10 July 2020

Trends In Military Technology And Warfare

Slug Throwers v. Missiles

Bullets


The smallest bullet in common military use is the 5.56mm round (a hair less than 0.22 caliber). A thrown slug is still called a bullet up to 12.7mm (0.50 caliber).

Grenades and Cannons Rounds


A slug thrower round that is more than 12.7mm is called a grenade or a "cannon" round up to abt 50mm (2 inch) rounds swith 20mm, 30mm and 40mm bring the most common cannon or grenade rounds). There are handheld grenade launchers operated by infantry with only a small number of rounds, but also cannons with a fixed mount or on a military ground vehicle, helicopter, fixed wing aircraft (e.g. the A-10 ground attack aircraft), or a military or paramilitary ship. Fixed mount cannons can often fire cannon rounds at rates comparable to or greater than automatic weapons firing bullets, with the most extreme version being the Phalanx close in weapons system (CIWS) which is used as an active defensive weapon primarily against incoming missiles, large incoming naval gun and artillery shell rounds, drones, and small water craft.

Shells


Slug thrower rounds above 2" are commonly "shells". Historically, they have ranged from 60mm mortar rounds (used as a secondary weapon on the Israeli Merkava tank as a secondary weapon) and the 75mm (3") shells used in smaller naval guns to 406mm (16") shells used for large naval guns on battleships and up to 24" in the heaviest mortar rounds used in World War II or later. Generally, slug throwers that fire shells are reloaded after each firing, sometimes in an automated process but rarely, if ever, on a rapid-fire basis. They are used in mortars, howitzers, naval guns, tanks, and anti-aircraft guns.

These days the largest slug thrower rounds in common use by NATO forces are no more than 155mm (6"). The 155mm shells is used in heavy artillery Howitzers and as heavy mortar rounds, the 127mm (5") shell is used in the naval guns of U.S. destroyers, a 120mm round is used in U.S. main battle tanks, 105mm rounds (a bit over 4") were used historically in lighter tanks and armored personnel carrier heavy guns and for lighter artillery. The 3" shell has been used in some U.S. naval guns. The largest slug thrower round still in common use is the Russian army's 240mm (9.45") heavy mortar in its 2S4 Tyulpan (Tulip) self-propelled heavy mortar round, but other mortar rounds generally don't exceed 120mm.


Shell Throwers Are Obsolete

All slug throwers with rounds larger than a grenade or cannon round (i.e. more than about 2" or 50mm) are basically obsolete, even though some remain in military service.

Except for tanks and smaller naval guns, shells are used primarily for "indirect fire" at reasonable long distances. But guided missile and smart bomb technologies (including "smart artillery rounds that are basically just guided missiles or smart bombs delivered via a howitzer or naval gun) are much more accurate at long ranges than "dumb" artillery rounds, even though they are more expensive. The greater cost is made up for by very nearly one shot, one kill rates with guided weapons which are far superior to unguided artillery and bombs, which not only reduces the number of rounds needed, but reduces collateral damage. Missile launchers can also be scaled to be much lighter than a slug thrower delivering ordinance with equivalent offensive effect.

Accuracy at long ranges is less of a concern for direct fire weapons in tanks and anti-artillery weapons.

But relatively small (as missiles go) ant-tank missiles such as TOW missiles (used by Bradley armored fighting vehicles and infantry) and Hellfire missiles (used by helicopters and drones) are as or more effective than large tank shells are destroying or disabling even heavily armored main battle tanks, armored personnel carriers and lightly fortified fixed shelters, and weigh much less than a 105mm or 120mm tank gun and the rounds that it must carry. Smart bombs and missiles are likewise effective at destroying heavier fixed targets that it would take many tank rounds to seriously harm.

In anti-aircraft applications, missiles are more accurate against often fast-moving targets except at very close ranges with automated fire control systems (such as those found in the Phalanx CIWS) and allow for fire at longer ranges. Anti-aircraft weapon effective against helicopters and fixed wing aircraft (such as Stinger anti-aircraft missiles) can be small enough to be utilized by infantry, although infantry carried anti-aircraft missiles have less range than mount delivery system anti-aircraft missiles. Also, in terms of offensive punch, rounds larger than 40mm are generally unnecessary for anti-aircraft fire, because the realities of flight prevent aircraft from being heavily armored.

Bullets and grenade and cannon grounds, in contrast, are still viable because missiles are not yet optimal in either price or effectiveness at short ranges in direct fire, where their greater accuracy is less of a factor, and against lighter targets with their lesser potency is less of a factor.

Armor v. Active Defenses And Other Alternatives


Heavy Passive Armor Is Obsolete


Armor and fortifications have been used since ancient times in a never-ending contest of offense v. defense. In the last half century or so, armor has been losing this race in most (but not all) contexts.

Passive armor such a metal plating and Kevlar bullet proof vests remains viable as a defense against bullets, shrapnel, and even grenades and cannon rounds to some extent.

But some kind of armor-piercing bullet (often 12.7mm), anti-armor shells, or missiles of a manageable size (sufficient to be launched from a ground based mobile missile launcher, from a missile battery of a warship or missile boat or submarine, or from a fighter aircraft) can generally penetrate almost any armor light enough to be used on an aircraft, ship, or ground vehicle while still allowing it to move at acceptable speeds.

Even a crude IED (i.e. an improvised remotely or automatically triggered ground mine) is powerful enough disable a heavy tank or mine resistant armored vehicle, and utterly destroy the vehicle seriously wounding or killing everyone on board, with any less well armored ground vehicle.

It is also possible to attack heavy armored tanks in vulnerable spots with less heavy infantry weapons if one can get in close enough, so heavily armored tanks need lighter and more vulnerable escorts. And, heavily armored tanks are so large than the terrain such as narrow mountain roads or narrow urban streets can become impassible to them or can be made impossible to them quite easily despite their ability to navigate extreme terrain with tracks. Ambush attacks can often be arranged that minimize the benefits of heavy passive armor.

It is possible to have an even more heavily fortified fixed bunker with armor protection greater than the heaviest armor possible on a tank, battleship, deep water submarine, or ad hoc field base. But once a bunker's location is identified it is possible to use a long range, heavy missile launched from sea or land, or a "bunker busting" bomb dropped by a bomber on a target that can't dodge away to destroy it.

Alternatives To Heavy Passive Armor


As a result, armor heavier than that necessary to keep small arms fire and shrapnel at bay is increasingly disfavored in lieu of stealth, mobility, dispersed formations, engaging the enemy at a distance beyond the accurate range of their weapons, and active defenses.

Stealth is to prevent ordinance from being directed at you because the enemy doesn't know where you are. This includes not just vehicles with low radar or sonar signals, but also deep water submarines that are harder to locate, traditional camouflage and false flag operations, covert suicide bombing missions, hidden remotely or automatically detonated bombs and mines, hiding aircraft in clouds or behind hills, mountains and trees, and so on.

A notable subset of stealth is in air to air combat. For the most part, air to air combat is now a one shot, one kill situation where the first to shoot kills the adversary who will often not even known that a fight is underway until after the first shot has been fired. Historically this was done by hiding in clouds, although increasingly anti-radar stealth is a factor. This makes "Top Gun" style dog fighting maneuverability and speed a secondary consideration, and excellent targeting devices and long-range missile capabilities the primary consideration.

Mobility limits the usefulness of enemy intelligence on your targeting location because it changes rapidly. This is particularly important when the adversary has active defenses that rapidly locate the source of an attack and target return fire at it.

Dispersed formations prevent any one killing blow from destroying a larger share of your forces so that the balance of your forces can attack an enemy ill equipped to handle a large number of forces at once, it also makes targeting more difficult since unless all targets are hit there may be return fire.

The benefit of engaging the enemy at a distance beyond the accurate range of their weapons is obvious and has been since archery, catapults, and thrown spears were in common use in ancient times. Historically this was often countered with passive armor and shields that could repeal arrows and the like, but now offense has overtaken passive armor, so long range engagement is a more fruitful approach.

Active Defenses


Active defenses are deployed to shoot mines, incoming shells, missiles, bombs, drones, and massed light forces such as small watercraft, before they hit a target for which the active defenses are providing point defense.

One kind of active defense is "reactive armor" that explodes outward from the protected surface at or shortly before ordinance hits an armored target actively pushing incoming ordinance backward and prematurely detonating it before it can apply its full effect to the protected surface's passive armor.

One kind of active defense uses cannons to hit incoming threats with big bullets, exemplified with the Phalanx CIWS.

One kind of active defense uses missiles to hit incoming threats, exemplified with the Patriot missile defense system.

One kind of active defense uses lasers to ignite explosives and fuel in incoming threats so they explode before they reach their targets.

One kind of active defense tries to interfere with the guidance systems of income threats with electronic radio wave jamming, electromagnetic pulses, flares, chafe launchers, and/or laser pointer type devices.

A close relative of these ordinance intercepting active defense systems are systems that analyze sound waves from incoming small arms fire to identify the location of the source of the incoming fire and to promptly return fire at the person or drone firing at you eliminating the threat of future incoming ordinance. Many air to air, surface to air, and air to ground missiles similarly use heat or radar signals to home in on aircraft or anti-aircraft batteries and eliminate them.

Wheels v. Tracks


Ground vehicles usually use either wheels or tracks.

Hovercraft and "ground effect vehicles" also exist and have seen limited military applications, and in snowy environments vehicles that use skis are also known. Neither are widely used for a variety of reasons that it may be worth reconsidering at some point.

Generally speaking, the modern trend has been to shift from tracks to wheels in military ground vehicles.

A number of factors have driven this trend.

* Wheels are faster and as mobility has become more of a concern given the declining efficacy of passive armor, mobility has become more important.

* Wheeled vehicles are vastly more fuel efficient than tracked vehicles, and that influences both the range of the vehicle between refueling and the amount of vulnerable fuel resupply logistics that are necessary. It also makes them ill-suited to routine patrol duty involving lots of driving around when it is unlikely to be necessary to engage off-road.

* Tracked vehicles tend to be heavier than comparable wheeled vehicles which impairs the ability to deliver them to the field by cargo aircraft, and limits the bridges strong enough to use them, making it harder to get them to the fight. Because heavy tracked vehicles are much less fuel efficient and also tend to damage civilian roads, often they are shipped to the theater by rail or ship, which are slower, and in the case of rail or even being driven only over high capacity bridges limits the flexibility that tracks freeing them of the need to be on roads brings.

* Lots of off-road conditions are a barrier to both tracked and wheeled vehicles that take considerable time to clear for either. A stand of trees, buildings in a city with narrow streets, narrow mountain roads, sufficiently large boulders, sufficiently thick walls, a variety of anti-vehicle and anti-tank barricades, deep water barriers such as rivers, lakes and canals, and bridges that aren't strong enough to hold the weight of large military vehicles can thwart both wheeled and tracked vehicles.

* Tracked vehicles can be superior on mud and loose sand and snow, but the capacity of wheeled vehicles to handle these kinds of terrains has improved. the off-road capabilities of wheeled vehicles has improved due to better tires and off road conscious designs (such as the Humvee).

* In practice, the reality of military operations as actually conducted in modern wars is that the vast majority of ground vehicle travel is either by road, or in off-road terrains that wheeled vehicles can handle. This is, in part, because wars are fundamental fights between groups of people and people tend to live and operate in places that they can get to with most of the way via wheeled vehicles.

Manned v. Assisted v. Remotely Operated v. Autonomous Systems


Increasingly, military systems are operated with machine assistance, remotely, or autonomously, rather than directly manned without machine assistance.

Even when systems are still manned, electronic targeting systems for everything from fighter- based missiles to artillery batteries to tanks to sniper rifles are becoming the norm. Functions like ammunition loading or material moving are also increasingly machine assisted. There are also safety overrides in many systems.

Almost every weapons system that isn't personally carried, e.g. all weapons mounted on vehicles or buildings, can and generally should be, at a minimum, remotely operated. For example, machine guns mounted on Humvees are now largely remotely operated, keeping the operator out of harm's way.

Many drones are remotely operated rather than truly being autonomous. Some drones are significantly autonomous, and some weapons systems that require almost instantaneous responses especially in active defenses are autonomous.

The implications of this for future conflicts of this factor are quite complex, while the other factors have relatively straightforward implications.

Fair Fights v. Asymmetric Engagements


There are two components to this concept.

Asymmetric Warfare

One is what is known as asymmetric warfare which is now predominant. 

This basically means that most wars are fought guerilla/insurgency style by one side. Usually, one side quickly obtains air superiority and using that control can also dispatch the opponent's heavy military equipment such as warships, tanks, heavy mobile artillery, armored personnel carriers, and fixed military bases with missiles and smart bombs. This means that quite early on, one side will have a full range of conventional heavy military armaments and the other will be limited to light infantry forces as most, in cases where the side reduced to light forces ever had heavier forces in the first place. There are very few countries which are "near peers" to the U.S. military and its allies, or to other major military powers, and as long as they don't get into wars with each other (which mutual assured destruction logic due to nuclear armaments for many world powers and the considerations of massive losses economic and military, even in a non-nuclear conflict, strongly discourage).

Asymmetric Weapons Systems In Battles

The other is at the operational level. Fighting an opponent with a comparable weapons system is rarely optimal.

If any adversary has a surface warship, you are probably best advised to counter that with aircraft, long range missiles, submarines, sea mines, swarms of small missile boats, SEAL type bombing raids, or biological warfare, rather than with another surface warship of the same class.

If an adversary has tanks or heavily armored vehicles, you may be best advised to counter them with artillery missiles, aircraft, land mines and light anti-tank missile forces. Tanks and other heavily armored vehicles, instead, are best used against forces with weapons lighter than tanks who have small arms and lightly armored vehicles, but not heavily armored vehicles or anti-tank weapons at their disposal.

Typically, you will defend against enemy airpower with light surface to air missiles if you don't have air superiority and more advanced air to air fighter capabilities than your opponent. It may be futile to even try to invest in the capabilities needed to have top rate air to air fighter capabilities that could deny an enemy air superiority for an extended time period. You would also want to focus on attacking air capabilities at adversary air bases, which are easier to attack fixed ground targets, if you can, rather than when your adversary's air to air fighters are in the air.

Likewise, if you have air superiority, you would want to invest primarily in air to ground warplane capability, rather than in air to air combat capability which is only useful at most in the brief time period in which you are acquiring air superiority.

Conclusions

Due to limitations of time, I am not working through the implications of these trends at a larger level, but these are some of the biggest trends that should be considered in thinking about the next stage of warfare driven by modern technology.

We are fighting the last war and procuring weapon systems on an expensive autopilot that provides limited value for money. Conventional wisdom in the military largely reflects this reality.

Deeper thought at the big picture level about the implications of these trends could give us a more effective military force at a smaller cost, and would help us focus better on the kind of threats and engagements it makes sense to prepare our military to fight. Failure to do so could lead to a sudden massive failure of our military because somebody else did this thinking and we didn't.

08 July 2020

A Long Blog

Blogger now gives you the option of downloading your entire blog into a word format document including all html code not visible to an outside reader. It does so at a default 10 point font. 

The Wash Park Prophet blog alone fills 11,313 pages and takes 5,327,404 words as of this morning. The average post takes about one and a half pages in printed out downloaded form. This is about the length of 34 paperback novels.

The Dispatches From Turtle Island blog fills 6,124 pages and takes 2,923,869 words as of this afternoon. This is about the length of 18 paperback novels.

Combined, there are 17,437 pages and 8,251,273 words between the two blogs. This is about the length of 52 paperback novels.

Quote of the Day

Sometimes a concept is baffling not because it is profound but because it is wrong.
– E. O. Wilson

Combat Soldiers Have Gotten Younger


Combat soldiers are now younger than there were in many major U.S. and U.K. wars. I've edited away almost everything but the raw factual data in this op-ed piece from the Military Times about the age of soldiers in U.S. and U.K. military service quoted below. 
As counter-intuitive as it would appear, the average age of young men dying in combat has decreased substantially from the mid-twenties of earlier wars to the late teens. One estimate puts the average age of Union soldiers during the American Civil War at just under twenty-six years old. A report on enlisted men from North-West England in the Great War puts the average age of dead soldiers at twenty-seven years old but more nineteen year olds died than any other age group. By World War II the average age of the US fighting man was still twenty-six years. In the Vietnam War the average age of soldiers killed in action had declined to 23 years and twenty percent of those killed were less than twenty years old. . . . 
A snapshot of this evolving paradigm came on 10 July 2009 when five UK servicemen with an average age of twenty years were killed in the very dangerous Helmand province of Afghanistan. Three of the dead soldiers were only eighteen. . . . 
SFC David D. Hack, US Army (Ret.) came up with this analysis of Vietnam War casualties: 
• Five men killed in Vietnam were only 16 years old
• Of those killed, 61% were younger than 21 years old.
• 11,465 of those killed were younger than 20 years old.
• The average age of the 58,148 killed in Vietnam was 23.11 years. . . . 
As these statistics show, notwithstanding lyrics of a popular song to the contrary, neither the average nor the median age of soldiers who died in Vietnam was nineteen (about 20% were nineteen or younger). The median age of U.S. soldiers dying in Vietnam was 20 and the average was 23. But, this was much younger than in prior conflicts.

The same source notes that both the U.S. and U.K. military allow both quite old and quite young people to enlist in the military.
The U.S, Military seems to agree with the concept of older recruits with a policy change by the Air Force in June 2014 when the maximum age for enlistment was raised from 27 to 39 years of age. The enlistment age restrictions for the Army, Navy and Marines are 35, 34 and 28. In a version of the moving goal post of necessity the U.S. Army announced in 2006 that they were increasing the maximum enlistment age to forty-two years old, the second time in six months having previously raised it to 40 years old. 
The UK Ministry of Defence raised the enlistment age limit for its Army Reserve in November 2014 to 52 from 43, individuals with specific qualifications or experience 45 to 50. The announcement included references to older soldiers sharing knowledge and experience as well as widening the recruitment pool. It was stated that this was part of a plan to reduce the regular Army by bolstering the number of Reservists. . . . 
The United States will allow enlistment of a seventeen year old teenager into their military with parental consent and eighteen year old without that consent. There are many aspects of law where certain individuals such as underage girls and more recently, boys, are incapable of consent. Surely this should apply to an equally dangerous scenario with even greater potential harm to the underage person. 
There is a greater debate in Britain than in America over the minimum enlistment age of boys into the military perhaps because the age is so low in the United Kingdom. A boy can apply for military enlistment in England at the age of fifteen years and seven months with parental consent to join at sixteen years old. . . .  
One realistic point of view is that a large majority of potential underage recruits fail early for health, academic or criminal history reasons. A senior military officer put the actual recruitment pool at less than five percent of the available under twenty-five year olds and even down from that for deduction of failures in the Armed Forces Qualification Test.
The term "available under twenty-five years olds" is a weasel word above, that probably omits men under the age of twenty-five who are in college or employed full time in a  decent "real job" and hence aren't interested in joining the military.

While physical fitness is certainly relevant to military service, it also isn't clear to me just what share of positions in military service actually require the level of fitness and physical ability that is predominantly found in young men to perform their duties. Certainly, there are some, but a lot of military jobs don't obviously require this, particularly in the modern Navy, the modern Air Force, and in non-front line combat posts (e.g. diesel mechanics and computer system operators).

07 July 2020

Brain Scans Lend Insight Into Six Common Psychiatric Conditions

We are starting to figure out how psychiatric disorders previously classified solely by symptoms are related to each other (and different from each other) at a biological level in the brain. 
"We found that 4 major psychiatric disorders -- major depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and obsessive-compulsive disorder -- show a surprisingly high level of similarity in their brain structural abnormalities," said Dr. Opel. The shared brain areas showing structural aberrations were mainly in cortical areas associated with cognitive processing, memory and self-awareness. 
On the flipside, Dr. Opel added, "we were able to identify regional abnormalities with high specificity for certain disorders." Interestingly, these distinct structural differences sometimes appeared in the same area for two disorders, but in opposite directions from the norm. 
In contrast, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and autism spectrum disorder did not share brain structural signatures with any other disorders. That may be because those disorders are considered developmental diseases with a distinct etiology from the other psychiatric conditions, which have more in common. 
The researchers do not yet understand the mechanisms behind the shared structural elements, but a growing body of evidence shows that these psychiatric disorders also share common genetic as well as environmental influences, which might underlie the current findings.
From Science Daily. The paper and its abstract are as follows:
Background 
Neuroimaging studies have consistently reported similar brain structural abnormalities across different psychiatric disorders. Yet, the extent and regional distribution of shared morphometric abnormalities between disorders remains unknown. 
Methods 
Here, we conducted a cross-disorder analysis of brain structural abnormalities in 6 psychiatric disorders based on effect size estimates for cortical thickness and subcortical volume differences between healthy control subjects and psychiatric patients from 11 mega- and meta-analyses from the ENIGMA (Enhancing Neuro Imaging Genetics Through Meta Analysis) consortium. Correlational and exploratory factor analyses were used to quantify the relative overlap in brain structural effect sizes between disorders and to identify brain regions with disorder-specific abnormalities. 
Results 
Brain structural abnormalities in major depressive disorder, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and obsessive-compulsive disorder were highly correlated ( r = .443 to r = .782), and one shared latent underlying factor explained between 42.3% and 88.7% of the brain structural variance of each disorder. The observed shared morphometric signature of these disorders showed little similarity with brain structural patterns related to physiological aging. In contrast, patterns of brain structural abnormalities independent of all other disorders were observed in both attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and autism spectrum disorder. Brain regions showing high proportions of independent variance were identified for each disorder to locate disorder-specific morphometric abnormalities. 
Conclusions 
Taken together, these results offer novel insights into transdiagnostic as well as disorder-specific brain structural abnormalities across 6 major psychiatric disorders. Limitations comprise the uncertain contribution of risk factors, comorbidities, and medication effects to the observed pattern of results that should be clarified by future research.

U.S. Navy Cuts Nine Ships

The U.S. Navy is cutting its fleet in its budget message for 2021, which won't materially impact the status of the U.S. as the dominant naval force in the world. Notably, eight of the nine ships are focused on littoral operations, an already shortchanged part of the force structure.
The U.S. Navy plans to inactivate nine ships in fiscal 2021, the service said in a message to the fleet. 
According to a June 30 message from the chief of naval operations, four littoral combat ships (LCS), three coastal patrol ships (PC) and one dock landing ship (LSD) are to be decommissioned. The Military Sealift Command will remove from service one fleet ocean tug (T-ATF).
As planned in the Navy’s 2021 budget proposal, the service plans to decommission the first two Freedom-class LCSs — USS Freedom and USS Fort Worth — and first two Independence-class LCSs — USS Independence and USS Coronado. Three of these ships have made major deployments to the western Pacific and all have been used as development platforms to mature the type’s concept of operations. The four LCSs, all based in San Diego, will be placed in reserve status. 
The three Cyclone-class PCs to be decommissioned are all based in Mayport, Florida, and used to train crews for the 10 PCs based in the Persian Gulf with the U.S. 5th Fleet. The three PCs being decommissioned — USS Zephyr, USS Shamal and USS Tornado — will be scrapped. 
The Whidbey Island-class LSD being decommissioned is USS Fort McHenry, which will be placed in reserve. The move will leave seven ships of the class still in service. 
The Powhatan-class T-ATF being removed from service is USS Sioux, which will be scrapped. Its removal will leave two T-ATFs in service. The class is being replaced by the Navajo-class towing, salvage and rescue ships. 
All eight commissioned ships listed above are to be decommissioned by March 31, 2021. The Sioux is to be removed from service by Sept. 30, 2021.
From here.

Prior to the decommissioning, there were 19 LCS that were commissioned and in service, with 35 (including these 19) planned.

05 July 2020

Advice To A King On Wine And Women From His Mother (Proverbs Chapter 31)

1 The sayings of King Lemuel contain this message, which his mother taught him.

2 O my son, O son of my womb,
O son of my vows,
3 do not waste your strength on women,
on those who ruin kings.

4 It is not for kings, O Lemuel, to guzzle wine.
Rulers should not crave alcohol.
5 For if they drink, they may forget the law
and not give justice to the oppressed.
6 Alcohol is for the dying,
and wine for those in bitter distress.
7 Let them drink to forget their poverty
and remember their troubles no more.

8 Speak up for those who cannot speak for themselves;
ensure justice for those being crushed.
9 Yes, speak up for the poor and helpless,
and see that they get justice.
A Wife of Noble Character

10 Who can find a virtuous and capable wife?
She is more precious than rubies.
11 Her husband can trust her,
and she will greatly enrich his life.
12 She brings him good, not harm,
all the days of her life.

13 She finds wool and flax
and busily spins it.
14 She is like a merchant’s ship,
bringing her food from afar.
15 She gets up before dawn to prepare breakfast for her household
and plan the day’s work for her servant girls.

16 She goes to inspect a field and buys it;
with her earnings she plants a vineyard.
17 She is energetic and strong,
a hard worker.
18 She makes sure her dealings are profitable;
her lamp burns late into the night.

19 Her hands are busy spinning thread,
her fingers twisting fiber.
20 She extends a helping hand to the poor
and opens her arms to the needy.
21 She has no fear of winter for her household,
for everyone has warm clothes.

22 She makes her own bedspreads.
She dresses in fine linen and purple gowns.
23 Her husband is well known at the city gates,
where he sits with the other civic leaders.
24 She makes belted linen garments
and sashes to sell to the merchants.

25 She is clothed with strength and dignity,
and she laughs without fear of the future.
26 When she speaks, her words are wise,
and she gives instructions with kindness.
27 She carefully watches everything in her household
and suffers nothing from laziness.

28 Her children stand and bless her.
Her husband praises her:
29 “There are many virtuous and capable women in the world,
but you surpass them all!”

30 Charm is deceptive, and beauty does not last;
but a woman who fears the Lord will be greatly praised.
31 Reward her for all she has done.
Let her deeds publicly declare her praise. 
Footnotes
31:1 Or of Lemuel, king of Massa [probably intended to refer to advice that King Solomon received from his mother]; or of King Lemuel, an oracle.
31:10 Verses 10-31 comprise a Hebrew acrostic poem; each verse begins with a successive letter of the Hebrew alphabet.
From the New Living Translation. 

Fifteen Years Of Blogging

Friday, July 3, 2020, was the 15th anniversary of this blog. Between this blog, its sister blog Dispatches From Turtle Island, and my unfinished serial novel, Wash Park Poet, I am on track to have made 10,000 posts sometime later this month.

North Korea's Hollow Military

North Korea is the most militarized country on Earth. But, behind massive numbers of soldiers is a level of readiness that had rotted, according to a recent Wall Street Journal report based upon testimony from a defector from the North Korean military. 

This seems to be in line with other reports on civilian and military life in North Korea, whose totalitarian regime and isolated economy have undermined its people's ability to function.

02 July 2020

Human Development Index By Region In South Asia

There are stark regional divisions in standard of living across South Asia. It is the least homogeneous region in the world in that respect. The fact that Sri Lanka is near the top, despite the fact that it had almost as long of a civil war as Afghanistan, which is near the bottom, in recent history, is particularly notable.

Hat tip to Razib Khan.

Also, total fertility rate in South Asia from the same author at the same blog in other post.

The Empirical Foundations Of The Case For Gun Control In A Nutshell

* Guns are not used millions of times each year in self-defense.
* Most purported self-defense gun uses are gun uses in escalating arguments, and are both socially undesirable and illegal.
* Firearms are used far more often to intimidate than in self-defense.
* Guns in the home are used more often to intimidate intimates than to thwart crime.
* Adolescents are far more likely to be threatened with a gun than to use one in self-defense.
* Criminals who are shot are typically the victims of crime.
* Few criminals are shot by decent law-abiding citizens.
* Self-defense gun use is rare and not more effective at preventing injury than other protective actions.
From here (with further explanation and peer reviewed research sources). 

01 July 2020

Quote of the Day

I would rather be a devil in alliance with truth, than an angel in alliance with falsehood.
― Ludwig Feuerbach

30 June 2020

SCOTUS Clarifies Federal Trademark Law Of Generic Marks 8-1

The latest U.S. Supreme Court ruling strengthens federal trademark protection for marginal trademarks of the type "genericmark.com" that arguably should have been considered generic marks not entitled to federal trademark protection. 

By rejecting the U.S. PTO's proposed bright line rule, the ruling also greatly increases the uncertainty involved with marginal trademarks, increasing the cost of determining if a trademark is valid and of litigating that mark if it violates the bright line rule but could conceivably meet the looser U.S. Supreme Court legal standard. Under this decision, more cases will go to trial and fewer cases will be possible to decide in a pre-trial motion to dismiss or motion for summary judgment at a much lower costs. The failure of the court to engage with the civil litigation cost impacts of the case, however, is somewhat disappointing.

This is an important issue, in the sense that it arises frequently, but a quite narrow one that hinges a great deal upon the fact that website addresses are unique, unlike other kinds of company names with type of entity designators, and product names. Indeed, the logic of the case comes close to establishing a per se rule that genericmark.com marks are never themselves generic, which from a civil litigation perspective really would have been a better rule.

There were legitimate arguments both ways on the merits in the case, but this case joins a long streak of intellectual property cases (mostly going against intellectual property right holders) that do not show strong partisan divides in the nation's highest court. 

From the official syllabus of the opinion in U.S. PTO v. Booking.com:
A generic name—the name of a class of products or services—is ineligible for federal trademark registration. Respondent Booking.com, an enterprise that maintains a travel-reservation website by the same name, sought federal registration of marks including the term “Booking.com.” Concluding that “Booking.com” is a generic name for online hotel-reservation services, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (PTO) refused registration. Booking.com sought judicial review, and the District Court determined that “Booking.com”—unlike the term “booking” standing alone—is not generic. The Court of Appeals affirmed, finding no error in the District Court’s assessment of how consumers perceive the term “Booking.com.” The appellate court also rejected the PTO’s contention that, as a rule, combining a generic term like “booking” with “.com” yields a generic composite. 
Held: A term styled “generic.com” is a generic name for a class of goods or services only if the term has that meaning to consumers. Pp. 6–14. 
(a) Whether a compound term is generic turns on whether that term, taken as a whole, signifies to consumers a class of goods or services. The courts below determined, and the PTO no longer disputes, that consumers do not in fact perceive the term “Booking.com” that way. Because “Booking.com” is not a generic name to consumers, it is not generic. Pp. 6–7. 
(b) Opposing that determination, the PTO urges a nearly per se rule: When a generic term is combined with a generic Internet-domain name suffix like “.com,” the resulting combination is generic. The rule the PTO proffers is not borne out by the PTO’s own past practice and lacks support in trademark law or policy. Pp. 7–14. 
(1) The PTO’s proposed rule does not follow from Goodyear’s India Rubber Glove Mfg. Co. v. Goodyear Rubber Co., 128 U. S. 598. Goodyear, the PTO maintains, established that adding a generic corporate designation like “Company” to a generic term does not confer trademark eligibility. According to the PTO, adding “.com” to a generic term—like adding “Company”—can convey no source-identifying meaning. That premise is faulty, for only one entity can occupy a particular Internet domain name at a time, so a “generic.com” term could convey to consumers an association with a particular website. Moreover, an unyielding legal rule that entirely disregards consumer perception is incompatible with a bedrock principle of the Lanham Act: The generic (or nongeneric) character of a particular term depends on its meaning to consumers, i.e., do consumers in fact perceive the term as the name of a class or, instead, as a term capable of distinguishing among members of the class. Pp. 8–11. 
(2) The PTO’s policy concerns do not support a categorical rule against registration of “generic.com” terms. The PTO asserts that trademark protection for “Booking.com” would give the mark owner undue control over similar language that others should remain free to use. That concern attends any descriptive mark. Guarding against the anticompetitive effects the PTO identifies, several doctrines ensure that registration of “Booking.com” would not yield its holder a monopoly on the term “booking.” The PTO also doubts that owners of “generic.com” brands need trademark protection in addition to existing competitive advantages. Such advantages, however, do not inevitably disqualify a mark from federal registration. Finally, the PTO urges that Booking.com could seek remedies outside trademark law, but there is no basis to deny Booking.com the same benefits Congress accorded other marks qualifying as nongeneric. Pp. 11–14.

23 June 2020

Presidential Race Polling Summary Four And A Half Months Out

The polls need to swing towards Trump by roughly 6.6 percentage points (implying national polling in favor of Biden by 2.6 percentage points), allowing Trump to take Minnesota, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Arizona, North Carolina, Ohio, Georgia, Iowa and Texas (but not Florida, New Hampshire, Nevada or Michigan) for Trump to win the electoral college, according to the FiveThirtyEight blog.
Overall — assuming that states that haven’t been polled go the same way as they did in 2016 — Biden leads in states worth 368 electoral votes, while Trump leads in states totalling 170 electoral votes. 
But a potential problem for Biden is that Trump could have an Electoral College advantage if the election tightens. Biden currently leads Trump by “only” 6.6 points in the current tipping-point state, Minnesota, but this is narrower than Biden’s 9.2-point lead in the national polls.

From here.


* * *
Polling aggregation at Real Clear Politics largely confirms this assessment.


New Mexico Biden + 11.0
Virginia Biden + 11.0
Minnesota Biden + 10.5
Colorado Biden + 10.0 (August 2019)
Maine Biden +10 (no CD breakdown, ignores old polls).
Michigan Biden + 8.0
New Hampshire Biden + 4.3
Nevada Biden + 4.0
Ohio Trump +0.5
Iowa Trump + 1.5
Texas Trump + 1.5
Georgia Trump + 7.5
South Carolina Trump + 12.0 (ignores old poll)

National Biden + 10.1

Betting Odds  Biden 56.8% Trump 36.8%.

* * *


Cook's Political Report leans far to the right of FiveThirtyEight in its predictions, but the trends still aren't good for Trump in its June 2020 assessment. 
This means there are 248 Electoral votes in the Lean to Solid Democratic category and 204 Electoral votes in Lean to Solid Republican. There are 86 Electoral votes in Toss Up.
To win the Electoral College, Biden needs 22 of the 86 votes in its "toss up" category. This would be Florida, or any two of the other four "toss up" states in their assessment.

Trump needs 66 of the 86 votes in its "toss up" category. Thus, he needs four out of five "toss up" states, one of which must be Florida (and also Ohio, Iowa, Georgia and Texas), to win.

Let's recall how many Electoral College votes some of these swing states have:

Maine (4)
Michigan (16)
New Hampshire (4)

Minnesota (10)

Florida (29)
Wisconsin (10)
Pennsylvania (20)
Arizona (11)
North Carolina (15)

Ohio (18)
Texas (38)
Iowa (6)
Georgia (16)



The states that Cook's rates as "Lean R" are polling 0.7 percentage points for Trump to 2.7 points for Biden and are really the "toss up" states that are in statistical ties.

The states that Cook's rates as "toss up" are polling 3.0 to 6.9 percentage points for Biden and are really "Leans D" states.

The states that Cook's rates "Leans D" are polling 6.6 to 10.2 percentage points for Biden and are really "Likely D" states.

There are some modest differences in how FiveThirtyEight and Cook's rank the states relative to each other. Cook's thinks Maine, Michigan and Florida are a bit more Trump leaning than FiveThirtyEight does relative to other states. But, there aren't huge differences in their rankings of the relative competitiveness of the swing states in 2020.


Widespread Higher Education Is New And Other Education Trends




From here.

In 1950, because WWII interrupted higher education for many people in born from 1915-1925 (ages 16-26 when the U.S. joined World War II, and 20-30 when World War II ended), the percentage of adults age 25-30 who had completed 4 year college degrees in the U.S. was at a record low. About 4% of white men, about 2.5% of white women, and about 1% of black men and women.


The Great Depression that led up to World War II also wasn't good for college attendance. Many people simply couldn't afford to stay in school to get a high school education, let alone a four year college education.

Now, that's changed. About 45% of white women, 35% of white men, 25% of black women, and 17% of black men who were aged 25-35 in 2015 had earned four year college degrees, and there was no sign that the trend was abating. 

Graduate degrees were rare indeed. They basically didn't exist prior to 1870. They have become much more common, with the rates of graduate degree completion between 2000 and 2010 doubled between then.
Since 2000, the number of people age 25 and over whose highest degree was a master’s has doubled to 21 million. The number of doctoral degree holders has more than doubled to 4.5 million. Now, about 13.1 percent of U.S. adults have an advanced degree, up from 8.6 percent in 2000.
From here. 






From here.

Public v. Private College Enrollment

Higher education enrollment in 2016 (which was 19.841 million in all) was about 74% public, 20% private non-profit (about 13.4% of the total at secular nonprofit institutions, and about 7.6% of the total at religiously affiliated institutions), and 6% for profit.

According to this source:
Religiously affiliated educational institutions often developed in response to social changes. For example, the world's first college charted to grant degrees to women was Wesleyan College in Macon, Georgia (1836). At the conclusion of the Civil War, the Freedman's Aid Society responded to absence of educational opportunity for newly freed slaves by creating institutes and colleges throughout the South. Many of these institutions continue their critical role in education in the early twenty-first century. Often church-related colleges began as academies or seminaries and then grew to college or university status. Many had short lives, closing as the result of social, demographic, political, and–quite often–financial reasons. Some colleges severed their relationship with the religious communities and continue in the twenty-first century as quality independent institutions. Among these are Vanderbilt University, Auburn University, University of Southern California, Oberlin College, and Princeton University. In 1881, 80 percent of the colleges in the United States were church related and private. In 2001, 20 percent of the colleges–approximately 980 institutions–had connection to a religious tradition. The "Digest of Educational Statistics, 2000," indicates that sixty-six religious groups in the United States currently sponsor colleges or universities. These institutions enroll more than 1.5 million students.
Notably, the share of higher education enrollment at private religiously affiliated institutions (about 7.6%) is quite close to that at the K-12 level discussed below (7.8%).

In both cases, the extent to which a religious affiliation meaningfully impacts the operations of the institution and is economically important, varies widely. Many, but not all, have undergone a shift from what:
George M. Marsden characterizes colleges and universities as moving from a perspective of "Protestant establishment" to one of "established nonbelief," a move toward embracing secularization and diminishing religious tradition.
The economic subsidy from affiliated religious institutions is now usually small, even though this wasn't necessarily true historically:
Religiously affiliated colleges and universities also receive expressions of partnerships and support from their sponsoring tradition. Financial support for the institutions usually represents less than 1 percent of their budgets; this is a radical decrease from the 1980s.

Figure 1 is from here.

But, since then, changed in federal financial aid policies have caused for profit higher education enrollments to plummet without offsetting gains in public high educational institutions and only modest gains in non-profit higher educational institution enrollments (mostly due to the successful conversion of a few large for profit institutions, like Ashford University and Grand Canyon University, from for profit to non-profit status).

Community college enrollments have also slipped in recent years, something that isn't very visible in measures of four year degree completion.

K-12 Education Enrollment Trends

As of 2015-2016 (the most recent statistics easily available to me), the national four year high school graduation rate in regular high school programs (as opposed, e.g., to GED programs) was 84.1%. In Iowa, it was 91.3%. In the District of Columbia, it was 69.3%.

Calculated in a more inclusive manner that counts people continuing to work towards a high school diploma after five years, or earning a high school diploma in an alternative program or with a GED, the overall national high school dropout rate was 6.1% for the same year, down more or less steadily from 27.2% in 1960, 15.0% in 1970, 14.1% in 1980, 12.1% in 1990, 10.9% in 2000, and 7.4% in 2010.

The current dropout rate (with the more inclusive measure) is 5.8% for white males, 6.2% for black males, 10.1% for Hispanic males, 4.6% for white females, 4.3% for black females, and 7.0% for Hispanic females.

Private v. Public Education


Table from CAPE.

Private K-12 education peaked around 1960 at 13.9% from which it declined to a 2014 low of 9.7%, and was lowest around 1920 at 7.3%.

About 10.2% of K-12 students attend private schools, 76% of which are religious (about 7.8% of the total) and 24% of which are secular (about 2.4% of the total). The nonsectarian, secular Montessori, Friends, Jewish, Islamic, and conservative Christian share have increased over the last 14 years, while the Roman Catholic, Adventist and other Protestant shares have declined.

The peak in private K-12 education around 1960 reflects resistance to school desegregation (Brown v. Board of Education was decided in 1954), which gradually waned, in part, due to growing comfort with desegregated schools and, in part, because de facto segregation based upon school attendance boundaries combined with white flight to the suburbs, tracking within schools, and school choice programs, provided alternatives that parents could find to circumvent school desegregation.

An older colleague at work, is his 60s, went to a private school in the District of Columbia at a time when most private schools in the District were not yet desegregated. 

The increase in non-sectarian and secular Montessori enrollment is largely a function of increased availability of voucher and charter school options in urban areas. Episcopal and Friends affiliated schools have draws similar to high prestige non-sectarian private schools, with Episcopal enrollment actually declining about 16% in absolute terms, and and the apparent 40% growth in Friends education in absolute terms probably partially being a function of rounding errors, although voucher programs may have helped in these cases as well.

The near doubling of the market share of Jewish affiliated K-12 enrollment, which is still a 50% increase in absolute terms, is probably largely attributable to the availability of voucher programs in areas with large Jewish populations (mostly in the Northeast Corridor), although increased concerns about anti-semitism and a desire to maintain a stronger Jewish identity could also play a part.

The increase in the Conservative Christian share largely reflects a steady enrollment in the face of a declining share of students attending private schools. There may also have been a fair amount of rebranding from Baptist and Calvinist to Conservative Christian.

In raw numbers, as opposed to percentage share figures, Roman Catholic education declined about 40% from 1992 (well after the peak) to 2016 and has probably declined further since then.

Declining Catholic and Protestant other than Conservative Christian enrollment largely reflects a shift to public schools and nonsectarian schools by parents who were primarily seeking to avoid what they perceived as "bad" desegregated public schools options, rather than because they were actively seeking religious instructions.

The growth in Islamic K-12 education reflects both a growing Muslim population in the U.S., mostly due to immigration, but in part, also due to conversion, and the availability of voucher programs.

Race and Medical School Admissions

Affirmative action in medical schools increased black and Latino medical school graduation rates by about 20%. This impact was significant, but much smaller than in top law schools. 
VEDANTAM: Well, several states have now banned schools from taking race into account. And this new analysis that I've looked at examines graduation rates at medical schools in California, Washington, Florida, Texas, Michigan and Nebraska. Now, schools in all these states have tried these techniques that we're talking about, and there are variations in how successful they are, but overall, there are strong patterns in the outcomes. I spoke with Liliana Garces at Penn State University, and along with David Mickey-Pabello, she's found that there's been a sharp drop in the number of black and Latino students graduating from medical schools in these states. Here she is. 
LILIANA GARCES: If you think about before the bans, for every 100 students that matriculated in medical schools in states with bans, there were 18 students of color. But after the bans, for every 100 students matriculated, there are now about 15.
From National Public Radio.

22 June 2020

Why Are They This Way? What Can We Do To Change Them?

On Facebook someone said: 
Try to think about how people became this way. Why do they think it is right? What can we do to respect people and talk across the divide? 
in response to this post:

Image may contain: 3 people, people standing, shoes, beard and outdoor
PucktographyJune 2 at 1:22 AM ·

This evening the town of Coeur d'Alene Idaho heard rumors that the same people who rumored to come in white vans into Spokane Washington last night were headed there. It was said these were the instigators that ruined a otherwise peaceful protest, broke into local business and vandalized. The local militia men and women responded with arriving all over downtown guarding all the major intersections. Store owners were boarding up their windows in preparation, while sentinels stood guard and others watched or enjoyed the local food and drink. There were some peaceful protesters there as well that were not bothered or hurt by the armed guards. North Idaho will not put up with Antifa or any group that threatens their towns. As always feel free to share and regardless of your political affiliation or viewpoints I hope you stay safe and enjoy the photos.
My response was as follows:
"What can we do to respect people and talk across the divide?" 
"We" in the general public can't talk across the divide. The gap is too wide and there is a metaphorical soundproof wall between us. All messages from the mainstream media, scientists, academia, school teachers, government officials, and "liberals" has been put on "blocked/ignore" status. Any talking to change their minds has to come from within - their extended families, or their own clergy, or people they do business with, or former members who have second thoughts.  
In the big picture, people in these communities are driven to this kind of movement and evolve culturally into this (1) through decades of economic stagnation and economic insecurity for non-college educated white men since the early 1970s that has left them with daily struggles and impaired their ability to have stable marriages, which they are seeking to blame on any scapegoats that they can (mostly the wrong ones like gays, blacks, Hispanics, and immigrants, rather than big business and government indifference), (2) the development of a white supremacist prison gang movement initially as a way to unite in response to minority street gangs that extended into prisons, that has continued to be a part of their lives after getting out, and (3) encouragement from sources like Fox News, less mainstream far right media and social network sources, clergy, and GOP leaders. This has also been plugged into a pre-existing anti-intellectual, law disregarding mountain man ethos in places like Idaho.  
Policies that would increase economic security for working class men, and that would reduce mass incarceration, would prevent prison gang formation when people are in gangs, and would encourage reintegration after getting out, and focusing on taking down demagogues in the GOP and corporate support for forces like Fox News, would help end these movements. 
GOP leaders know this in their bones even if they don't consciously understand things in those terms, which is why they are so adamantly opposed to universal health care, social services programs, minimum wage support, paid leave, and labor unions would would take away the economic stagnation and insecurity and fear that drive conservative political movements.