16 November 2015

Blizzard

A blizzard warning is in force for Denver and all points to the Northeast in Colorado.

Most of my professional colleagues, office mates, and apparently the Denver Public Schools folks who make decision on school closures and delays, don't seem to understand the difference between a serious winter storm with heavy snowfall, which Denver gets several times a year, and a genuine blizzard, which we haven't had in Denver once since I moved here in the spring of 1999.

The real danger of a blizzard is not that it is slippery, although it is.  Blizzards are dangerous because they can completely wipe out your visibility with the speed of a gust of wind filling the air with blinding snow.

Shortly after I moved to Oxford, Ohio as a child, in 1977, there was a blizzard.  Several college students died in it, trying to make the short several block trip from their fraternity houses to the liquor store (back when you didn't have to be twenty-one to buy 3.2 beer).  They got lost and froze to death right on High Street which runs through downtown Oxford, such as it is.

I've driven in near blizzard conditions, but it isn't something I would repeat if I could help it.  The only accidents that I've had that have involved both vehicles in motion (I've nicked parked cars a couple of times, and have been fit once while I was stopped at a stoplight on a clear day), took place is snowy, near blizzard conditions.

They are not to be messed with and I've postponed a deposition tomorrow that was supposed to start at the projected worst time for blizzard activity until the precipitation is projected to have ended in Denver (the blizzard warning ends at 2 p.m. but the weather is projected to abate from West to East).

Maybe this blizzard warning will turn out to be a false alarm.  But, I'm not about to be forewarned and rush into the situation like a fool anyway, when I don't absolutely have to do so for some reason that will seem important enough to have justified it if I or someone else is in a serious car accident as a result.

If you must drive in blizzard or near blizzard conditions, 9 News has some useful hints that you should heed which match my previous experiences driving in these conditions.

The Friday The Thirteenth Massacre In Paris And Its Root Causes

A few thoughts on the multiple terrorist attacks on Friday evening in Paris.

France

* Some news reports state that it took three hours for police to enter the scene at the rock concert hall where terrorists with assault rifles killed and wounded a majority of the victims of this attack.  Law enforcement learned that the rules are different in hostage situations where there is an active shooter sometime around the time of the Columbine shooting in Colorado.  The French need to learn that lesson now.  This is the one respect in which the official response in France can be seriously faulted.

* It is striking that most of the attacks last Friday and back in January, were concentrated in just one or two Parisian neighborhoods, presumably due to their symbolic power.

* It is too early for police gathered evidence to reliably confirm that this attack was actually conducted by ISIS, but since ISIS claimed responsibility after the fact, it is legitimate to strike back against ISIS whether its claim of responsibility was true or not.

* The French military's experience fighting Islamist insurgents in Algeria, insurgents in Mali, and Boko Haram in the African Sahel, should serve it well should it choose to go beyond its bombing raid on the ISIS capitol on Sunday to some sort of ground campaign against ISIS.

* Some analysts are arguing that the strikes in Paris may be a response to military defeats in Iraq.  It is an interesting theory, but I'm not convinced.  There have also been hints, for all intents and purposes no more credible than rumors yet, that the train terrorist attack thwarted by off duty U.S. servicemen may have been planned by the same person or group that conducted the latest round of terrorist attacks, and perhaps also the earlier round of attacks in January.

* The terrorists in the latest massacre have spurred France to action and made it afraid in a way that it hadn't been until now.  But, ultimately, this massacre was a bee sting to a nation that is still secure and powerful and has integrated much of its Muslim population into its society.  One of the "good guy" martyrs in the January attacks was a French Muslim cop.  Yes, at least one attacker this time was a Syrian refugee and others had been foreign fighters in Syria.  Others were French citizens, but only a small number of insurgents lurk among a million or more loyal French Muslim citizens of recent immigrant heritage.

* The risk of mistakes from rash action here to France are greater than the risk of taking only more thoughtful action.  France has suffered a horrible tragedy, but even including the deaths and injuries it has suffered from terrorism in its crime statistics, it has still experienced much less homicide and violence than gun drenched Americans suffer in every ordinary year.  This is true despite the fact that its politics of general strikes, and extreme union tactics, are much more extreme and violent than American politics (or perhaps, the certainty that violence won't cross critical thresholds makes other street political action possible).

* France can't predict and stop every terrorist incident.  But, snatches of intelligence released in the news suggest that it isn't totally oblivious to the real risks either.  It has room to improve its anti-terrorist efforts while maintaining a human and democratic free society, even if it can never be perfectly successful.  But, it isn't starting from nothing either.  France needs to remember the importance of preserving its soft power, which the U.S. has too often forgotten to do in its long running war on terrorism.

The Middle East and Its Neighbors

* Neither Syria nor Iraq have capable without outside assistance of asserting de facto control over large swaths of their own territories, despite the inferior military equipment of ISIS.  They haven't even managed to do so with a coalition of powers led by the U.S. providing airstrikes and recent Russian intervention on behalf of the Baathist regime on the ground and from the air.

* Half of the population of Syria has been displaced, and many millions are refugees - some nearby in Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey, others making their way to Europe and beyond.  Thousands of refugees have died on the way, with losses particular high among those trying to travel by boat across the Mediterranean.

* Also, keep in mind that before its civil war, Syria had been home to millions of Sunni Arab refugees, mostly from predominantly Shiite areas of Iraq.  Many of them are now twice displaced.

* Who can fault the refugees for fleeing this horrible situation? On one side they have ISIS.  On the other they have an undemocratically selected rump Baathist regime that has used chemical weapons on its people, indiscriminately bombed its own cities and towns with airplanes, and dumped crude "barrel bombs" from helicopters on marketplaces full of its own people.  Only a reign of terror has allowed the regime to hold onto what it continues to control.  Food supplies are scarce.

* In part, the economies of Jordan and Lebanon may in the end be helped as much as hurt by the influx of newcomers.  Human capital matters more than physical capital.

* A significant share of Syria's territory is held by neither the rump Baathist regime nor ISIS.  The varied rebel forces holding this territory are not as bad as ISIS, but some of them are only a little better.

* The most optimistic development in the situation has been the development of grass roots civil society organizations doing their best to meet local needs in the face of insurmountable armed opposition from multiple sides.  Purported governments in exile formed from leaders of early rebel movements seem largely irrelevant at this point, however.

* The first of the Arab Spring revolutions, in Tunisia, seems to have resulted in a fragile but improved democratic government.

Libya's regime was deposed with our help in a campaign of bombing orchestrated by Hillary Clinton, but the nation is divided between competing successor regimes and order has not been fully restored.
Egypt had a revolution and a brief elected government, but an Army coup, fearful of the intentions of the Muslim Brotherhood backed winning coalition has put itself and its puppet back in charge.  It increasingly looks like a Russian aircraft crash leaving Egypt was bombed by ISIS.

To some extent our actions, particularly in Libya, led on Syrians to revolt too, although Russian opposition to outside intervention played a major part as well.

* Yemen's ugly and mostly ignored civil war had little to do with Arab Spring and it was a fragile democracy for a while, but its civil war is ongoing and all of the sides hate the U.S.  In hindsight, unifying North Yemen and South Yemen was a horrible idea that sowed the seeds of the current horrible civil war there.

* Saudi Arabia and the other Arabian oil monarchies are officially anti-ISIS.  But, there is good reason to suspect that non-regime factions in these affluent societies are fueling ISIS and other Islamic radical movements worldwide from the 9-11 attackers, to the Taliban in Afghanistan, to foreign fighters and funds that keep ISIS and other affiliates of it worldwide afloat.  Saudi Arabian involvement in Yemen's civil war has perpetrated indiscriminate attacks that have killed many civilians there and its motives in that conflict should be questioned.

* Iran has played the turmoil well.  The U.S. has neutered its Afghan neighbor to the East and its Iraqi neighbor to the West.  It has secured eased sanctions with a deal on its nuclear program.  U.S. actions segregated Iraq religiously leaving most of the Iraqi territory on the Iranian border firmly in the hand of provinces which have much smaller non-Shiite minorities and rump Iraq controlled by a civilian government that is a good friend of Iran.  Rise of ISIS is not unrelated to the religious and ethnic segregation that occurred as a result of U.S. occupation of Iraq following the Iraq War which fanned extremism and ethnic nationalism there, and ISIS has shifted focus away from Iran's wrongdoings.  Iran's homegrown political system has also emerged from years of international sanctions as a resilient Islamic democracy, which while not up to Western standards of human rights and electoral fairness, is still a state where elections do matter, rather than a dictatorship or one party state.  Its theocratic leadership has filled the role of a transitional constitutional monarch, with real power and a final say over key issues, but delegating considerable power to elected civilian leaders.

Iran has also quietly backed the Baathist regime in Syria, by encouraging fights among other factions there, and continued to back its anti-Israeli militias in Lebanon.

* Turkey hasn't necessarily improved its situation, but has managed to maintain domestic order and avoid mistakes that could have left it worse off.  On the whole it is managing the situation as well as could be expected.

* If there are any "good guys" in the conflict who can fairly be said to share of goals for the most part for the region, it is the Iraqi and Syrian Kurds and the Yazidi people whose genocide our intervention prevented with Kurdish assistance.  Despite Turkish discomfort with their Kurdish minority, and rump Iraq and rump Syria's insistence on preserving the pre-conflict status quo, the Kurds are long overdue for payback for their efforts and have among the most functional civilian self-governments in the region, as well as being one of the most "liberal" Islamic ethnic groups in the region by Western standards.  Why should U.S. diplomats insist that the Kurds remain subjected to the ineffectual, openly Shiite biased, and Iran-aligned rump Iraqi government whose military prowess has been pathetic as well, as opposed to being a sovereign states which is how they are acting in fact?

A Kurdish national homeland in the region would be a bastion of stability, democracy and tolerance compared to its neighbors (apart from Turkey).  And, unlike most of the other factions in the Middle East, the Kurds aren't obsessed with anti-Israeli or anti-American fervor.

* Israeli-Palestinian conflicts have gone on as usual, with periods of more and less intense conflict and no end in sight, despite all of the static in the region.

* Afghanistan is still at war with the Taliban, fourteen years after the U.S. intervened decisively in the Afghan civil war that it has almost won against it.  The related insurgency in Pakistan's frontier provinces is also still ongoing.  The U.S. installed regime in Afghanistan seems capable of holding onto control, but it has a fragile grip and is still fighting a low level civil war than flares up occasionally in parts of the country.  Those areas where the regime remains in control aren't always much to write home about, but the Taliban controlled area and the places where the fighting remains hot seem to be much worse.

Europe

* The refugee situation has made the Syrian civil war "Europe's problem" whether it likes it or not.

* In some ways Europe is well equipped to receive Muslim immigrants.  As a result of the Holocaust, most of Europe's Jews were either killed or fled to Israel or the U.S.  Most countries in Europe are secular leaning but historically Christian with significant Muslim minorities already.  In Germany, Muslim minorities are heavily Turkish.  In France, there are many Algerian Muslims.  In the U.K., there are many Pakistani Muslims.  Spain and Italy already had significant numbers of North Africans.  Even Scandinavia has taken in a significant minority of Muslim immigrants.  Integrating a large new wave of Muslim immigrants into their societies is not an entirely new problem for them.

* Countries like the U.K. and Germany are spending on the order of $1,000 per month per refugee per year to meet their needs, and there have been serious discussions of ways to shift the burden that nations closest to the border are facing.  Winter is coming and the need may increase.  European countries have mostly stepped up to the moral challenge of making a serious effort to treat refugees humanely, despite the growing unpopularity of this stance.

* Europe is also much more dependent upon Middle Eastern oil than the U.S. is, especially now that Russian intervention in the Ukraine has caused the rest of Europe to rule out reliance of Russian resources.

The Big Historical Arc

* Arab Spring has increasingly looked more like Europe in 1848, a round of European revolutions against monarchs that failed.  All of the Middle Eastern and North African monarchies remain secure with dissent there promptly crushed, even Jordan which is burdened with something like half a million refugees.  The only revolution that has tentatively left its people better off was the first in Tunisia.  Egypt has gone sidewise.  Libya has as much bad news as good and is neither a win nor a loss.  Syria was a disaster.

* The post-World War I settlement that defined the boundaries of the modern Middle Eastern nation states, as modified by the post-World War II creation of Israel, is in a state of piecemeal, but seemingly inevitable collapse.

* It is time for the U.S. to abandon the increasingly untenable dream of maintaining that settlement and time instead to imagine a new, more robust and stable alternative that can secure the backing of the people of the Middle East as they are today.

* The West has the military and economic might to obliterate ISIS, Boko Haram, and many other Islamist radical groups around the world, and to force Syria's war criminal led Baathist regime to capitulate and step down.  It has not yet decided that it is worth the cost in blood and treasure and a long term, locally resented colonial commitment to do so.  But, it is important to recognize that lack of fortitude, focused commitment to the cause, and ruthlessness is central to the reason that these groups can be effective enough to survive.  The costs may not be worth the benefits of doing so, because ultimately, no situation will be stable until it is accepted as legitimate by the local citizens.

At Least He's Not Your Town Board Member

In the front range hamlet of Pierce, Colorado (population 900), one of the town board members, D.J. Meyer, was the leader of a small biker gang that regularly beat people up and stole prescription drugs.

Last September, the town board member and the four members of his gang murdered a woman who had been a house guest of the board member, dumped her body in Wyoming, and dumped her dog twenty miles away. On October 29, the town board member and four gang members were arrested for murder based upon multiple confessions, another woman related to the gang was been arrested on lesser charges.  The dog has been recovered, and they are still looking for the body.

More than two weeks later, it ends up in the Denver Post.

The gang leader had run unopposed for the town board position, because it is hard to find anyway willing to serve as elected officials in small town government.  This time, they truly did end up picking from the bottom of the barrel, although apparently local town officials and law enforcement were not aware of the gang or its leader's criminal activities.

Newsflash: Governors Still Have No Say In Immigration Policy

Several U.S. governors have stated that their states will not accept Syrian refugees. But, under our system of federalism, they have absolutely no say in the matter because immigration is an exclusively federal function of government. The CNN news report's failure to mention this little detail reflects poorly on its credibility. The governors are entitled to their own opinions, but not their own facts.

13 November 2015

Arrow's Impossibility Theorem Strikes 3rd Circuit Appellate Ruling

A three way split in a 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals anti-trust case has caused Arrow's Impossibility Theorem, which states that some mixes of individual preferences leave the group's voting preference ill defined, (or some close cousin of it) has reared its ugly head, making it hard to figure out who should win and lose under the circumstances.
This case presents what academic literature terms a “voting paradox.” On the one hand, two judges (Judge Greenberg and I) believe that the outcome should be that Hanover’s suit not proceed, though we do so for different reasons. However, one majority of this Court (Judges Fuentes and Greenberg) believes that Hanover has antitrust standing (I do not because I do not discern antitrust injury), while another majority (Judge Fuentes and I) believes that Hanover should survive Village’s motion to dismiss (assuming it has antitrust standing). The paradox is that, if I vote on the judgment of this case (affirm or reverse) based on my individual views, a majority of the Court will have ruled against the prevailing party on each relevant issue, meaning that our Court’s reasoning would not support its judgment. However, if I follow, despite my dissent, Judge Fuentes and Greenberg on the antitrust standing issue, my individual vote would be inconsistent with my view of who should win were I alone ruling.
He chooses to vote by issue rather than by outcome. The full decision is here.

12 November 2015

The Disappointing Case For Soviet Style Democracy

I find it very hard to understand why it is at all legitimate to have a system of electing members of the board of directors of publicly held corporations in which the only candidates on the ballots are those persons nominated by the incumbent board of directors.  In other words, on ballots like those used by the Soviet Union and pre-Iraq War Iraq. Yet, there are law professors who do just that.  Basically, they argue that it would be a disaster to have a board of directors where all the votes weren't always unanimous and people sometimes offered dissenting opinions in discussions of corporate policy.

If you are going to favor the status quo, the only sensible choice, it seems to me, is to make it official and strip shareholders of any right whatsoever to vote in person or by proxy for members of the board of directors which would instead be officially self-perpetuating.   Then again, that proposal also has academic support.  This undermines even the possibility of a change in control by someone who has acquired a majority of the company's shares in the marketplace.

It is one thing to say that the sole say that shareholders should have in the management of corporations is to have a say indirectly through directors that the shareholders elect, and ending the ballot initiative process on micromanaged corporate policies.

It is quite another to say that shareholders should have no meaningful right whatsoever to control who serves on the board of directors and thereby controls the corporation, particularly in light of the minimal legal obligations that members of the Board of Directors are typically held to in litigation.

The self-perpetuating directorship concept fundamentally upends the nature of what a corporation is, particularly without the heightened prohibitions against self-dealing enforced by taxing authorities and state attorney generals that protects beneficiaries of non-profit organizations and business trusts.

Seriously, you would think that this was a case where there are barbarians at the gate, and not a case of institutional investors with multi-million dollar investments entirely run by 1%ers seeking a little bit of voice, because their huge portfolio limits as a practical matter their ability to vote with their feet.  They have so much money that they have to buy shares in pretty much every company that they are permitted by their fund charters to invest in.

10 November 2015

Cowardly Chicken Little Colorado Sheriffs

I have pretty much no respect whatsoever for the 41 Colorado Sheriff's who have written a letter to President Obama explaining that they are terrified that Guantanamo Bay inmates held in a maximum security prison in Colorado would "significantly - and unnecessarily - endanger our citizens."

This simply does not pass any reasonable reality check and makes this prisoners out to be comic book supervillains, rather than the bunch of mostly low level, mostly Yemeni al-Queda functionaries who haven't even committed any war crimes, that most of them are in fact.

The notion that some dangerous al-Queda fifth columnists would try to spring these detainees from a Colorado prison is simply laughable.  They would stand out like a sore thumb and have a very long way to go to a safe haven, unlike the current site in Cuba, where the Cuban government would likely embrace with open arms any escaped detainee and could do so with impunity.

The letter says much more about how cowardly and detached from reality most of these local government elected officials in Colorado are, than it does about the realities of the policy issues involved.

This is simply partisan demagoguery at its worst.  The politicians, including a few Democrats, who have given any credibility to this argument, deserve similar scorn.

09 November 2015

Independence Movement Heats Up In Catalonia

With a clear majority of 72 vs 63, the Catalan Parliament has approved this morning the nine points of the declaration that I advanced on Friday, which proclaims the beginning of a process for the formation of a sovereign and independent Catalan Republic, allowing for 30 days to initiate the corresponding key laws (constituent process, social security and public treasury) and declares insubordination towards Spanish institutions such as the Constitutional Court, explicitly mentioned.
More at From what we are . . . they will be.

The Catalan government seek a basically socialist leaning reorganization of their independent or autonomous region.

Will there be war? How will the constitutional crisis in Spain be resolved?

Parasites

I'm not the only one who finds the relationships between parasites and their hosts in nature to be some of the most compelling and fascinating stories out there in the natural world.  Science fiction author Charlie Stross crowd sources some interesting aspects of these stories at his blog.

Building Codes Are Still A Barrier To Affordable Housing

Denver's building codes arbitrarily disallow many "tiny-houses" which could otherwise alleviate affordable housing.  Building and zoning codes in Denver also place unduly restrictive limitations on accessory dwelling units and single occupancy hotels and hostels.

Eliminating code created barriers to affordable housing would do more to help households that find rents in Denver to be too high than current programs that require developers in large developments to create a certain number of units of affordable housing which have produced almost no results in practice so far.

The basic political reality is that those restrictions have remained in place because of NIMBY concerns of neighborhood associations afraid of higher densities and an influx of undesirable people into their neighborhoods.

A policy of making loans to developers of a handful of rent controlled apartment complexes, which is one of the main ways that Denver promotes affordable housing is not an effective solution to the problem.

05 November 2015

Conservatives For Darth Vader

Apparently, the hot new thing to do to win props in conservative political and policy circles is to take a bold stand in favor of Darth Vader and the Galactic Empire.

Perhaps it shouldn't be surprising that Professor Bainbridge, who is a tireless advocate for the anti-shareholder democracy faction in corporate law, is also an apologist for Darth Vader and the genocidal destruction of the planet Alderaan.

One of the Republican Presidential candidates, Marco Rubio, also recently made a point of making a pro-Vader speech, which just goes to show you which political party represents the Dark Side.

04 November 2015

Metro Denver School Board Election Recap

In Denver, three incumbent school board members were all re-elected in the face of teacher's union sponsored challenges emphasizing "neighborhood schools" as opposed to charter schools and magnet programs.  But, Board President Happy Haynes won by only about 800 votes out of well over 100,000 votes cast, just enough to avoid an automatic recount.

In first ring western suburb Jefferson County, in a race that captured national attention, all five far right conservative members of the school board were ousted in one decisive fell sweep - three in recall elections and two to challengers in the ordinary general election.

In exurban Douglas County, there was no recall election, but all three of the seven school board members facing regular election challenges were replaced.  Ideological conservatives sponsored by the Republican party controlled all seven seats on the school board prior to the election (whose energies among other things supported a religious school voucher program held to violate the state constitution and state education funding statutes).  Now, the ideological Republicans have a 4-3 majority on the board.

02 November 2015

Violent Islamic Intolerance

While not all societies with significant numbers of Muslims have significant percentages of the population who favor death to people who leave Islam, the percentages actually vary greatly, a great many predominantly Muslim societies have lots of people who do feel this way.

For example, more than 30% of the population of Bangladesh feels this way, and as a result a number of prominent atheist bloggers and publishers have been killed by Islamists there in the last couple of years.

While not all Islamic societies share this norm, a great many do, and that norm is incompatible with a modern, pluralistic society.

Sometimes Things Work

* Sometimes Congress actually does pass a budget before the government is shut down.

* Sometimes the cops catch the robbers.

* Sometimes a city government admits it was wrong in enforcing an unconstitutional ordinance without having to be sued to get it to fix its mistake.

* Sometimes the U.S. Supreme Court does the right thing.

It doesn't happen all the time.  But, it happens often enough that I haven't entirely lost faith in "the system."

Mac Trackpad Infinitely More Subtle

Back in the day, there were three things you could do with a Mac mouse.  You could click, you could double click, and you could drag by holding down the mouse as you moved it.

Now, there are sixteen different "gestures" you can make with a Mac trackpad (including "force click").

How can something so seemingly simple, actually be so complex.  It is elegant in its way, and I may eventually learn to like it.  But, there is definitely a learning curve.

Open Carry Law Delayed Response In Colorado Springs Shooting

Witnesses watched in horror as Harpham picked his victims off. One of them, the bicyclist, pleaded for his life before being killed.

"I heard the (young man) say, 'Don't shoot me! Don't shoot me!' " Naomi Bettis, a neighbor who witnessed the killing, said Monday.

Bettis said she recognized the gunman as her neighbor — whom she didn't know by name — and that before the initial slaying she saw him roaming outside with a rifle. She called 911 to report the man, but a dispatcher explained that Colorado has an open carry law that allows public handling of firearms.

"He did have a distraught look on his face," Bettis said. "It looked like he had a rough couple days or so."

After Harpham shot the bicyclist, Bettis said she watched him walk toward Platte Avenue. She then heard more gunfire.
From here.

Consumer Arbitration Really Is Unfair

The New York Times is running a series on the problems with arbitration, particularly consumer arbitration clauses in take it or leave it contracts of adhesion.

Part I

Part II

Part III

I'll fill out this post at a later date with some of the details of why its indictment of consumer arbitration is correct.  Previous posts at this blog on the subject can be located via the Arbitration tag. The CFPB, a new federal agency, is considering regulations banning or restricting the practice.  A number of major providers of consumer arbitration ceased to provide the service within the past few years.

The stories are effective because mandatory pre-dispute arbitration fundamentally conflicts with a variety of widespread norms held by participants in the community subject to arbitration over their rights in the transactions they enter into and their reasonable expectations of fairness.

There are isolated contexts where it can make sense, such as in business to business transactions where privacy and a swift resolution are imperative, and in business to business transactions in which large numbers of cases, none precedent setting, between entities are likely (e.g. resolution of fee disputes between realtors who are part of the National Association of Realtors over who gets what share of a real estate commission).

But, routine disputes between credit card companies, cable companies, cell phone companies, and the like, over systemic mistreatment of large numbers of similarly situated consumers are not benign and encourage dishonest business practices by large companies.

UPDATE November 5, 2015: Law professor Stephen Carter writing an opinion piece for Bloomberg offers a rather unpersuasive rebuttal to the New York Times account of consumer arbitration clauses discussed above.

As someone who actually represents parties on a fairly regular basis in cases that involve, or could involve, commercial arbitration, and who drafts contracts and evaluates contracts for clients, I should also put on my "to do" list comparison of most material differences between a court forum and an arbitration forum.

For example, privacy, rules of evidence, discovery, speed of litigation, limitations on injunctive relief, and the availability of appeals.  The particulars of these differences are often different for major arbitration forums, for example, the American Arbitration Association and the Judicial Arbiter Group, and a significant minority of arbitration clauses call for arbitration of very narrow issues without specifying any widely adopted set of arbitration rules.  Also, even within AAA arbitration rules, for example, there are actually several different sets of rules for different kinds of disputes.

There are some respects in which arbitration can be a superior forum for certain kinds of disputes, and in other respects arbitration can be profoundly inferior for many kinds of disputes.

In general, for example, the looser rules of evidence that apply in arbitration causes under AAA commercial arbitration rules, tend to be a positive difference between an arbitration forum for commercial cases, and a court forum for commercial cases using evidence rules largely designed in the first instance for criminal cases and applied more generally to all civil cases even though the justifications for them in commercial cases tried to a judge are far less compelling.

On the other hand, it is rare indeed that the near universal absence of appellate relief for a bad decision made in an arbitration forum is a good one, except in very simple, small stakes cases between repeat players with comparable power in the institutions that conduct the arbitrations. In those cases, the law of averages mitigates the harm caused by individual erroneous decisions on any given litigant over time, and the benefits of rapid dispute resolution and reduced costs that flow from a lack of appellate review outweigh the harms caused by a lack of appellate review in any individual wrongfully decided cases within a pool of cases. There may be a place for a lack of meaningful appellate review, for example, in fee disputes between Realtors involved in the same real estate transaction, or between banks resolving disputes over check payment snafus.

But, a lack of meaningful appellate relief is almost never fair to a litigant in a high stakes dispute who is a one time player or will only litigate in that forum a very small number of times.  The lack of meaningful appellate review of arbitration awards in these circumstances fundamentally undermines the rule of law.

In a significant class of disputes for which arbitration is often appropriate, privacy and freedom from government involvement in dispute resolution, are important motives for choosing this forum.  For example, arbitration is frequently a desirable forum for trade secret disputes.  But, bifurcation that allows some relief to be sought in the courts while limiting other relief to arbitration forums can undermine the argument for arbitration in these cases, as can the important harm caused by removing precedents that would have been valuable to litigants in future disputes from the public domain.

Filing fees in arbitration cases are universally much higher than the filing fees in comparable cases in the Court system.  These fees buy, in part, a significantly faster time from filing to resolution in most arbitration cases.  This is partially a procedural issue, and partially a product of an intense scarcity of judges in the vast majority of U.S. courts with jurisdiction over civil actions. But, generally speaking, the amount of attorneys' fees involved in litigating a dispute through arbitration is not materially lower than the attorneys' fees that would have been incurred litigating the same case in the ordinary court system.

Empirical evidence also tends to show rather powerfully, that arbitration forums in which a repeat player (typically a big business) imposes an arbitration forum on an infrequently litigant such as a consumer or employee, show a pronounced bias, relative to the Court system, in favor of the repeat litigant who had the economic power to chose the arbitration forum.

As another example, the arbitration forum is often chosen primarily to defeat the possibility of obtaining vindication through class action litigation, or to deny a litigant substantive remedies (e.g., exemplary damages may not be awarded in arbitration forums in Colorado).  In these circumstances, the appropriateness of using an arbitration clause to secure these benefits is almost always deeply problematic.

Ultimately, however, the ninety year old Federal Arbitration Act tips the balance far too strongly in favor of arbitration and does the nation a deep disservice in the process.  The scope of circumstances in which arbitration is appropriate (and a respectable share of cases that I handle in arbitration are of that type), is, however, far greater than the scope of circumstances where the FAA mandates an extremely strong policy in favor of binding pre-dispute arbitration clauses,

Devil's Night Curtailed In Detroit

DETROIT (13abc, Action News) - . . . City officials said Saturday that only 28 fires had been reported over the first two days compared to 66 at the same time in 2014. More than 3,500 people volunteered to help patrol Detroit streets this year. The campaign is a long-running response to what used to be known as Devil's Night, the day before Halloween. In 1984, Detroit had more than 800 fires during the period.
From here.

30 October 2015

Are There Any Republican Pagans?

Halloween, which is tomorrow, is derived from the traditional pagan festival day of Samhain, one of the four seasonal holidays halfway between equinoxes and solstices, together with Ground Hog Day, May Day, and Midsummer's Day.   Hence, it is a time when we think about the roots of modern practices in pagan traditions.

Earlier this week, the Republican Presidential candidates for the 2016 election had a debate in Boulder (which is a hot spot of neo-pagan practice in Colorado).

For the most part, pretty much everyone who doesn't self-identify as a Christian has a political leaning which is Democratic, unaffiliated, or third-party, because a substantial part of the Republican party favors a vision of the United States as a Christian Nation, the Establishment Clause be damned. For example, very socially conservative and quite economically conservative and anti-communist Muslims tend to identify politically with the Democratic party, because a significant share of Republican officials are openly anti-Muslim.

This tends to hold true for people who religiously identify as pagans as well, who also tend to be politically liberal or libertarian leaning and to care a lot about environmental issues, rather than socially or economically conservative.

The only really prominent conservative pagans are neo-pagan white supremacists who draw upon the Nazi regime's effort to link itself to Nordic and Germanic pagan tradition as a way to booth its nationalist appeal.

Are There Pagan Republicans?

But, are there Pagan Republicans out there in our vast and incredibly diverse nation?

The answer is yes, as this article from the 2009 election season explains.  Indeed, there are even pagan Republican political candidates:
Sexy teenage witches or nature-worshipping environmentalists, not Republican politicians, serve as our popular images of contemporary Pagans. But as fall campaigns for New York City’s City Council heat up, a Republican candidate from Queens has been forced “out of the broom closet.” Given that Republicans are typically linked with conservative Christianity, both the Neopagan community and some Republicans are a bit puzzled by Dan Halloran, who is running on Republican, Libertarian, Conservative, and Independence lines for City Council.

Halloran’s campaign Web site counters the assumption that Neopagans dress and act differently from other Americans. Photos on his official site show a clean-cut and conservatively dressed Halloran speaking out against “Obamacare,” supporting youth baseball programs and the Boy Scouts, and presenting a Police Officer of the Month Award. In contrast, the Queens Tribune story played up his alter identity as Pagan priest by running a photo from his page on the “Paganspace” Web site that shows a blue-robed Halloran kneeling before his ritual tools.

“So, who do you think is going to win that City Council race between ‘Democratic Victor’ Kevin Kim and ‘Pagan Lord’ Dan Halloran?” asked Reid Pillifant in his story in the New York Observer on September 18, 2009. A day earlier, a news story identifying Halloran as a King (priest) of Theodism, a form of Norse Paganism, ran in the Queens Tribune and attracted attention to Halloran’s unorthodox religious identity.
Now, the fact that this is happening in New York City is notable.

In national politics, the Republican party is almost extinct in most of the Northeast Corridor and New England.  At the state and local level where they remain, and among the few remaining Republicans in federal office from the region, many are more socially liberal than their GOP peers, even if they have the backs of the 1%ers on economic policy.  New York City Republicans are among the most cosmopolitan and socially liberal in the nation (albeit with an authoritarian streak when it comes to law enforcement and crime).

New York State, in particular, is also notable because candidates are permitted to identify with more than one political party at the same time on the ballot, and the political party organizations, gutted in an effort to destroy political party machine politics with Progressive reforms, are very weak there.

In a similar vein, Razib Khan, whose blog I regularly read and find thoughtful, is a politically conservative atheist.

The Political Leanings Of Religious Adherents Is Historically Contingent

Certainly, there is nothing inherently liberal about pagan religious beliefs.  We don't generally think of classical Roman political beliefs, the political beliefs of the classical Greek Spartans, the Egyptian Pharaohs, the Hittite kings, or Viking political beliefs, for example, as particularly liberal, yet all were pagan.  In our own day and age, the most prominent political party in the world associated with polytheistic religious practice, the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata party of India, is a socially conservative political party.

Similarly, most political parties with Muslim affiliations are politically conservative leaning (often in opposition to authoritarian socialist one party regimes nominally of the political left, which they oppose).  And, in China and the former Warsaw Pact countries, atheism is associated with the former Communist regime, while religious movements tend to be associated with reform movements (although the Russian ruling party is trying hard to associate itself with Orthodox Christianity).

Christians are liberal leaning in South Korea relative to other Koreans for reasons rooted in the country's post-Korean War political history that has made South Korea the most Christian country in all of Asia (at roughly 50% Christian).  Christianity attracted adherents in South Korea, in part, because Christians were important civil society actors working to oppose the right wing authoritarian regimes that prevailed in South Korea for many decades, and also because Christians had no taint of Korea's former exploitive Japanese political masters.

Something similar is the case in China, where Christians are also an opposition force that is home to many dissidents from the prevailing one party regime there.

The political leanings of Christians in the United States are also historically contingent.

Today, almost every white person who publicly identifies as Christian in a political context is conservative leaning.

But, most major religious traditions in the United States have both liberal leaning and conservative leaning denominations, the former often geographically Northern, and the latter often geographically Southern (there are also racial splits, with many Christian communities being historically black or serving predominantly immigrant populations).  These splits are present among Presbyterians, Lutherans, Baptists, and even Mormons, for example.  One round of splits took place mostly over the issue of slavery, and a second round of splits emerged more than a century later, mostly over gay rights.

For whatever reason, white Christians with left leaning political affiliations don't tend to invoke their religious views in the public square, although black and Hispanic and other immigrant religious leaders often play more prominent political roles, often from the political left and as community organizers at the grass roots.

This wasn't always the case.

The Civil Rights movement, and earlier, the Progressive movement that brought us Prohibition, fought corruption, and helped push for labor law reforms, featured prominent Christian leaders making left leaning political cases from a religious perspective.  Christians played prominent parts in both the left leaning Abolitionist movement and the conservative pro-slavery movement.  Until probably sometime after the 1950s, doing the "Christian thing" had politically liberal rather than politically conservative connotations.  It meant focusing on mercy and charity, impulses that modern political conservatives disparage as "bleeding heart liberalism".

On the other hand, the Revolutionary and Founding Fathers era of American political history, was one of the most secular periods in politics in the United States, and was also a time of very low levels of religious affiliation nationally, particularly in the American South which was the most secular part of the United States until the Second Great Awakening starting around the 1840s.

One can hope that we may someday return to an era where most religious affiliations are politically diverse.  But, at the moment, religious denominations seem to be the main contenders in the culture wars that have pitted conservative white Christians against an incredibly diverse tent made up of everyone else.

29 October 2015

The Limits of Appellate Relief

As the Arthur Anderson case makes clear, it is frequently true that the reversal of a trial court's decision on appeal is cold comfort to the party prevailing on appeal, who may suffer devastating consequences from the trial court decision that can never be fully remedied, particularly in criminal cases.