mitigated with good future nuclear power plant design, it can't be reduced entirely to zero and there have been a handful of nuclear power plant failures in history. In the U.S., the most famous, which led to very little lost human life was the Three Mile Island incident. The Chernobyl plant failure in the Ukraine (where mitigation measures were recently upgraded with a protective steel "barn" over the melted down plant) was very serious in terms of lost lives, health impacts and lost use of property, however, and the Fukushima plant failure in Japan, at a quite high risk location, has likewise caused non-negligible impacts.

In sum, nuclear fission power is plagued with exaggerated public fears of the danger it poses while more mundane fossil fuels are actually far more harmful to human life, but it does have to be carefully managed and the supply of nuclear fuel while currently abundant relative to demand, is also not infinite.

* Nuclear fusion power plants involve some of the same issues of fuel (deuterium and tritium) security although less intensely, but fuel would still be cheap and energy density would still be high. It would not have the same risks of meltdown or nuclear waste that a fission plant does even though it could give rise to a one time explosion if there was massive plant failure with a localized impact that could be mitigated with good land use. Like nuclear fission, it would only be useful for generating electricity on a power plant scale.

It would be cheap, but the costs of building a nuclear fusion power plant, potentially requiring rare or toxic materials, would still be very high, preventing a nuclear fusion power plant from generating "too cheap to meter" electricity, even if fuel and operating costs were negligible. It could be price competitive, but not dramatically cheaper. But, it would be a permanent, sustainable solution to running out of both fossil fuels and uranium.

The main problem with nuclear fusion is that while we understand the physics governing it more or less perfectly in theory, and can make nuclear fusion bombs, we can not managed to engineer any sustained net power producing nuclear fusion electrical power plant and realistically, it could be many decades before we can, if ever.

* Hydropower is renewable, generates no air pollution, doesn't use anything toxic or produce waste to generate electricity, which is the sole kind of energy it can generate. It can be used as a 24 hour baseline electricity source.

But, there are limited supplies of it because there are only so many rivers that can be effectively dammed. In the arid west, dams are already valuable as a way to manage scarce water resources, but dams also flood large areas of otherwise useful land and destroy not only the ecologies of the flooded areas but also the ecologies that had depended upon free flowing rivers.

* Tidal power in principle provides essentially all of the clean energy benefit of hydropower, apart from being a little bit less of a 24 hour power source, without flooding large areas of useful land. But, they are extremely technologically challenging to put in place and every system must be custom, with only a couple of facilities that are current viable, and it can disrupt sensitive tidal ecosystems. Obviously, it can only add to the grid in coastal locations.

* Wind power is renewable, non-polluting, cost effective in large areas, intermittent but more reliable than solar in many areas, has a modest land footprint, and not ultra-hazardous in any respect. It needs to be paired with batteries or another baseline electricity source, and is can pose a hazard to some kinds of birds. Wind power is rapidly making up a much larger part of the total electric grid.

* Sails and kites with modern designs can reduce fuel demands greatly for ships making transoceanic trips, particularly is speed is not at a high premium.

* Photovoltaic solar power is attractive in a few places as a source of utility electricity in the Southwest, where supplies of solar power also coincide with air conditioning driven demand for electricity to a significant extent, since days in the Southwest got hot, but nights rapidly cool. It is also a good niche source of electricity in places were a larger electrical grid is not available, and is an expensive, but decentralized partial power source for homes and businesses connected to the electrical grid, especially when reverse metering is available.

Prices for solar electricity generation have plummeted with technological advances (although tax subsidies have clouded the issue of price).

Solar electricity is renewable and the fuel is free. Some solar cell production methods use toxic or scarce materials, and solar cells can take up lots of space and can break and need to be replaced over time.

Critically, photovoltaic power systems don't work when its dark, and have degraded performance where days are shorter and cloudy days are common, making it less attractive cost wise in those places. And, it isn't a viable source for 24 hour baseline power without being joined to some efficient and large scale power storage technology, or having a backup alternative power source (like nuclear or natural gas power electricity).

* Heat solar power is a simpler and more efficient use of solar power for water heating and space heating, especially when reaching a boiling point is not necessary. This includes solar hot water heaters, solar pool heating, and passive solar arrangements to use the sun to reduce heating needs in buildings.

* Energy conservation is a good substitute for energy consumption and great progress is being made in reducing the energy consumed on lights (due to LEDs and motion detectors), electronics (due to solid state computer memorized and reduced size computer chips), heating and cooling (due to insulation, and ground heat exchange systems), and vehicles (due to lower weight materials, regenerative braking, and reduced energy consumption at idle, especially by hybrid and electric vehicles). In transportation, the most overlooked way to increase fuel efficiency is to increase passenger occupancy in vehicles, which makes old school buses as energy efficient as a top of the line hybrid vehicle.

* Plug in electric vehicles and electrically powered rail systems make it possible to substitute gasoline and diesel (and to a lesser extent natural gas) for electricity off the grid which is increasingly become cleaner, more renewable and has less rapidly fluctuating prices. Electrically powered urban rail systems have basically no downsides relative to conventionally fueled locomotives, high speed rail operates on the same basis, and freight rail could be relatively easily adapted to be electrically powered with existing technology.

Notably, it takes considerable electricity to refine crude oil into gasoline or diesel fuel, so converting cars and trucks and buses to electricity will have less impact by increasing overall electricity demand than one might expect.

* The need for better energy storage systems (batteries and battery substitutes) in terms of cost, range, energy density, rechargeability, and environmental soundness of their construction, is pretty much the exclusive barrier to widespread conversion to electric cars and trucks, and also, at another scale, to conversion to renewable but intermittent power sources for the electrical grid. Existing batteries needed for an electric car are expensive, have limited range, can take a long time to recharge, and can require toxic or scarce materials to make.

12 December 2016

Trump Voters Still Delusional

People who voted for Trump in the last election remain likely to believe a lot of basic facts that are completely false or are absurd.
-40% of Trump voters insist that he won the national popular vote to only 49% who grant that Clinton won it and 11% who aren’t sure. 
-Only 53% of Trump voters think that California’s votes should be allowed to count in the national popular vote. 29% don’t think they should be allowed to count, and another 18% are unsure. 
There’s been a lot of attention to the way fake news has spread and been believed especially by Trump supporters and that’s borne out in our polling: 
-73% of Trump voters think that George Soros is paying protesters against Trump to only 6% who think that’s not true, and 21% who aren’t sure one way or the other. 
-14% of Trump supporters think Hillary Clinton is connected to a child sex ring run out of a Washington DC pizzeria. Another 32% aren’t sure one way or another, much as the North Carolinian who went to Washington to check it out last weekend said was the case for him. Only 54% of Trump voters expressly say they don’t think #Pizzagate is real. 
There’s also been a lot of discussion recently about how we might be in a post-fact world and we see some evidence of that coming through in our polling: 
-67% of Trump voters say that unemployment increased during the Obama administration, to only 20% who say it decreased. 
-Only 41% of Trump voters say that the stock market went up during the Obama administration. 39% say it went down, and another 19% say they’re not sure.
From Public Policy Polling.

Who cares what the truth is if you are rewarded by voters, and you can convince voters that things that are patently false are actually true?

George W. Bush looks "reality-based" compared to Trump and his supporters.

One of the biggest challenges for Democrats and liberals over the next four years will be figuring out how to get conservative perceptions of reality to correspond more closely to reality itself.

Meritocracy in China

Less than ideal evidence nonetheless suggests that modern Chinese civil servants, continuing an ancient Chinese tradition, are competent and talented.
For a while I have been arguing that China is much more of a meritocracy than many outsiders (or for that matter insiders) believe. You have to distinguish type I from type II error; the princelings do unjustly well but smart people from rural areas are elevated at fairly high rates. Most important jobs are filled by very smart people. Therefore I am happy to see this new paper by Margaret Boittin, Gregory Distelhorst, and Francis Fukuyama:
. . . . We surveyed over 2,500 Chinese municipal officials on three organizational features of their bureaucracies: meritocracy, individual autonomy, and morale. They report greater meritocracy than U.S. federal employees in almost all American agencies. . . .
There are other interesting results in the body of the paper. The only U.S. federal agencies with higher meritocratic self-assessment than the Chinese mean are the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the SEC, the OPM, and Education. Homeland Security, Agriculture, and HUD do the worst, with the performance of the branches of the military being poor as well . . . . You will note that Chinese civil service jobs are highly coveted, and on average there are fifty applicants for each slot, making those jobs more exclusive than Ivy League universities.
From Tyler Cohen.

09 December 2016

Rural Living Is Less Healthy

One of the more notable bits of news in the wake of this election was that the largely urban part of America that voted for Hillary Clinton contributed twice as much to the economy as the largely rural part of America that voted for Donald Trump. In addition to being more economically productive, urban America is healthier than rural America. 

Interestingly, rather than being better off because they have lower taxes, taxes that are too low are one of many reasons that rural counties are less healthy, because they don't provide sufficient public services.
The 2016 County Health Rankings, released Wednesday, compare health disparities among nearly all the counties in the country on the basis of more than 30 factors, including education, housing, exercise and commuting time. The report shows dramatic differences between rural and urban counties on a number of measures, most notably premature death rates. 
Rural counties have higher rates of smoking, obesity, child poverty and teen births, as well as higher numbers of uninsured adults than their urban counterparts, according to the report, a collaboration between the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute. Large urban counties have lower smoking and obesity rates, fewer injury deaths and more residents who attended some college. 
"What we think is going on here is that ... in rural areas, there is a smaller population, fewer businesses, fewer taxes -- and they're struggling to offer as many opportunities as urban," said lead researcher Bridget Catlin. "All of this has a significant impact on health." . . . 
"Urban residents definitely have better access to health care, but there's far more to good health than just that," said Catlin. "People have an impression of rural areas as healthy living and the great outdoors, but there aren't sidewalks. It can actually be more difficult to get out and exercise. Urban can offer more recreation facilities and more safe options." 
"Rural populations are also aging faster than urban areas," said Catlin. "Younger people who do go to college and leave home -- many of them don't return back home. What's left is an older population in the rural areas."
From CNN.

08 December 2016

Patent Law Tamed Yet Again

The United States Supreme Court made another major shift in patent law on Tuesday, overruling Federal Circuit precedents that had held that any design patent violation entitles the prevailing party to 100% of the profits from the product utilizing the patent, in the case of Samsung Electronics Co. v. Apple, Inc. According to the official syllabus of the decision (in the link above) the holding is that:
In the case of a multicomponent product, the relevant “article of manufacture” for arriving at a [35 U.S.C.] §289 damages award need not be the end product sold to the consumer but may be only a component of that product.
In the case, Samsung was ordered to pay $399 million to Apple for breaching design patent aspects of the iPhone that were a small component of the total product. The U.S. Supreme Court held in a unanimous opinion that damages for breach of a design patent should instead be proportionate to the contribution that the patented element makes to the total product - in this case, probably a small fraction of the total $399 million of profits that Samsung made from selling the infringing phones.

The decision resolves what had been a serious fundamental flaw in patent law that produced damages that were grossly disproportionate to the true value of the harm from an infringement. Under the old rule of law, it could easily be the case that the damages award for multiple breaches of different patents that all contribute to the same product could result in total damages far in excess of the total profits from the sales of the goods.

This is a particular barrier to technological innovations, because it is often not at all clear until a court finally resolves the issue, whether a product infringes a patent, and because there is no fool proof way to review the existing catalog of patents when designing a new product. Yet, a patent holder can recover for patent infringement even if the product is designed and/or invented completely independently of the patent holder's invention.

Also, a the patent holder can take a wait and see approach and only sue in cases where an allegedly infringing product becomes profitable, without bearing any of the downside risk, when potentially infringing products turn out to generate little or no profits.

This is one of an ongoing string of U.S. Supreme Court decisions that have generally narrowed the scope of what can be protected by patent law and the consequences for infringing a patent. Previous cases have, in particular, narrowed the scope of patentable business processes and software, made it easier to sanction weak patent infringement claims with attorneys' fee awards, narrowed the general presumption that injunctions are available for every patent infringement, and now, narrowed the scope of damages which can be awarded for an infringement that is a minor part of a product.

For a long time, the U.S. Supreme Court stayed away from patent law, which is a quite insular and technical speciality in the law, since circuit splits of authority never arose because all patent law cases are handled on appeal by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, a bench full of judges with private practice backgrounds in firms that enforced patents, resulting in a degree of institutional capture. But, the U.S. Supreme Court eventually got wise to this problem and has embarked on a slow but steady roll back of the Federal Circuit's patent law excesses.

Patent holders are now about 3 pro to 17 against to 4 neutral in U.S. Supreme Court litigation implicating patent law since 2005, a period which also included the America Invents Act in 2011 which was a major reform. There has also been related nationalization of trade secret law this year.

An important piece of patent legislation of venue for infringement actions has some change of passage either in the lame duck session or in the next Congress.

Other Relatively Recent Posts on Patent Law at this blog include:

* 15% of U.S. Tech Patent Litigation Due To Patent Troll Enforcement Of Three Dubious Patents

* Patents Are Much Harder To Get Than They Were A Dozen Years Ago

* Almost Half Of Fully Litigated Patents Are Invalid

* Fed Circuit Wrong Again On Patent Law

* The Law Against Using Your Own Ideas

* Tax Strategy Patents Are No More

Community Bail Funds

The framing of Community Bail Funds as "Bail Nullification" is in my view, counterproductive, but the practice itself is a fascinating end run around the failure of other policy makers to implement bail reform, which has been repeatedly demonstrated for half a century or so, to be an effective and workable criminal justice reform.
The longstanding scholarly debate over the ability of community members to engage in nullification has been confined to the study of jury nullification — when jurors acquit someone despite knowledge of their legal guilt. 
This Article explores the possibility of community nullification beyond the jury by analyzing the growing and unstudied phenomenon of community bail funds, which post bail for strangers based on broader beliefs regarding the overuse of pretrial detention. When a community bail fund posts bail, it can serve the function of nullifying a judge’s determination that a certain amount of the defendant’s personal or family money was necessary to ensure public safety and prevent flight. 
This growing practice — what this Article calls “bail nullification” — is powerful because it exposes publicly what many within the system already know to be true: that although bail is ostensibly a regulatory pretrial procedure, for indigent defendants it often serves the function that a real trial might, producing guilty pleas and longer sentences when an individual cannot afford to pay their bail. 
By examining the ways in which community bail funds serve the functions that a nullifying jury might — allowing popular participation in an individual case to facilitate larger resistance to the policies and practices of state actors — this Article argues that community bail funds have the potential to change how local criminal justice systems operate on the ground, shifting and shaping political and constitutional understandings of the institution of money bail. 
Community bail funds give a voice to populations who rarely have a say in how criminal justice is administered, especially poor people of color. And the study of bail funds helps point toward other ways in which bottom-up public participation can help create a criminal justice system that is truly responsive to the communities that it is ultimately supposed to serve.
Jocelyn Simonson (Brooklyn Law School) has posted Bail Nullification (Michigan Law Review, Vol. 115, 2017, Forthcoming) on SSRN via the Legal Theory Blog.

04 December 2016

Quote Of The Day

The race of man . . .  cannot long be happy without virtue, nor actively virtuous without freedom, nor securely free without rational knowledge.
-- William Jones

When Do Placebos Work And Why?

Placebos are particularly effective with conditions related to nervous system chemistry and immune response.
Do placebos and the power of the mind work? What I’ve found is yes, but not with everything. There are rules and conditions in which healing can be incredibly effective. Parkinson’s, chronic pain, irritable bowel syndrome, depression, anxiety, certain types of asthma, and autoimmune deficiencies are all very placebo-responsive. 
But cancer is not. . . .
Placebos have been particularly effective in the treatment of Parkinson’s disease. How do you explain that?

Parkinson’s is the perfect disease to talk about placebos. It is a chronic deficiency of dopamine, which is one of those brain chemicals that does a lot of jobs in our bodies. One of [dopamine’s] important roles is in reward processing: how we think about good things we might get in the future.

Expectation drives placebos. And dopamine is a chemical that’s very responsive to our expectations. Parkinson’s happens to be a deficiency in the very chemical that’s very important in placebo effects and rewards.

If you look at Alzheimer’s, which does not have a high placebo response, you start to see that there are rules at play when it comes to placebos. It’s not your brain magically doing all these crazy things. There are certain chemicals we have access to and others we don’t.
From a National Geographic interview with Erik Vance, the author of Suggestible You: The Curious Science of Your Brain’s Ability to Deceive, Transform, and Heal, which was published by National Geographic.

Some of this appears to be related to neuroendocrine systems in the body such as the HPA axis:
The hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis (HPA axis or HTPA axis) is a complex set of direct influences and feedback interactions among three endocrine glands: the hypothalamus, the pituitary gland (a pea-shaped structure located below the hypothalamus), and the adrenal (also called "suprarenal") glands (small, conical organs on top of the kidneys). 
These organs and their interactions constitute the HPA axis, a major neuroendocrine system that controls reactions to stress and regulates many body processes, including digestion, the immune system, mood and emotions, sexuality, and energy storage and expenditure. It is the common mechanism for interactions among glands, hormones, and parts of the midbrain that mediate the general adaptation syndrome (GAS). While steroid hormones are produced mainly in vertebrates, the physiological role of the HPA axis and corticosteroids in stress response is so fundamental that analogous systems can be found in invertebrates and monocellular organisms as well. 
The HPA axis, HPG axis, HPT axis, and the hypothalamic–neurohypophyseal system are the four major neuroendocrine systems through which the hypothalamus and pituitary direct neuroendocrine function.
Conditions that do not relate to the neuroendocrine systems, nervous system chemistry or the immune system, in contrast, are not very responsive to placebo effects. They don't work, for example, to stop cancer, retard Alzheimer's disease, prevent blood loss, or to set broken bones. In other words, if your brain doesn't have control over any of the relevant bodily symptoms, placebos don't work.

U.S. Immigration Courts Still Broken

ARLINGTON, Va. — Walk into the immigration court here, and scenes of a justice system in collapse abound. . . . The judge in Courtroom 2 had unsettling news for Edhite Pouken Shienji, a woman from Cameroon seeking asylum. After 14 years of delays, she was finally scheduled for a hearing. But at the last minute, the judge was reassigned to handle the cases of some migrants from Central America. Her hearing was postponed once again — to 2019. 
In Courtroom 8, there was a deportation hearing for Damián Martínez, from Mexico. The judge soon discovered he was a 4-month-old infant, dozing on the shoulder of his mother. Somehow the baby’s case had become separated in court records from hers. The bewildered mother, in court without a lawyer, had no clue how to fix the problem. The judge could only urge her to make sure that Damián “presents himself in all of his future hearings." . . . 
On a visit to the immigration court in Denver four years ago, cases were moving briskly, but judges were starting to worry because hearing delays were reaching 18 months. Now in Denver, the court with the longest wait times in the country, most cases drag on more than five years, the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, a research group studying federal data, has found. In Arlington, by reputation one of the nation’s best-run courts, eight judges have more than 30,000 cases, with some scheduling hearings in 2022.
From the New York Times.

Political theory predicts that political institutions respond to voters, and that immigration law, because it mostly benefits people who can't vote, will usually be sorely neglected. This theory seems to be a pretty accurate one.

Who Knew I Was In The Market For That?

Customized Internet advertising is a weird thing.

Sometimes it is spot on and even suggests purchases you'd never dreamed of but totally want once you see it (whether or not you'll actually buy something is another thing).

Often, you are bombarded with ads for things immediately after you've purchased something like that on the Internet. But, usually, you don't need any more of that thing at that point.

Other times, its just wild and weird. Today, for example, I've been getting advertisements hoping that I'll buy a $1.5 million plus apartment in a high rise in Manhattan.  Who knew that I was in the market for one of those? (Unless the Internet knows something that I don't.) My best guess is that I've been reading the New York Times more than usual.

03 December 2016

The Red Letter Christian Pipe Dream

Christianity is what Christians do, and that is something that few people of good will can be proud of these days. I know the history that brought us to the place we are today. I can even see some psychological and sociological logic to it.  But, in my gut, I am still baffled at how Christianity became such a predominantly evil institution, in the United States and to a lesser extent, in Europe as well, as least.  But, it did.

New York Times Op-Ed writer Tony Campolo is struggling with this as well on behalf of a huge demographic, fecklessly hoping for a new movement of Christians who believe in good, but the evil in Christianity has instead driven a grass roots surge of ernest and far more moral secular humanism.
Evangelicalism was closely associated with the campaign of Donald J. Trump, and more than 80 percent of white evangelicals voted for the president-elect. . . . much of the good that went by the name “evangelicalism” has been clouded over; now a new movement is needed to replace it. 
When it comes to religious identity in America, the fastest-growing group is the “nones.” Nearly a quarter of all Americans, and over 35 percent of millennials, report no religious affiliation. Nones, many of whom grew up within evangelicalism, often still affirm faith in God. They left the church because they gave up on evangelical leadership. Nothing sums up their objections more clearly than evangelicals’ embrace of Mr. Trump. . . .

[T]he old guard, like the Focus on the Family founder James Dobson, were ardent Trump supporters . . . At Liberty University, the largest evangelical college in the country, thousands of students signed a petition denouncing the support of its president, Jerry Falwell Jr., for Mr. Trump and insisting that they were more interested in being Christian than in being Republican. 
Andy Crouch, the executive editor of Christianity Today, criticized both candidates, writing that enthusiasm for Mr. Trump “gives our neighbors ample reason to doubt that we believe Jesus is Lord.” He added, “They see that some of us are so self-interested, and so self-protective, that we will ally ourselves with someone who violates all that is sacred to us.”. . .

Jesus-centered faith needs a new name. Christians have retired outdated labels before. During the late 19th century, when scientific rationalism fueled the questioning of Scripture, “fundamentalism” arose as an intelligent defense of Christianity. By the 1930s, however, fundamentalism was seen as anti-intellectual and judgmental. It was then that the term “evangelicalism” was put forward by Christianity Today’s first editor, Carl F. H. Henry, as a new banner under which a broad coalition of Jesus followers could unite. 
But beginning with the culture wars of the 1980s, the religious right made a concerted effort to align evangelicalism with the Republican Party. By the mid-’90s, the word had lost its positive connotations with many Americans. They came to see Christians — and evangelicals in particular — as anti-women, anti-gay, anti-environment and anti-immigrant and as the champions of guns and war. . . . 
Perhaps we need a new reformation — one that invites Christians to return to the teachings of Jesus and offers our neighbors a truer vision of how he lived and moved in the world. . . . Maybe this is a moment in our history for evangelicals to repent and be “born again” again as Red Letter Christians.
The trouble is that there is no such movement. Not any movement with a prayer of becoming relevant, at any rate. People in the United States and indeed, in Europe as well, who give a damn about the values that the Gospel's moral messages emphasize have overwhelmingly abandoned the superstitious and anti-scientific nonsense of religion in favor of secular humanism.

Getting your morality from a source telling the story of an exorcist demigod and his exorcist followers who embrace the demon possession theory of mental and physical health is not way to live in the 21st century. Neither is putting your faith in a God who a few volumes earlier was urging his chosen people on in repeated campaigns of ruthless genocide.

Also, historically, Campolo is wrong in suggesting that Trump marks anything new. At most, Trump, whose new appointed chief of strategy offers up Hitler and Satan as positive role models for President Trump, simply made the long standing truth a bit more obvious. Evangelical Christians and many Catholics as well (although certainly not all) have firmly embraced evil and rejected any message that is remotely recognizable from the Gospel for at least a generation. And, during that time, they have come to dominate Christianity as more sane denominations with gentler, more human messages have withered in one of the most dramatic cases of institutional collapse in peacetime history.

There is no reason to imagine that this will change for the better in my lifetime, or the lifetime of my children. The rats are abandoning the ship because it is sinking and has found a less precarious place to ground themselves that is connected to reality and not half-fictional myths.

01 December 2016

Refugees Saving Dying Neighborhoods

The linked story highlights how refugee communities, such as 70,000 Muslim Bosnians who settled in a neighborhood in Saint Louis in the 1990s, can revitalize neighborhoods in cities that are seeing massive population declines.

29 November 2016

Topics Safe Enough To Risk Offending An Influential Academic Over

A new micro-symposium at SSRN provides counterpoints to and elaborations of University of Chicago law professor Richard Posner's essay, "What Is Obviously Wrong With The Federal Judiciary?" with only bylined pieces permitted.

The abstract stated:
After Richard Posner gave the Green Bag’s readers a double dose of “What Is Obviously Wrong With the Federal Judiciary,” we invited them to comment on his comments on the courts. So did he: “What I would most like to see would be criticism of the criticisms that I have made of the federal judiciary, and of the American legal culture more broadly, in this two-part article and at much greater length in Divergent Paths (and earlier books and articles). 
The Bluebook must have its defenders – let them defend their precious tome from me. And so must the awful legal jargon found in so many judicial opinions, and their verbosity; the superfluous headings and subheadings; the silly flourishes; the paeans to the adversary system; the pattern jury instructions; the standards of review; the dread of the italicized period; the spittoons behind the Supreme Court’s bench. The list goes on and on... But no; it seems I am to remain a voice crying in the wilderness. Pretty depressing.” This micro-symposium should inspire in Posner both a new cheeriness and more of the same old depression.
On which issues did academics (and perhaps a few practicing lawyers) dare challenge the judge?

* Which is the correct spelling of the latin legal phrase, "Ejusdem generis" or "Euisdem generis"?

* Headings and subheading in judicial opinions are important contrary to Posner's claim.

* An originalist method of interpretation of the constitution has some impact on the outcome of the case apart from the intended result of the person using it. Posner joins with an essay rebutting this and claiming that the so called originalist method advanced in the essay is "Faux Originalism".

My Two Cents On Other Matters

In Defense Of The Bluebook and the Italicized Period.


I was a Manual Of International Legal Citations editor during my term on the Michigan Journal of International Law, and in that post I gained some appreciation of the Bluebook (the leading legal citation style guide published by a consortium of three leading law school law reviews). 

Posner's University of Chicago style guide is its chief competitor in the marketplace for legal citation style guides, so he can fairly be accused of partiality.

What is good about the Bluebook?

When you write a law review or legal opinions or a legal brief, you must make stylistic choices about citation formatting whether you want to or not.  The decision to include a period in or outside italics, which is often hard to discern in print, is one such choice.

A good law review, court or law firm does so consistently and in a manner that has some outside justification for the choices made just like every other argument in persuasive legal writing. An authoritative ruling on every possible choice that could be made in formatting a citation, eliminates the need for the rest of the sane population of the world to debate these issues that must be decided to produce a finished work, but add little value of their own.

The core rules of the Bluebook are simple to apply in the handful of cases that make up 95% of legal citations, follow a common logic, and recognize the distinction between the more elaborate publishing register of an academic journal, and the more practical publishing register of a legal opinion or brief. The rest of the Bluebook provides guidance for myriad rarely used sources with examples that an author might otherwise fear to cite at all for fear that there is no proper legal citation for them. Thus, it implicitly broadens the scope of what is considered legitimate legal authority.

Also, the Bluebook's core rules (which I more or less follow in citations at this blog and its sister blog) thankfully eliminate much of the extraneous information required by ordinary academic journal style guides which are superfluous in legal writing, because, for example, the publishers of the leading case reporters are well known and the authorship of binding legal precedent is often irrelevant. 

The list of standard abbreviation conventions in the Bluebook is also particularly useful, and its jurisdiction by jurisdiction summaries provide a quick outline of the entire range of authoritative legal sources in existence.

In Defense of Legal Jargon In Court Opinions

Today, more than ever, legal researchers engage directly with source materials such as court opinions and statues, using word searches. 

In a word search, you only turn up cases that use the buzzwords of legal jargon you mention. An opinion that substitutes "plain English" for legal jargon will often be missed causing researchers to fail to identify relevant law since they no longer usually search using "digests" that organize case headnotes by subject matter regardless of the terminology used.

So, legal jargon in court opinions is more important now than ever before.

In Defense of Pattern Jury Instructions

At the end of every trial, the judge must devise jury instructions with input from the lawyers for both sides of the case relying on the relevant case law. There is infinite variety in how this can be done from scratch, which leads to constant legal battles over jury instruction language by counsel for both sides that is often critical on appeal because this is how all conclusions of law are implemented in a jury trial.

Yet, the vast majority of jury trials involve a modest subset of the entire law presenting legal issues that sometimes recur in every case, and sometimes recur in every case of a particular type.

Pattern jury instructions allow judges and counsel to dispense with wasteful argument over the details of jury instructions on matters where the law is settled that are tangential to the issues at hand for the jury (such as a lengthy description of their power to evaluate the evidence and the burdens of proof that apply). This frees up precious judicial and counsel resources at a time when a jury has heard all of the evidence and is waiting around to receive the case, to focus on the legal issues that are disputed and particular to the case at hand. It also insures relative uniformity across the judicial system.

In Defense of The Spittoons Behind the Supreme Court’s Bench

Why exactly would it be better for Supreme Court justices to spit on the floor than to spit into a spittoon? Duh!

And, if the spittoons were placed in front of the Supreme Court's bench, counsel presenting their cases to the court and the audience hearing oral arguments would be in line of fire of judicial spit. It is hard enough for them to face sharp questioning without having to dodge judicial spitballs as well.

In Defense Of Stating Standards of Review

Standards of review are obviously important to securing the right result in a case, and calling attention to this in each decision and brief, while somewhat redundant, does focus the authors on the task at hand in a manner that is often outcome determinative. Also, while the standard of review is clear to the participants even if not stated, it is helpful to state this so that clients and the public can better understand opinions.

In Defense of Verbosity

Verbose judges do so because (1) they seek to explain every element of their reasoning, and (2) it is faster to write a long opinion than a carefully honed smaller one. Both are desirable in the conditions they face relative to the common prior practice of dismissing arguments raised by counsel out of hand without any reasoned justification whatsoever.

Why Is Climate Change A Liberal Issue?

The need to address man caused climate change and the rising sea levels (among other things) that would result is largely a liberal issue in the U.S.  U.S. conservatives tend to be climate change deniers.

Part of this is historical conservative distrust of science and distaste for the government regulation of business necessary to protect the environment and slow climate change.

But, there is another piece to it as well. The impact of climate change due to rising sea levels which is its most obvious consequence falls disproportionately on the "coastal elites" of the United States who are predominantly liberal and vote Democratic.

Almost all of the major cities on the Pacific coast are at risk, with comparatively conservative San Diego fairing better than most Pacific coastal cities. The major cities of the Northeast, and Florida, which is one of the most liberal Southern states, also face grave flooding risks, as does New Orleans, a liberal hub within the South.

In contrast, rising sea levels disproportionately have little impact on "Red State America". Appalachia, the Midwest, Utah, Idaho, Arizona, the Great Plains and the interior of the South are far less affected. 

Of course, the correspondence is not perfect. The conservative Panhandle of Florida and the coasts of the Carolinas would be impacted, as would a lot of the Gulf Coast of Texas. Liberal outposts like Denver, Minneapolis, Chicago and Austin would be largely spared. But, these are the exceptions that prove the rule.

28 November 2016

Great Name For A Rock Band

Back in 865 CE, there was a Viking military group operating in Britain known as the Great Heathen Army according to contemporaneous chronicles, which would be a great name for a rock group.

25 November 2016

Wells Fargo Bank Still Violently Anti-Consumer And Crooked

Consumer arbitration is always a scam, but this one is particularly noteworthy, because the company claims the consumers are bound by agreements signed with signatures forged by the company. 

If there is any way that you can avoid doing business with this dishonest bank, you should take advantage of it and move your accounts immediately.
Even though disgraced Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf has left the building, his most outrageous legal theories live on: on Wednesday, the company filed a motion in a federal court in Utah seeking dismissal of a class action suit by the customers it defrauded -- the bank argues that since customers sign a binding arbitration "agreement" when they open new accounts, that the customers whose signatures were forged on fraudulent new accounts should be subject to this agreement and denied a day in court.

This is the same argument that Stumpf made during his disastrous performance in front of a blazing Elizabeth Warren -- that Wells's poor customers should be subjected to agreements they never made, because Wells stole their identities and "agreed" on their behalf.
From here.